diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index 49ae7e6..4887d6c 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,5 +1,126 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff +## Current evidence reconciliation and routed decisions at 13:03 UTC + +Canonical brief was read again this cycle with digest **d7e6d69**. The default +brief encountered a read-only SQLite boundary; the narrowly approved exact brief +command succeeded. No database permissions, state copy or engine switch occurred. +Current native tasks were read before the explicit addressed unread100 request; +subsequent explicit unread100 refreshes, including 13:01–13:03, returned empty. +The requested historical owner **44512241** WAL counterexample, **eca7ded3** +Overview-title decision and Kernel **b952872d** implemented API/refusal were +separately reread from the Manager's addressed history. Historical pages were +never used as unread-completeness proof. Read acknowledgements do not close waits. + +The native backlog still has **55 tasks: 38 proposed, 8 blocked, 6 completed, +2 assigned and 1 in_progress**. Runtime inbox **e440 assigned4**, Console workflow +**in_progress13** and Work source-engine design **6e4 assigned3** each retain their +existing specialist assignment. Fresh next-task lookups returned resume for all +three. The 13:02 manager check-in has no findings or named approval waits; its +idle presence rows are timestamped session observations, not task completion or +proof of process absence. No second implementation assignment was created. + +Fleet evolution measured eight recurring domain sets; hierarchy assessment +measured nine sets and eleven historical Manager coordination requests. Pending +Fleet changes were empty. The six existing specialists still have coherent +owners; exact contracts, direct peer review and bounded handoffs address the +observed friction better than another identity or hierarchy change. No domain +proposal, retirement, activation or provider start occurred. + +**Console source and focused evidence.** Owner **64ae2ea5** identified an initial +mobile viewport failure on predecessor **a97a878**. Owner **6df88358** identified +the separate dashboard approval-count selector hidden after reset. Manager read +the actual native failed outputs: **53b9271f** on **3ebfebea** fails the original +sticky-rail assertion; **cda85773** on **a97a878** times out with one open approval +present but hidden. Each has exact test/check PASS receipts, but neither has a +complete four-PASS qualification set. QA **02166e16** permits strict desktop and +390x844 initial-layout coverage; the exact reset adapter and refresh stimulus +decisions remain with QA, without changed predicates, captures or fallback. + +Owner **ae83ef12** corrects the later probe attribution: the earlier **88ed1ed** +mobile failure reused the same fragment after resizing and was not a cold load. +An actual about:blank-to-URL cold-load probe on **88ed1ed** passes Fleet selection, +focus, open details and viewport bounds (top273.359/bottom691.813 within844); +the predecessor override fails. This removes the claimed unresolved 88ed initial +cold-load failure. It is attributed independent focused evidence, not a Manager +run, native receipt, screenshot qualification or operational acceptance. + +Fresh read-only Git observation at 13:02 found Console clean at +**69ab615eba14e06b8c69018090883e3bacd9d5f6**. Manager inspected the two-path delta +from 88ed: refresh application restores its captured viewport; the test dispatches +the actual Refresh button event without Playwright scrolling that header into +view. Native **d49c2f61-2969-433f-acc2-eba51728e25c** nevertheless is **FAIL**, exit1, +invalidReason null, measurementsExecuted true: exact scroll equality fails +**347 != 167** at navigation line153. An unfinished wheel stimulus is a hypothesis, +not an accepted explanation. Manager routes this exact failure and a deterministic +strict stimulus/settlement decision to Console **694b338c** and QA **264ea20c**. +All original equality, viewport, stale-evidence, navigation, draft and preview +assertions remain required. No retries, sleeps, relaxed bounds or snapshot changes +are authorized. Fresh final source gates, independent QA, guarded integration and +separate actual live desktop/mobile acceptance remain open. + +Owner **1444787c** subsequently confirms actual active Console/Manager units; +live4174 alpha2 still reports healthy plus120 unread and stale idle presence. +This reinforces the existing attention/presence criteria, not an owner obligation +or proof of idle work. Its attributed predecessor d993/95ec7424 result is +231PASS/1FAIL/5SKIP with the same347-versus167 scroll counterexample. Manager +routes the exact proposed instant numeric scroll or actual scroll-event completion +variant before non-scrolling Refresh dispatch to QA **700bc99d** and Console +**532da794**. Precise QA consent and a deterministic correction remain open; +read acknowledgement does not resolve that test decision or the native failure. + +**Kernel implemented source versus native qualification.** The exact observeMessages +implementation at **a4bba018** exists; the WAL/leading-whitespace mutation-killing +proof correction has narrow independent owner and QA acceptance. The original +44512241 raw state.db comparison missed WAL writes, which was a test-signal gap, +not evidence that the actual SELECT implementation writes. Kernel task **565fa463 +blocked7** retains its full history and candidate. Its stored 'QA pending' clause +is historical: actual narrow QA acceptance now exists. The genuine current source +ControlPlane3 versus registered2 refusal occurs before execution and produces no +qualified native receipt. No missing-API, missing-test-consent or full acceptance +claim replaces that boundary; neither fixtures nor prose waive it. + +**Proposed source-qualification protocol.** Manager read Kernel's exact clean +**1e27766f278d443e640de9e3ba60b43ce96b9e7a** proposed-only refinement of spec +sections18/20 and additive ADR026. Work is design lead on its existing assigned3; +Kernel is the named two-document contributor, not a second active implementation. +QA's actual lifecycle/schema review **02166e16** exists. Source engine E, product +subject S and receipt authority A must have separate exact provenance; product +storage metadata is not the adapter's required control-plane schema. Initial CLI +subject derives from authenticated registered area and clean managed worktree, +without caller selection flags. Current normative policy and native gates stand. + +Owner **03fc1c55** requires two corrections before a code plan: name the affected +Kernel3 candidate instead of implying every source CLI requires3; distinguish +UNKNOWN/unproven execution, which retains guards and forbids replay, from proven +terminal FAIL/INCOMPLETE, which may perform scoped cleanup under existing owned +policy after independent descendant and durable-outcome proof. Cleanup is separate +from PASS eligibility; no elapsed-time inference or force unlock. The first routing +attempt returned automatic-review text without a TORCH receipt; its reason was +not captured and delivery was not assumed. A safe bounded design-only retry +produced **84767292**, then Work **e10d2947**, QA **914f8951**, Release **a76fb146** +received the exact correction. No rejected action or enforcement guard was bypassed. +Other actual protocol handoffs are Work **e2c44df3**, Release **7bfc2bc1** and +Kernel **ff9cf6c4**. Revised draft, exact lifecycle/store/confinement/artifact/ +reconciliation contracts, Release presentation and future code/test/policy consent +remain open before implementation. A proposed document is not governing policy. + +**Sequenced dormant-service phases.** After supported inbox qualification and +Runtime's existing e440 wrapper, Kernel inventory **1e688a36 blocked4** needs the +exact pure inventory export/digest contract and QA/source qualification. Runtime +dormant-plan **2b4a6ab5 proposed1** follows qualified inventory, without a second +Runtime assignment. Release persistent-operations then consumes both qualified +APIs for source preview/provision scenarios. Its old additive-test permission hold +was resolved; actual APIs and source/operational gates remain. Full roadmap, +reservation/schema blocked histories and owner-only upgrade wait are preserved. + +Canonical was independently clean at **0fdfcb3b**; Kernel was clean at **1e27766f**. +No final acceptance, new source implementation, automatic wakes, installation +switch, live schema recovery, host activation, extra identities or provider launches +occurred. Latest five-PNG consent remains limited to completed exact Runtime +recovery and cannot authorize the pending runtime upgrade or live schema recovery. + + ## Latest mobile viewport counterexample at 12:35 UTC Final current-task then explicit unread100 refresh reads actual owner **560e62bf**: