From 059cb3bbd8cd98f814cbc9e5daaf8b848a5dc568 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: thePR0M3TH3AN Date: Thu, 1 Oct 2026 02:50:35 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] TASK-console-attention-actions: triage bounded scope and preserve checker recovery waits --- .../TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json | 22 ++++-- .../TASK-console-attention-actions.json | 40 +++++++--- .../backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json | 22 ++++-- ...emaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md | 74 ++++++++++++++++++- 4 files changed, 136 insertions(+), 22 deletions(-) diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json index d4e98f0..02d25c4 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "observedAt": "7b7c6584b9d3", "feature": null, "milestone": null, - "state": "in_progress", + "state": "blocked", "owner": "project-kernel", "evidence": [ "npm run test: 195 passed", @@ -34,14 +34,17 @@ "message:bbc47b24-8135-436c-942f-f9378ada0bc9:guarded-unlanded-artifact-dependency-plan-request", "message:4eb63056-e77c-4c1e-b8f1-d742869b813e:QA-exact-additive-note-reconciliation", "reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md", - "message:9d671f19-4184-4dc0-b98f-0b0d9cb2d868:QA-exact-note-reconciliation-consent" + "message:9d671f19-4184-4dc0-b98f-0b0d9cb2d868:QA-exact-note-reconciliation-consent", + "receipt:108f3607-c9c6-4135-8f39-3b57e6accbfa:incomplete:worktree-changed-during-check", + "message:c293d46a-0e20-40cb-bdcf-1e45f434ee22:installed-checker-correction", + "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:owner-technical-routing" ], - "commit": "8350e47b0f92f7d41454a8e9a1b59e645b95eefe", + "commit": "dd62c7787737e35138cef7871489d6be1ee696c9", "integrationRequest": null, - "blockedReason": null, + "blockedReason": "Merged candidate is gate-blocked after installed alpha.2 check runtime (not candidate CLI) ran dashboard and rewrote exactly five QA-owned tracked PNGs. Dashboard exit0 receipt 108f3607-c9c6-4135-8f39-3b57e6accbfa is incomplete/worktree-changed-during-check. Preserve NEW bytes, external archive/hash and clean-before provenance; obtain NEW named QA bounded recovery disposition before any restoration. Lint unrun; no new four-gate qualification/integration. Re-entry uses explicit candidate bin/torch.mjs from canonical cwd, registered area, after approved recovery.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T23:06:51.644Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T06:26:52.642Z", - "revision": 10, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T06:44:09.098Z", + "revision": 11, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -112,6 +115,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T06:26:52.642Z", "note": "Closing read received actual QA9d671f19: QA independently inspected both merge indexes and issued exact additive reconciliation/path consent to each owner. Named peer consent wait resolved; resume SAME existing assignment to preserve complete strict local notes plus canonical generated-artifact note and remove only conflict markers/duplicates. Specialists alone finish/stage/commit own preserved merge, all four required checks on resulting clean exact candidate, independent QA/newrequest. Unmerged tree is work in progress, not qualification; Manager edits no peer files and starts no providers. Old candidates, receipts, verdicts and archive retained; wakes paused." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T06:44:09.098Z", + "note": "Actual merge finished; preserve new exact candidate and previous strict QA/receipt history. Landed isolation1a2 not shown faulty: installed alpha2 check service lacks output environment propagation, native Kernel admitted installed launcher. Native owner must archive new byte set and exact pre-clean receipts then request QA recovery for THIS candidate/path set; old4068350 approval cannot cover this incident. No peer dirty-file edits/restore/stash/gate waiver. Candidate CLI/source version explicit for all resulting checks; Release read-only activation/rollback plan pending arbiter, wakes paused." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json index 6a5af58..ebb270d 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json @@ -2,36 +2,44 @@ "schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1", "id": "TASK-console-attention-actions", "title": "Make attention findings specific, deduplicated and actionable", - "description": "Owner sees six vague attention cards: MESSAGE_BACKLOG, three indistinguishable WORKTREE_PROBLEM, ONE-DISK RECOVERABILITY and duplicate unacknowledged message count. Show human-readable problem, owning agent, branch/path, severity and actual consequence. Deduplicate the same message queue, group worktree issues by identity, distinguish normal ahead/unique commits from broken operations or unprotected work. Offer contextual quick actions when supported: owner approval/rejection with existing preview-confirm/revision/evidence checks, open exact message/thread, inspect exact worktree, request owning-agent review or retry a qualified operation. Non-owner approvals must not gain approve buttons. No generic dismiss, mass acknowledgement, automatic merge/cleanup or silent remote push. Actions must preserve drafts under refresh and report pending/error/unknown honestly.", + "description": "Owner sees six vague attention cards: MESSAGE_BACKLOG, three indistinguishable WORKTREE_PROBLEM, ONE-DISK RECOVERABILITY and duplicate unacknowledged message count. Show human-readable problem, owning agent, branch/path, severity and actual consequence. Deduplicate the same message queue, group worktree issues by identity, distinguish normal ahead/unique commits from broken operations or unprotected work. Offer contextual quick actions when supported: owner approval/rejection with existing preview-confirm/revision/evidence checks, open exact message/thread, inspect exact worktree, request owning-agent review or retry a qualified operation. Non-owner approvals must not gain approve buttons. No generic dismiss, mass acknowledgement, automatic merge/cleanup or silent remote push. Actions must preserve drafts under refresh and report pending/error/unknown honestly. Owner 9590d8b1 (2026-10-01) authorizes bounded implementation using the committed observed desktop audit findings while TASK-console-ux-audit remains blocked and incomplete. Full-audit completion is no longer an implementation-start prerequisite; actual browser desktop/mobile visual acceptance remains required before completion. Scope: separate Waiting on you (genuine authenticated owner decision with consequence/options), Fleet handling (named responsible domain and next step), and Arbiter handling (provider starts/install activation). Do not rewrite the dashboard architecture or hide unresolved risks. QA path consent is required before assignment; existing frozen assertions, ownership and verification controls remain enforced.", "priority": "high", "affectedDomains": [ "owner-console", "project-kernel", "qa" ], - "dependencies": [ - "TASK-console-ux-audit" - ], + "dependencies": [], "acceptanceCriteria": [ "Overview shows exact condition and responsible identity instead of repeated opaque codes", "Duplicate message finding is one actionable card", "Approve/reject appears only for an owner-addressed pending approval and uses current revision/evidence preview and explicit confirmation", "Worktree progress is not falsely presented as a broken repository; unsafe recovery remains visible", "Quick actions route to exact entities and cannot silently merge, acknowledge peers, publish or delete", - "Regression covers stale decision, wrong approver, duplicate findings, no available action, failure and refresh while editing" + "Regression covers stale decision, wrong approver, duplicate findings, no available action, failure and refresh while editing", + "Waiting on you contains only a genuine owner-addressed decision with evidence/options/consequence; routine domain waits show Fleet handling with responsible owner/next step; arbiter-reserved execution/install work is labelled Arbiter handling.", + "Unavailable browser and last actual visual capture remain explicit verification dependencies; source/API/scenario evidence cannot be labelled visual PASS, and final desktop/mobile acceptance remains incomplete until real browser evidence exists.", + "Implementation uses existing observed desktop audit evidence without marking the audit completed; preserve dark mode, TORCH branding, owner authority, independent QA consent and exact candidate checks." ], "observedAt": "0224abf2e08d", "feature": null, "milestone": null, - "state": "proposed", + "state": "ready", "owner": null, - "evidence": [], + "evidence": [ + "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:bounded-attention-implementation-authorized", + "owner-console:eab85dd:reports/design-system/task-console-ux-audit-owner-console-2026-09-30.md:desktop-findings-mobile-incomplete", + "approval:6d029541-3206-41f8-bdd7-eda7514f34e3:pending-QA-path-consent", + "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:bounded-implementation", + "message:bd4df0d9-6647-476a-bef0-a6c0c7b1c3aa:concrete-attention-projection-evidence", + "approval:6d029541-3206-41f8-bdd7-eda7514f34e3:pending-QA-consent" + ], "commit": null, "integrationRequest": null, "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-09-30T22:56:50.255Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-09-30T22:56:50.255Z", - "revision": 1, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T06:47:44.579Z", + "revision": 3, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -39,6 +47,20 @@ "actorId": "owner", "at": "2026-09-30T22:56:50.255Z", "note": "Task created." + }, + { + "from": "proposed", + "to": "proposed", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T06:46:37.285Z", + "note": "Explicit owner-authorized metadata amendment, not a lifecycle transition: remove full audit completion dependency for bounded attention implementation using actual existing desktop findings. Preserve blocked audit and require real final visual acceptance. Existing service exposes no metadata-amend API; reviewed Manager-owned ledger changed with expected revision1 and recorded revision2/history. No dependency gate waiver or assignment authority invented. QA6d029541 consent still pending before assignment." + }, + { + "from": "proposed", + "to": "ready", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T06:47:44.579Z", + "note": "Current briefd7e6d69 reread before exactnewitem. Canonical continueddevelopment ownerauthorization plus exact9590d8b1 permits bounded existingattention task. Metadatarev2 removes only full-audit start prerequisite; auditblockedrev5 remains unchanged, final actualdesktop/mobilevisualacceptance mandatory. OwnerConsole nextidle/cleaneab85dd/no active item. Ready for prioritization only; MUST obtain actual QA6d029541 pathconsent before assignment. Existing allcriteria/assertions/authoritycontrols retained; sourceobservability projected blockedReason ownedConsole. Arbiter controls start, no manager providerlaunch; no broadUIrewrite or scopeexpansion." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json index cfac7a8..99140a7 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ "observedAt": "d636cae93c5a", "feature": null, "milestone": null, - "state": "in_progress", + "state": "blocked", "owner": "provider-runtime", "evidence": [ "receipt:b346e435-f3e2-45f8-935d-0d4fe67dd3ea:test:pass", @@ -35,14 +35,17 @@ "reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md", "message:47308bba-aa1d-4712-b871-e7bc57aba3a6:owner-artifact-dependency-landed", "message:4eb63056-e77c-4c1e-b8f1-d742869b813e:QA-exact-additive-note-reconciliation", - "message:9d671f19-4184-4dc0-b98f-0b0d9cb2d868:QA-exact-note-reconciliation-consent" + "message:9d671f19-4184-4dc0-b98f-0b0d9cb2d868:QA-exact-note-reconciliation-consent", + "receipt:fc8da04b-76fb-4e5d-9ca9-dacfddd31332:incomplete:worktree-changed-during-check", + "message:c293d46a-0e20-40cb-bdcf-1e45f434ee22:installed-checker-correction", + "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:owner-technical-routing" ], - "commit": "5bbd81a01fa5281ee17c4b4fbafc2e58d1327f7d", + "commit": "286bfa72e3202ec0806f7c3075821c8057d6e132", "integrationRequest": null, - "blockedReason": null, + "blockedReason": "Merged candidate is gate-blocked after installed alpha.2 check runtime (not candidate CLI) ran dashboard and rewrote exactly five QA-owned tracked PNGs. Dashboard exit0 receipt fc8da04b-76fb-4e5d-9ca9-dacfddd31332 is incomplete/worktree-changed-during-check. Preserve NEW bytes, external archive/hash and clean-before provenance; obtain NEW named QA bounded recovery disposition before any restoration. Lint unrun; no new four-gate qualification/integration. Re-entry uses explicit candidate bin/torch.mjs from canonical cwd, registered area, after approved recovery.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T20:20:17.000Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T06:26:55.754Z", - "revision": 8, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T06:44:06.318Z", + "revision": 9, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -99,6 +102,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T06:26:55.754Z", "note": "Closing read received actual QA9d671f19: QA independently inspected both merge indexes and issued exact additive reconciliation/path consent to each owner. Named peer consent wait resolved; resume SAME existing assignment to preserve complete strict local notes plus canonical generated-artifact note and remove only conflict markers/duplicates. Specialists alone finish/stage/commit own preserved merge, all four required checks on resulting clean exact candidate, independent QA/newrequest. Unmerged tree is work in progress, not qualification; Manager edits no peer files and starts no providers. Old candidates, receipts, verdicts and archive retained; wakes paused." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T06:44:06.318Z", + "note": "Actual merge finished; preserve new exact candidate and previous strict QA/receipt history. Landed isolation1a2 not shown faulty: installed alpha2 check service lacks output environment propagation, native Kernel admitted installed launcher. Native owner must archive new byte set and exact pre-clean receipts then request QA recovery for THIS candidate/path set; old4068350 approval cannot cover this incident. No peer dirty-file edits/restore/stash/gate waiver. Candidate CLI/source version explicit for all resulting checks; Release read-only activation/rollback plan pending arbiter, wakes paused." } ] } diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index 3761c9d..c524c7d 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,6 +1,78 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff -## Current reconciliation at 06:27 UTC +## Current reconciliation at 06:48 UTC + +Current canonical brief still matches `d7e6d69f06a71971182f6c5944e5b1769324fb10b4c67a9b048b4633b8a6f7a8`; +read again before attention triage. Canonical is clean at landed `1a2b5b0`. +No fresh ready integration request exists. Six specialists retained: repeated +cross-domain signals and 29 hierarchy recurrences are advisory; this incident +calls for check-runtime provenance and peer routing, not another identity. +Startup backlog health had no anomalies, historical activity remains incomplete. + +**Waiting on the owner:** no current owner-addressed pending decision. Ordinary +technical recovery and path consent belong to named peers, not human relay. + +| Handling | Responsible party and next step | Evidence and actual limit | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Fleet | Runtime archives new five PNGs and pre-clean provenance, requests new QA scoped recovery | Candidate `286bfa72e3202ec0806f7c3075821c8057d6e132`; dashboard `fc8da04b-76fb-4e5d-9ca9-dacfddd31332` exit 0 **incomplete**, tree changed; lint unrun | +| Fleet | Kernel archives its new five PNGs and provenance, requests its own QA disposition | Candidate `dd62c7787737e35138cef7871489d6be1ee696c9`; dashboard `108f3607-c9c6-4135-8f39-3b57e6accbfa` exit 0 **incomplete**, tree changed; lint unrun | +| Fleet | QA decides additive attention scenario/path consent | Approval `6d029541-3206-41f8-bdd7-eda7514f34e3` pending; attention ready revision 3, unassigned until actual consent | +| Fleet | Release prepares read-only candidate installation and rollback plan | Request `ed730547-1e18-4e9c-a456-33549524e2fc`; installed alpha.2 remains active, activation not performed | +| Fleet | Kernel transports exact proposal blob and adds working TODO link | Manager author consent `25b96042-6d44-454e-a517-5d5514ba031d` for only report at commit `2c50ae6`; not entire manager commit or ledger | +| Arbiter | Resume native owners for preservation/review, then approved recovery and candidate checks; review installation plan before activation | Manager starts no providers and edits no dirty peer files; no install/wake action | + +Both strict note merges finished. Runtime task is now **blocked revision 9** and +Kernel task **blocked revision 11**, recording the actual new gate instead of old +merge consent or idle presence. Manager verified their new exact receipts: each +test/check PASS, dashboard incomplete/worktree-changed-during-check; neither has +all four qualifying gates. Each worktree has exactly the five tracked PNG changes. +Candidate source passes `TORCH_CHECK_ARTIFACT_DIR`; Kernel correction `c293d46a` +admits using installed alpha.2 launcher. Installed check service and landed source +are different runtimes. No source regression or arbitrary QA repair is established. + +Recovery requires NEW external archived bytes, manifest hashes/candidate/receipt, +exact current HEAD and public clean-before evidence, then named QA approval for +that proven set. Old `406ff` approval covered `8350` and cannot authorize either +new incident. Do not restore, stash, delete, update baselines, rerun old checker or +claim exit 0 qualifies. Only each native owner applies its approved recovery. +Afterwards all checks use explicit candidate CLI from canonical cwd, for example: + +```sh +# cwd: /home/user/Documents/GitHub/TORCH +node /home/user/TORCHWorktrees/3dc11932-6e3c-42aa-9a8a-ca7b8f818b54/provider-runtime/bin/torch.mjs checks run --id test-dashboard --area provider-runtime --yes --json +``` + +Use the corresponding Kernel path/area for Kernel and the same candidate runtime +for all four required gates. Retain engine path and exact receipts; resulting +clean commit needs independent QA/new serialized request. Installed startup tools +may remain installed by policy; that does not authorize using their old check +implementation to qualify new code. Source landing alone never updates installation. + +Owner `9590d8b1` now authorizes bounded **TASK-console-attention-actions** using +actual committed desktop audit findings. Manager amended this same task's owned +metadata at expected revision 1: removed only full-audit completion as a start +dependency, retained every old acceptance criterion, added honest handling labels +and final real visual acceptance, recorded revision/history, then triaged ready. +The audit remains blocked revision 5; no completion claim or duplicate queue. +QA consent is required before assignment. Scope is concise owner-only decisions, +named Fleet and Arbiter work, exact area/branch/path labels, deduplicated warnings, +blocked-reason projection, drafts and current approver/revision controls. Unknown +evidence stays visible; no general dashboard rewrite or authority bypass. +Concrete arbiter evidence `bd4df0d9`: doctor emits `area` while attention reads +`areaId`; duplicate message count; every unlanded integration labelled decision; +snapshot backlog projection omits `blockedReason`. Source/API evidence cannot be +called visual PASS; actual browser connection and desktop/mobile coverage remain +final acceptance gates. + +Starting-presence task remains queued after executor qualification and diagnostics +resume. Owner `89cd3b3d` observed actual running services while installed presence +still displayed stale idle. Require actual held-open CLI fixture, launch lease, +manual/timer exclusion and unknown interruption evidence, with Release/QA consent. +Automatic wakes stay paused even after terminal-executor gates pass, until this +startup boundary and an explicit safe activation decision are qualified. No +default-main, deployment, publication, spending or provider-model changes. + +## Historical reconciliation at 06:27 UTC Installed brief reread matches digest `d7e6d69f06a71971182f6c5944e5b1769324fb10b4c67a9b048b4633b8a6f7a8`. Canonical remains clean at landed `1a2b5b0`; no newer candidate/request exists.