From 13e07f8032b227e32b6c682ce1af6f8805e12da7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: thePR0M3TH3AN Date: Thu, 1 Oct 2026 11:07:22 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] TASK-6e4ff870 record concrete Phase B review and conditional peer consent --- ...emaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md | 53 +++++++++++++++++ ...date-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md | 57 ++++++++++++++++++- 2 files changed, 109 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index e39cff6..2c8bb1d 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,5 +1,58 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff +## Complete current Kernel contract review at 15:04 UTC + +Authoritative brief d7e6d69 refreshed by exact narrowly approved retry after normal +read-only SQLite refusal. Own branch starts clean547ec63. CURRENT tasks then own +addressed unread100 supplied complete Kernel **b6818413** (14:54), owner **42f9** +(15:00). Both read in full, specific peer decisions routed, then individually +acknowledged. Manager check-in refreshed; idle historical presence badges do not +prove resumed QA/Work are absent. Evolution8/hierarchy10 signals remain advisory; +retain six coherent owners and direct protocol/test consent, no hierarchy proposal +or identity/start action. Health48 stale-observation/2 dependency warnings are +review evidence, not cleanup/closure permission. Extra two Kernel source paths +were independently ownership-queried; existing six-path contract recorded. + +Proposal report now reviews b681 CandidateStore/v1 metadata/attempt/result/receipt +tables and index, short BEGIN IMMEDIATE one-row CAS, UNKNOWN retention, parent/ +private issuer/managed reader and input/fence admission. Precise remaining decisions: +executable DDL and unambiguous digest canonicalization; private fixture authority +issuance through a reachable harness composition without caller target selectors; +positive nonpromotable fixture CAS scenarios without fake native receipts; +actual input-use boundary versus wrapper byte receipt; enforceable descendant +coverage versus insufficient process-group emptiness. Unknown coverage refuses PASS, +no same-user OS containment claimed. Current initialized MCP actor/claimedIdentity +source was inspected and cannot be substituted as pure authority reader. + +Exact QA7fd/Work563/Kernel844 handoffs request current consent/protocol decisions, +not a new generic review cycle. No agreed implementation scope until actual QA +contributor consent plus Work protocol agreement; no source/tests/liveDDL/store/ +CLI/native consumer edits, new parallel assignment or provider launch. PhaseA316 +landed/pushed/nativeQA source acceptance remains resolved; full6e4verification7 +stays open. Runtimeassigned6 remains the other sole active item. Full56roadmap and +all blocked histories stay intact; c178proposed/duplicatec532unauthorized preserved, +no additional landing. Legacy2 receipts/current3vs2 refusal and pending human75 +are unchanged. Owner42 current live healthy Console observation supersedes its +sandbox curl failure, without proving installed/mobile/full acceptance. + +Actual **QA78cd** at15:04 provides CONDITIONAL six-source/three-test/TIN consent, +not actionable code permission. Conditions require byte-canonical DDL and FK +verification, reachable closure fixture harness with no selectors, framed E/S/A, +attempt/child/full-pipe proof excluding OS/semantic-use claims, PGID-only UNKNOWN +and nonpromotable fixture finalizer for positive atomic transaction scenarios. +Current PhaseA cannot supply that proof. Manager86de asks whether peer7992 copy +matches current b681; Work476 receives exact current conditions and protocol +decision request. Do not weaken full frozen-input/native consumption criterion by +calling pipe receipt actual arbitrary-check use. **Work protocol agreement remains +pending** after refreshed own unread100; no next implementation scope agreed. + +Final current-task refresh retains56 and only Workverification7/Runtimeassigned6; +canonical independently clean316. Native queue is originala178landed, duplicate +c532ready/unauthorized, oldcce needs_convergence. Current owner approval75 is still +pending1/approverowner; no activation attempt. Only local report documents were +edited through apply_patch; no tests/source/DDL execution, consumer/CLI wiring, +provider/host/runtime/wake action, task lifecycle change or another landing. + ## Final source-sync and Manager checkpoint at 14:53 UTC Actual own unread100 delivered owner548: arbiter independently inspected exact316 diff --git a/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md b/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md index 0b85631..9fa5a6f 100644 --- a/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md @@ -8,6 +8,59 @@ no new assignment, identity, queue or full-task closure is requested here. Current authoritative brief is d7e6d69. Kernel's proposed sections18/20 and ADR026 at 6fdb88ea supply design context, not normative gate changes. +## Current complete contract review: Kernel b681, 15:04 UTC + +Manager read the complete durable message **b6818413-798a-450c-ad20-dfca25f45f77** +(14:54 UTC), including all six paths, CandidateStore/v1 table definitions, +issuer/reader/parent composition, lifecycle CAS and proof admission. The earlier +959 shape discussion below is historical; current technical decisions target b681. +Current task is Work verification7 at exact316/a178 landed; native QA and permitted +development-ref source synchronization are resolved, not whole-task completion. +No code, source/test edit, registered provisioning or activation is authorized. + +The new contract specifies candidate_store_meta, candidate_attempts, +candidate_results, candidate_source_receipts and a reconciliation index; independent +E/S/A and attempt/guard/lease/fence digests; busy_timeout=0 and short BEGIN IMMEDIATE +mutations; issued -> executing -> sealed -> finalized one-row CAS; result plus +eligible receipt in one transaction; SELECT-only reconciliation. UNKNOWN retains +the open attempt and guards, never a terminal result or replay. Definition/input/ +output and artifact bounds are named. Module-private fixture authority, pure +managed metadata reader and parent-only engine composition replace the previously +unnamed seams. These are concrete progress, subject to the exact issues below. + +| Boundary | Manager review decision | Exact unresolved evidence/contract | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Executable DDL and digests | Not yet executable or uniquely canonical | Supply exact ordered CREATE TABLE/INDEX/PRAGMA statements, UTF-8/LF byte representation and a versioned length-framed or canonical envelope. Define which bytes/digests are inputs; exclude self-referential stored digest values. Pin schema_digest separately from ddl_digest, logical-state ordering and SQLite configuration. | +| SQL invariants and byte limits | Application assertions alone are insufficient evidence | SQL length(TEXT) measures characters, while stated limits are bytes. Pin enforced UTF-8 limits and null/hex/type pairing for optional schema/proof fields; cross-row result/attempt/PASS-only receipt linkage must reject forged combinations at the declared boundary. | +| Reachable private fixture issuer | Private WeakMap verification is useful, but issuance is undefined | An external harness cannot call a module-private issuer as stated. Specify a supported composition that creates its own fresh synthetic mkdtemp target, retains the private issuer, returns only bounded nonpromotable operations/attestation and rejects caller paths/registered selectors. No exported issue-from-path escape hatch. | +| Fixture positive CAS evidence | Current blanket fixture rejection leaves a positive test gap | Define a separate nonpromotable fixture-result transaction surface for valid issue/start/seal/finalize/crash scenarios, while the registered receipt adapter always refuses fixtures. No fixture native PASS or copied registered-looking fixture receipt. | +| Input read versus execution use | Wrapper hash attests byte receipt only | Pin a versioned consumer/dataflow that uses the bound immutable representation for the declared check, attempt/channel/direct-child identity binding and replay limits. An untrusted child statement, token echo or copied-byte digest cannot prove arbitrary executor use. | +| Descendant terminal coverage | Process-group emptiness is insufficient | A child can leave the group. Name an enforceable supervised execution boundary and its verifier/coverage limits; if escape prevention or complete terminal coverage is unavailable, retain UNKNOWN and refuse PASS. PID/group sampling alone cannot discharge this requirement. No same-user OS containment claim. | +| Trusted metadata composition | Initialized MCP seam cannot substitute pure reader | Actual server opens ControlPlane before assertIdentity; claimedIdentity uses that initialized instance. Pin pure launch binding validation, reader/verifier dependencies and refusal of unavailable/incompatible state without open/DDL. cwd/env are inputs to validate, not sufficient authority by themselves. | + +Manager routed exact decisions to current resumed QA **7fd57562**, Work **5638f592** +and Kernel **8446d2bb**. These are bounded decisions on b681, not a new generic +design loop or implementation assignment. QA contributor/scenario consent and Work +parent/engine protocol agreement are distinct required decisions. Until their +actual current replies, no bounded next implementation scope is recorded as agreed. +Legacy compatible schema2 receipts retain meaning and current required3/current2 +native refusal stays intact. Host/provider/wake/installation/approval75, live DDL, +CLI and existing native consumers remain excluded. Full56 backlog remains open; +idempotencyc178 is proposed and both original/duplicate integration records remain. + +Actual QA **78cdac6d-0546-472d-b8c6-de1619f9e27e** at15:04 grants conditional +scenario/path consent only for six Kernel paths, three tests and append-only TIN; +it is **not actionable consent or code authority** until byte-canonical DDL with +per-connection FK verification/no caller schema, reachable private fixture harness, +framed E/S/A, attempt/child/full-pipe proof, PGID-only UNKNOWN and closure-only +nonpromotable fixture finalization are pinned. QA excludes OS and semantic-use +claims and says current Phase A cannot PASS under the proposed protocol. Work's +current protocol agreement is separately pending. Manager requests confirmation +that QA's peer-addressed Kernel7992 copy is the same concrete b681 revision. +Byte receipt must stay visibly narrower than actual arbitrary-check input use; +the full task's frozen-input/native consumption criterion remains unproved, not +weakened by relabelling this bounded prototype. No next code scope is agreed yet. + ## Entry conditions and scope decision Work Phase A corrected candidate b1c4c26b is implemented and currently clean. @@ -30,7 +83,7 @@ assignment. Kernel's reservation125, inbox565 and inventory1e688 histories stay blocked and intact. A later Kernel implementation needs explicit sequencing; this proposal does not activate it or silently transfer the Work-led item. -## Actual read-only interface review and remaining design decisions +## Historical 959 interface shape review Kernel959d proposes protocolVersion1 APIs: @@ -75,6 +128,8 @@ and src/kernel/**, QA owns test/**. Proposed new paths are: | Attempt/result store and transaction boundary | Project Kernel | src/control-plane/candidate-attempt-store.mjs | | Authenticated E/S/A context derivation and refusal | Project Kernel | src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs | | No-DDL result finalizer/receipt adapter | Project Kernel | src/control-plane/check-receipt-adapter.mjs | +| Pure managed-install/worktree metadata reader | Project Kernel | src/kernel/managed-subject-metadata.mjs | +| Parent authority and engine composition | Project Kernel | src/kernel/candidate-source-parent.mjs | | Store/provisioner/transaction scenarios | Independent QA | test/fleet/candidate-attempt-store.test.mjs | | Subject/engine/adapter binding scenarios | Independent QA | test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs | | Finalization/replay/artifact/outcome scenarios | Independent QA | test/fleet/check-receipt-adapter.test.mjs |