From 66125e6c4f2918d92060d3582ea8560896bc5efb Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: thePR0M3TH3AN Date: Thu, 1 Oct 2026 10:51:16 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] TASK-6e4ff870 record exact Phase A landing and proposed Phase B handoff --- ...-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json | 39 +++- ...-c178b387-dc7f-4392-b7ba-9bbc894070db.json | 41 ++++ .../TASK-console-attention-actions.json | 19 +- ...emaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md | 168 ++++++++++++++ ...date-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md | 206 ++++++++++++++++++ 5 files changed, 462 insertions(+), 11 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .torch/backlog/TASK-c178b387-dc7f-4392-b7ba-9bbc894070db.json create mode 100644 reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json index e65f6f5..adfb24a 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ "observedAt": "cb145e56cb7d530f9563b98d4f9920ff0372a67a", "feature": "Check execution provenance and state isolation", "milestone": "Reviewed reliability dependencies", - "state": "in_progress", + "state": "verification", "owner": "work-integration", "evidence": [ "message:28f03fa6-ff6e-4af8-87e0-631218f1ec55:owner-bounded-design-document-phase", @@ -39,14 +39,27 @@ "message:a9d35980-8bb7-410e-803a-8e882d041c2e:actual-implemented-Phase-A-candidate-local-checks-not-native", "message:f1a17c3c-5b7e-42c1-918b-06102a865340:independent-current-source-boundary-defects", "message:e3027336-9254-4f3b-bd40-eaf4ef8ca5bb:QA-current-994-draft-NOT-ACCEPTED-exact-same-scope-additive-corrections", - "message:39da248a-96e7-4a05-832f-5ca749a70a96:same-assignment-corrective-handoff-no-duplicate" + "message:39da248a-96e7-4a05-832f-5ca749a70a96:same-assignment-corrective-handoff-no-duplicate", + "message:7680e7b8-7430-467a-ac0f-4f931123abf6:corrected-local-Phase-A-b1-not-converged-native", + "message:1b804536-b7c8-4a0c-abf4-bef32ce288f9:QA-narrow-b1-source-accepted-13focused-excludes-childconsumption-OSsandbox-atomic-directory", + "message:a69aec7b-e4cc-42cd-98be-0ea64eca0c27:actual-fivePNG-command-provenance-no-archive-no-intermediatehashes", + "message:10f29671-89b1-4df9-8fc7-73d0cd5658f1:guarded-convergence-resulting-exact-native-gates-request", + "message:0e95d68f-05b5-4475-8c3c-d2c32c5e687d:actual-converged316-native4PASS", + "message:c841b139-adea-4b06-877e-cb4c750c04f3:QA-exact316-source/nativegate-accepted-11verifiedPNG-not10", + "integration:a1789e46-b91e-496c-9204-ab204dac6a6d:landed316:2026-10-01T14:44:26.747Z", + "receipt:b524193a-58f5-411e-be73-ff4517e84a0f:exact316-test-PASS", + "receipt:c252b84c-64dc-416d-8130-d581ea939419:exact316-check-PASS", + "receipt:d0981f67-deee-4016-a65d-cba1212198eb:exact316-dashboard-PASS-11PNG", + "receipt:ddc79b34-c400-4a2e-8b36-c9fd7f352b8f:exact316-lint-PASS", + "integration:c5328d31-30f3-473d-9b4d-fab80220012a:duplicate-ready-unauthorized-native-evaluate14:45-preserved-not-landed", + "message:959d86f6-fb73-4ed3-a220-9d11f68b24db:PhaseB-readonly-contract-review-missing-issuer/reader/DDL/CAS-nocodeconsent" ], - "commit": "9946a2a3e49fd777ff06d3905e32ae0dbc43b2ed", - "integrationRequest": null, + "commit": "316d8b7480c2e10925ebdff8310fe26ef5a881a8", + "integrationRequest": "a1789e46-b91e-496c-9204-ab204dac6a6d", "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:14:01.401Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T14:09:12.927Z", - "revision": 5, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T14:46:56.262Z", + "revision": 7, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -82,6 +95,20 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T14:09:12.927Z", "note": "Record actual commenced Phase A implementation on SAME assigned4, not readiness/acceptance/task completion. Worka9 reports clean994/new two source modules/two scenario files/additive TIN and local checks, but actual ownerf1/d896 and QAe302 reject UTF8 byte cap, syntax-only env validation, missing timeout/immutable-input and root/manifest link/read/canonicalization gaps. Continuing exact same scoped corrective implementation under QA additive direction; native receipts/independent corrected acceptance and later phases remain unqualified. Preserve full criteria/owner/history/unique commits and every schema/native guard. Canonicale8 advanced; guarded clean convergence/fresh exact checks before any request. No wiring/store/schema/consumer/gate/lease/install/live/host/provider/wake action." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "verification", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T14:29:54.685Z", + "note": "SAME Phase A corrected candidate now in verification after actual QA1b804 narrow source/test acceptance and artifact incident classification. Keep994 rejection/all history/full criteria; 13 hermetic local PASS does not qualify native receipts, actual childinputconsumption/OSsandbox/concurrentdirectorylocking. Worka69 reports exact toolapproved five-pathrestore14:15:19 and explicitly no archive/intermediate dirty hashes; QA independently currentclean and overwrite mechanism only, no history fabrication/old286reuse. Nativeguardedconvergencecanonicale8 underway; resultingexactSHA fresh4sourcegates, independentresultingcommitQA/newrequest remain. FullTASK6e4 and laterstore/context/adapter/nativeoperational phases incomplete. No parallelassignment/wiring/schema/provisioner/host/install/provider/wake/fixturepromotion." + }, + { + "from": "verification", + "to": "verification", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T14:46:56.262Z", + "note": "Reviewed metadata-only amendment at expectedrev6; native service lacks metadata amend. Actual guarded clean316 convergence, QA c841 exact bounded PhaseA source/nativegate ACCEPT and 11 verified PNGs (correct Work10), four exact current-definition PASS receipts and original a178 native landed14:44:26 recorded. Request creation14:32 preceded QA14:36; authorization14:44 followed verdict. Full state remains verification, not ready/fulltaskcomplete; owner/fullcriteria/dependencies/all earlierhistory/b1/994rejection/oldcce preserved. Later duplicatec532 stillready/unauthorized after nativeevaluate; no secondland/manualstate/delete. Prototype does not establish childinputconsumption/OScontainment/atomic snapshot/native adapter receipt wiring/operational acceptance. PhaseB read-only API review requires exactpureissuer/reader/fullDDL/CAS/scenarios/QAconsent before code; no newassignment/store/schema/installation/host/provider/wake activation." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-c178b387-dc7f-4392-b7ba-9bbc894070db.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-c178b387-dc7f-4392-b7ba-9bbc894070db.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0f2cbd1 --- /dev/null +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-c178b387-dc7f-4392-b7ba-9bbc894070db.json @@ -0,0 +1,41 @@ +{ + "schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1", + "id": "TASK-c178b387-dc7f-4392-b7ba-9bbc894070db", + "title": "Make exact integration requests atomic and idempotent across concurrent handoffs", + "description": "Owner e40b3de2 measured14:42 duplicate incident: a178(14:32) and c532(14:40) same project/area/branch/exact316/basee8/definitions ready unauthenticated. Root orchestration contributed by requesting submission before discovery and crossing later use-existing warning; do not attribute solely specialist failure. Original a178 subsequently native landed; c532 remains ready/unauthorized after native evaluation, oldcce unchanged. Preserve every audit record. Propose Work-owned atomic get-or-create request identity and supported duplicate disposition; not same mechanism as proposed approval-atomic20. No parallel implementation, manual DB/state patch, queue-force, lost audit/unique commits or gate/lease weakening. Existing PhaseA stays verification; new work proposed only.", + "priority": "high", + "affectedDomains": [ + "work-integration", + "qa" + ], + "dependencies": [ + "TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e" + ], + "acceptanceCriteria": [ + "Versioned atomic get-or-create identity binds project, source area/branch/exact commit, target branch/base and required-check definition tuple; identical requests return the same audited ID.", + "Deterministic competing-process boundary scenarios prove exactly one actionable request; every attempted handoff remains auditable without dropped record, forged authority, changed lease/resource guard or weakened exact source checks.", + "Distinct target/base/definitions and retry after rejection require explicitly versioned new attempt semantics; supported superseded/already-integrated disposition preserves both histories and prevents duplicate landing.", + "Original a178/c532/cce incident history and root-orchestration contribution remain; independently qualify supported native API behavior before any cleanup/disposition, never direct DB delete/patch or queue force." + ], + "observedAt": "316d8b7480c2e10925ebdff8310fe26ef5a881a8", + "feature": "Serialized integration integrity", + "milestone": "Incident-backed reliability follow-up", + "state": "proposed", + "owner": null, + "evidence": [], + "commit": null, + "integrationRequest": null, + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-01T14:49:54.703Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T14:49:54.703Z", + "revision": 1, + "history": [ + { + "from": null, + "to": "proposed", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T14:49:54.703Z", + "note": "Task created." + } + ] +} diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json index 6e44fc3..d3e973f 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json @@ -24,7 +24,8 @@ "Presence rows show timestamped source/freshness/unknown evidence; a last idle heartbeat is never presented as verified current process absence.", "Unacknowledged message attention is classified by actual recipient, routine peer coordination versus genuine owner decision, and age; aggregate backlog counts do not make the owner responsible for every message, and no suppression or mass acknowledgement occurs.", "Timer/process/presence disagreements link exact observed evidence, the existing task and responsible domain without silently resolving or activating services.", - "Before publishing a final blocked/waiting-on-approval/needs-owner report, refresh authoritative unread inbox, current named permission and task evidence; distinguish a timestamped earlier observation from current state and reconcile already-resolved routine waits without asking the owner again. A mechanical observation-watermark/status protocol, if needed, requires an owned reviewed proposal before schema/API implementation." + "Before publishing a final blocked/waiting-on-approval/needs-owner report, refresh authoritative unread inbox, current named permission and task evidence; distinguish a timestamped earlier observation from current state and reconcile already-resolved routine waits without asking the owner again. A mechanical observation-watermark/status protocol, if needed, requires an owned reviewed proposal before schema/API implementation.", + "Given the measured14:18 doctor healthytrue/56warnings with48 stale-SHA findings,49-task activity warning and only1 ownerpending activation, attention explicitly separates actionable owner decisions, Fleet-owned exceptions and advisory recheck cohorts with measured counts. Deduplicate/collapse repeated stale-commit cohorts with per-task/current-owner/current-reproduction drilldown while retaining every observedAt recheck requirement, unsafe recovery warning and pending owner approval. Dirty active implementations and unique commits are evidence, never automatic owner cleanup requests; do not suppress findings, auto-close or acknowledge peers." ], "observedAt": "0224abf2e08d", "feature": null, @@ -58,14 +59,15 @@ "receipt:558d8598-0332-49eb-9296-9f68b5880604:correct-check-id-preserved;prior-revision7-transcription-49aa-is-not-a-receipt", "message:799d0275-c113-45cd-a0cb-06ca78f9c71f:land-code-retain-visual-blocker", "message:25e645bf-db6a-4df8-9107-3b82f15e27d8:incident-backed-presence-health-message-classification-criteria", - "message:22df881a-9d38-4706-b0bf-da05c6b674c8:Console12:22-stale-QA-wait-after12:19-consent" + "message:22df881a-9d38-4706-b0bf-da05c6b674c8:Console12:22-stale-QA-wait-after12:19-consent", + "message:6a402108-28bb-40b8-a6f7-6fd49184f85e:measured14:18-56warnings-48stale-49taskactivity-vs1ownerpending-categorization" ], "commit": "cb145e56cb7d530f9563b98d4f9920ff0372a67a", "integrationRequest": "9b39e0f8-3ff9-44c5-8b03-9f7d7bdc524b", "blockedReason": "Source cb145e56 landed through guarded integration after four exact PASS receipts and independent QA f21b0c38/eb5a356c/all11 artifact hashes. Actual live desktop/mobile browser acceptance remains unavailable and required for full completion; generated artifacts are not visual PASS. Preserve old75afe INCOMPLETE/lost history and current owner/candidate/receipts.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T22:56:50.255Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T12:27:23.922Z", - "revision": 10, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T14:30:04.270Z", + "revision": 11, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -107,7 +109,7 @@ "to": "verification", "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T09:06:56.870Z", - "note": "Actual exactclean cb145 whitespace-repairedcandidate/fourfreshPASS/noinvalidReason independentlyread. Same item enters namedQA7a69 exactcandidate/11externalartifactreview; all strictgates/old75afeINCOMPLETE/losthistoryretained. Actualdesktop/mobilevisualacceptance remainsmissing—not waived by functionalreceipts, generatedscreenshots or sourceonlyevidence. No request/landing/fullcompletion inferred; no unrelated UIrewrite or testsweakened." + "note": "Actual exactclean cb145 whitespace-repairedcandidate/fourfreshPASS/noinvalidReason independentlyread. Same item enters namedQA7a69 exactcandidate/11externalartifactreview; all strictgates/old75afeINCOMPLETE/losthistoryretained. Actualdesktop/mobilevisualacceptance remainsmissing\u2014not waived by functionalreceipts, generatedscreenshots or sourceonlyevidence. No request/landing/fullcompletion inferred; no unrelated UIrewrite or testsweakened." }, { "from": "verification", @@ -136,6 +138,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T12:27:23.922Z", "note": "Owner22df explicitly requests existing-item incident/requirement recording. Reviewed metadata-only amendment preserves current state, owner, candidate, dependencies, prior criteria and every historical wait. No lifecycle transition, new assignment, wrapper/API/schema contract implementation, autoapproval or mass acknowledgement. Fresh final-status observation is required; any mechanical protocol stays an owned reviewed proposal." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T14:30:04.270Z", + "note": "Explicit owner6a402 requests append-only measured attention criterion/evidence on SAME existing item after fresh currentbrief. Reviewed metadata only; expectedrevision10, original14criteria/owner/state/candidate/integration/dependencies/history preserved. No implementationassignment, healthautofix/warningsuppression/cleanup/newtask or lifecycletransition. Source/backend/livevisual qualification remain separately open; Managerledger service lacks metadataamend operation." } ] } diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index 944f6dd..7efcb59 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,5 +1,173 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff +## Incident-backed intake at 14:50 UTC + +Actual ownere40 attributes duplicate request incident partly to root orchestration: +submission requested before existing request discovery and crossing later warning; +not solely specialist failure. After current brief reread and actual owned-path +query, one native **TASK-c178b387-dc7f-4392-b7ba-9bbc894070db** was created proposed/ +unassigned for Work integration-request atomic idempotency and supported audited +duplicate disposition, separate from approval-atomic20. No parallel code assignment. +Prior55 roadmap retained; now56 =39proposed/9blocked/6completed/1assigned/1verification. +Fleet evolution refreshed after intake; ownership/process/scenario correction is +appropriate, no role creation/activation. Duplicatec532 remains ready/unauthorized, +not silently cancelled/deleted or landed twice; concrete Work handoff retains wait. + +## Exact Phase A landing and current handoffs at 14:46 UTC + +Actual own unread100 delivered Work0e95/f098, Kernel959d, QAc841 and owner27/81; +read individually and routed before acknowledgement. QA c841 ACCEPTS exact clean +**316d8b7480c2e10925ebdff8310fe26ef5a881a8** for bounded Phase A source/native-gate +qualification: merge parents b1+e8; exactly five approved paths versus e8; both +parents' append-only TIN preserved; all13 focused scenarios in native test output; +four current-definition native PASS/exit0/invalidReason null. Dashboard d098 has +**11 unique regular PNGs**, independently byte/SHA verified including pilot-review, +correcting Work0e95's 10 count. Historical five-PNG restore attribution remains +no archive/no intermediate bytes; 994 rejected. Source review is resolved, not an +owner wait or proof of child consumption/OS containment/atomic directory snapshot. + +Current queue contained original **a1789e46-b91e-496c-9204-ab204dac6a6d** created +14:32:01 and duplicate **c5328d31-30f3-473d-9b4d-fab80220012a** created14:40:09 for +identical316/e8. Manager created no request and used the earlier request. Creation +preceded QA14:36; authorization followed QA at14:44:07. Native evaluate ready, +native authority succeeded, native plan blockers[]/canProceed true, native land +**14:44:26.747**. Canonical independently clean316. No manual Git landing, +queue reorder, self-source acceptance, gate waiver or native-schema fallback. +Duplicate native reevaluation14:45 stillreports READY/unauthorized; preserve it +without second authority/land/delete. Work receives exact duplicate/idempotency +process handoff, no new implementation assignment. Older cce needs_convergence +unchanged. Full Work remains **verification7** by reviewed metadata-only amendment, +actual316/a178 recorded while every full criterion/owner/history/b1/994 is retained. +Do not close full source-qualification protocol from Phase A source landing. + +Kernel959 read-only review provides proposed provisionFixtureCandidateAttemptStoreV1, +deriveCheckSubjectContextV1 and FinalizeV1 shapes. Its new pure authenticated issuer/ +verifier/managed clean-subject reader are explicitly missing; owner27 identifies +existing actorId/claimedIdentity seam as initialized-CP-dependent. FullDDL/CAS/API +lifecycle and actual child-input/terminal/descendant/seal admission proofs still +need concrete peer review. QA c841 grants NO PhaseB contributor/code/test consent. +Proposal report now records actual shapes and precise remaining design work; +Kernel/QA/Work/Release receive bounded read-only contract/scenario handoffs, not +owner implementation-detail waits or code/store/DDL authorization. + +E8 remote sync is verified, not proof of new316 remote sync. Release9ae receives +actual316 postlanding read-only provenance/remote-boundary handoff for arbiter-only +bounded nonforce existing developmentref push; Manager makes no competing push. +Pending alpha3owner75, native adapter/receipt wiring and actual connected-browser/ +installed/mobile/full Console criteria remain. Full55 roadmap/counts unchanged: +38proposed/9blocked/6completed/1assigned/1verification. No new identity/provider +launch/automatic wake/installation/live schema/host activation or fixture promotion. + +## Corrected source acceptance, remote verified and Phase B proposal at 14:33 UTC + +Fresh currentbrief **d7e6d69** read through exact approved retry after ordinary +readonly-database failure; Manager starts clean75ca263. CURRENT all55 task evidence +preceded explicit own addressed unread100. Actual owner23d3, Release7f605, +Work7680/a69, owner9f888/6a402/135a/66e70, QA1b804 and selfcheck-inf111 were read, +routed and individually acknowledged after understanding. Check-in refreshed on +startup and after the scheduled own message; actual pending findings were routed, +no read acknowledgement was treated as resolution. Evolution8/hierarchy10 signals, +changes none: retain six coherent specialists with explicit contracts/phase +sequencing. Health48 stale-observation/2 resolved-dependency warnings are advisory; +no auto-fix, duplicate queue, suppression or identity activation. + +**Current corrected Phase A and restoration truth.** Clean Work +**b1c4c26b1b517312f4f42b7db2e95ed8b6cd06ac** supersedes9946 for review only. Manager +inspected the exact same5path corrective diff, source bounds/allowlist/copied-byte +hash and regular-file manifest code; actual7680 reports local13focused/full +test208PASS/5intentionalSKIP/check/dashboard/lint PASS, not native receipts. +Exact native receipt lookup atb1 was empty. Actual owner23 resolves the original +focused cap/env repro only. QA **1b804** independently narrowly ACCEPTS b1 after +7+6 named hermetic scenarios; 9946 remains rejected. Explicit exclusions remain: +engine attests copied bytes, executor receives cwd, so actual child input +consumption/OS containment are not proved; wx/verify detect ordinary drift but do +not lock a concurrent-writer atomic directory snapshot. No whole-task, native or +operational acceptance follows. Future adapter eligibility must reject missing +applicable input/terminal/descendant/seal proof rather than substitute this summary. + +Owner9f888's new five-PNG dirty observation was not old286 consent. User's current +launch reports the completed exact14:15:19 restoration, Work **a69** names actual +plain npm run test:dashboard generator on unconvergedb1 and tool-approved git +restore of only activity-review/check-evidence/operation-outcomes/owner-briefing- +desktop/mobile PNGs; no source/assertion restore. Work explicitly states **NO +archive and NO intermediate mutated PNG hash set**. Current baseline blob IDs: +activity5155b8fbdd1e75a56bb9c0188384878c8f5fb21a, +check094e4f46dc48ce38dfff8da0fe0ca02810eae1d2, +operation96dbc5a3deadd356ec363025ac853364c3073893, +desktope67a2e03e9eebd1092446ef8ae2b7a9600300d9f, +mobile2315501dc73d33b7550421a595bdab9a9c41657f. +QA independently sees those exact five clean versusb1 and identifies script default +reports/design-system when TORCH_CHECK_ARTIFACT_DIR is absent. It did not restore, +archive/hash dirty bytes or prove time/toolpermission from Git. Preserve that +command-history attribution and QA proof limit; no invented archive, repeated +restore, old approval reuse or native dirty-run qualification. + +SAME Work **in_progress5 -> verification6** records b1 narrow review/classification, +full criteria/owner/history/994 rejection retained. Concrete Work **10f29671** asks +native guarded clean convergence tocanonicale8, resulting exact commit fresh4 +native source checks with artifact isolation/actual candidate CLI provenance, +independent resulting-commit QA/new exact request. No old receipt/frozen checker/ +fixture/schema fallback. Mid-observation staged changes were Work's active owned +convergence, not Manager cleanup authority. Owner66 reports only append-only TIN +merge conflict preserving both sides. Latest Manager reads Work **clean316d8b7480c2e10925ebdff8310fe26ef5a881a8**; +Fresh exact316 native receipts **b524193a test,c252b84c check,d0981f67 dashboard, +ddc79b34 lint** are all PASS/invalidReason null. Exact resulting-commit independent +QA/provenance verdict and new request are still separately required; source checks +of a prototype do not qualify its ability to create registered receipts. No +Manager peer branch edit or provider launch occurred. + +**Exact source synchronization resolved.** Release **7f605** verified e8 exact +current-definition native fourPASS and landed6cb, while pointing out rows lack a +separate CLI-engine SHA and remote DNS initially prevented verification. Actual +QA1b804 reverified11artifact hashes and accepts the unchanged exact subject/ +definitions after landing; no gratuitous rerun required. Owner **135a** inspected +PUBLIC exact candidate bin/torch source invocation commands13:40:45/13:41:32/ +13:41:50/13:42:18, rechecked clean canonical/remote0fdf/ancestry, executed only +approved nonforce **e8:refs/heads/rewrite/portable-agent-fleet** push to existing +origin, exit0. Actual owner **66e70** confirms postpush remote exacte8; Manager's +independent read-only **git ls-remote** also returns full +**e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891** for that sole development ref. Source +sync is resolved, no duplicate push/false owner wait/new remote/main/legacy or +publication claim. Current canonical remains clean e8; native6cb landed and +old Workcce needs_convergence unchanged. Actual owner activation75 independently +refreshed **pending1/approver owner**; live/browser/installed acceptance remains +separate from source push and completed exact Runtime PNG recovery. + +**Concrete proposed next phase.** Manager authored +`reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md`, with live +ownership verified for4Kernel newmodules and3QA newtests. Proposed B0 fixture-only +provisioner/schema qualification, B1 authenticated side-effect-free E/S/A context +reader, B2 attempt/result store and no-DDL atomic CAS/finalizer all require exact +API/DDL/identity/compatibility contracts and named QA contributor/scenario consent. +No currentControlPlaneinitializer/nativeconsumer/exactPasses change, live DDL, +registeredstore, CLI wiring, provider start or operational activation. Actual +owner66 readfull proposal/agrees isolateddirection and resumed EXISTING Kernel +read-only --pin-phase-b-contract review only; no code/docs/test/state edit/newtask. +Kernel **7fcc39e3** receives concrete proposal and authority boundary; QA/Release +receive bounded contract review requests. Actual child consumption, parent +terminal/descendant fence and seal proof are native receipt prerequisites, not +inferred from Phase A metadata. Legacy schema2 receipts and be1required3/current2 +refusal remain. Kernel blocked inbox/reservation/inventory and full55 roadmap +remain intact; future assignment requires explicit reviewed scope/fresh brief/next. + +**Measured owner attention criterion, not dispatch.** After separately refreshing +current brief, explicit owner **6a402** request appended strict measured14:18 +criterion/evidence to SAME attention **blocked10 -> blocked11**, preserving all +prior14criteria/owner/candidate/history. Healthydoctor56warnings/48stale-SHA/ +49taskactivity versus1actualownerpending must separate owner action, Fleet-owned +exception and advisory cohorts; collapse/deduplicate with per-item current owner/ +reproduction drilldown while retaining observedAt guards, unsafe unknowns and +approval truth. No dirty-work/unique-commit cleanup request, silence, auto-close or +mass ack. Console **c74ae855** receives later-phase direction, not newassignment. + +Current55 remain38proposed/9blocked/6completed/1assigned/1verification; Runtime6 +and Work6 are the sole active items. Open concrete handoffs: resulting316 independent +QA/provenance/newrequest, Kernel exact PhaseB contracts and consent, actual +connected-browser/live Console acceptance. Source review/sync are resolved, genuine +alpha3human decision is unchanged. No wakes, installation/schema/host action, +extra identity, provider launch, manual Git landing or fixture promotion. + + ## Exact convergence and rejected Phase A draft at 14:08 UTC Manager checkpoint **24e4a40** recorded actual Console source landing. Native diff --git a/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md b/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0b85631 --- /dev/null +++ b/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md @@ -0,0 +1,206 @@ +# Proposed Phase B: authenticated candidate context and receipt adapter + +Status: proposal reviewed by arbiter66e70; isolated direction agreed, concrete +contracts and consent still pending. No implementation or activation authority. +The arbiter resumed existing Kernel read-only contract review only. +This is a phase of existing TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e; +no new assignment, identity, queue or full-task closure is requested here. +Current authoritative brief is d7e6d69. Kernel's proposed sections18/20 and +ADR026 at 6fdb88ea supply design context, not normative gate changes. + +## Entry conditions and scope decision + +Work Phase A corrected candidate b1c4c26b is implemented and currently clean. +QA1b804 narrowly accepts 13 focused hermetic scenarios and classifies the separate +five-PNG incident without an archive/dirty-byte claim. Local full checks remain +development evidence. Guarded convergence to canonicale8c4c424 produced clean316d8b74. +Four fresh native PASS receipts and independent QAc841 exact source/native-gate +acceptance now exist; native originala178 landed that exact source at14:44:26. +Source entry evidence is resolved; full task and operational proof remain open. +Narrow acceptance excludes actual child input consumption, OS containment and a +concurrent-writer atomic directory snapshot; those are explicit future proof gaps. Preserve +9946 rejection, all current/old receipts, actual restoration command history and +old cce needs_convergence. No archive is claimed without actual evidence. + +Recommendation: approve only a Kernel-owned hermetic implementation trial after +those entry conditions and the exact interfaces/tests below are accepted. +Review B0, B1 and B2 separately; decline or revise any unresolved contract before +code. Manager must reread current brief and next-task selection before an actual +assignment. Kernel's reservation125, inbox565 and inventory1e688 histories stay +blocked and intact. A later Kernel implementation needs explicit sequencing; +this proposal does not activate it or silently transfer the Work-led item. + +## Actual read-only interface review and remaining design decisions + +Kernel959d proposes protocolVersion1 APIs: + +- `provisionFixtureCandidateAttemptStoreV1({fixtureAuthority,fixtureIdentity,canonicalSchemaDefinition})` + resolves one fresh synthetic temporary store through trusted fixture authority, + never a caller path. Immutable `FixtureStoreAttestation` includes fixtureIdentity, + protocolVersion, schemaVersion, schemaDigest, ddlDigest, preStateDigest, + postStateDigest and nonpromotable:true. Registered/preexisting/drift stores refuse. +- `deriveCheckSubjectContextV1({parentAuthority})` returns immutable E/S/A, with + no caller area/check/root/commit/manifest/DB/adapter selector. Existing + resolveInstalledProjectRoot/readInstallManifest are only read primitives. +- `FinalizeV1({finalizerAuthority,attemptRef,expectedTupleDigest,terminalProof,artifactManifest})` + derives its compatible store internally and performs sealed-to-finalized CAS, + ResultRecord and eligible receipt in one transaction; no caller writer/store. + +These are proposed shapes, not implementation-ready authority contracts. The +RegisteredSubjectAuthorityV1 issuer/verifier and pure managed-worktree/clean-source +binding reader do not exist and must be concretely pinned in the proposed Kernel +check-subject-context module, or name an additional owned path before code. +Owner27 identifies current MCP server actorId/ControlPlane.assertIdentity and tools +claimedIdentity as the initialized-parent boundary; they depend on ControlPlane and +cannot substitute the new side-effect-free seam or prove same-user OS containment. +Kernel must pin full CandidateStorev1 DDL, lifecycle/CAS states, bounded envelopes, +single-use finalizer authority and issue/start/seal/finalize/read-only reconcile APIs. + +QA c841 explicitly grants **no Phase B contributor/code/test consent**. Kernel, +Work, Release and QA resolve these routine interface/scenario details directly; +no additional owner product decision is required merely to name pure interfaces. +Admission must reject absent actual child immutable-input consumption, attributable +parent terminal/descendant fence or artifact seal proof. Fixture attestations never +produce native PASS. Exact contracts and named QA consent precede any later code +scope decision; this report grants none. + +## Exact contributor map proposed for review + +Live ownership queries on 2026-10-01 confirm Kernel owns src/control-plane/** +and src/kernel/**, QA owns test/**. Proposed new paths are: + +| Proposed responsibility | Primary implementer | Exact new path | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Fixture-only provisioner, schema compatibility inspection | Project Kernel | src/control-plane/candidate-attempt-store-provisioner.mjs | +| Attempt/result store and transaction boundary | Project Kernel | src/control-plane/candidate-attempt-store.mjs | +| Authenticated E/S/A context derivation and refusal | Project Kernel | src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs | +| No-DDL result finalizer/receipt adapter | Project Kernel | src/control-plane/check-receipt-adapter.mjs | +| Store/provisioner/transaction scenarios | Independent QA | test/fleet/candidate-attempt-store.test.mjs | +| Subject/engine/adapter binding scenarios | Independent QA | test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs | +| Finalization/replay/artifact/outcome scenarios | Independent QA | test/fleet/check-receipt-adapter.test.mjs | + +QA must name any contributor exception before Kernel touches tests and must +approve an append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md destination. Existing source files, +ControlPlane initializer/schema guard, CLI/bin, Work CheckService/conditions, +resources, Integration exactPasses, Backlog, Delivery, config and native receipt +consumers are excluded. Work reviews the actual Phase A engine/collector API; +Release reviews the future CLI/parent transport boundary without current wiring. +Any newly necessary path returns for named ownership/contributor review first. + +## B0: qualify the provisioner in an isolated fixture + +First pin CandidateAttemptStore/v1 DDL, protocol/schema version, lifecycle, +compatibility matrix and migration/refusal behavior in a reviewed contract. +Product schema metadata is independent of registered receipt schema authority. +The existing currentControlPlane2/required3 refusal remains unchanged; declaring +a compatible adapter cannot make be1ae951's initializing schema3 CLI compatible. +Valid legacy schema2 receipts retain their existing contract and meaning. + +Proposed provisioner inputs are a trusted fixture authority, a fresh fixture +storage handle and reviewed immutable schema definition. It can create only a +unique synthetic fixture store in a test-owned temporary root. It refuses a +registered project/root, arbitrary caller DB path/selector, missing identity, +unsupported schema, drift or unexpected preexisting data. No candidate module +creates storage. Idempotent repeat provisioning compares exact schema/digests; +it never relabels, drops or silently migrates an incompatible store. + +Output records fixture identity, schema version/digest, pre/post logical state +and DDL evidence; it is always a nonpromotable fixture attestation. There is no +current registered-store DDL, live migration or native receipt. A future actual +provisioner requires a separate owner decision with exact registered subject, +compatible schema/code, writer/process-fence evidence, pre/post state and risk +qualification. This proposal cannot satisfy that decision or approval75. + +## B1: derive context without initializing live state + +Proposed Context/v1 is derived by a trusted parent from authenticated registered +project/area binding and its clean managed candidate; caller arguments can only +verify a binding, never select foreign area, commit, root, manifest, database, +engine, adapter, schema or expected subject. Pin the existing authenticator seam +and a side-effect-free reader before code; do not construct ControlPlane as a +shortcut if its constructor initializes schema. If current APIs cannot derive +this safely, return the precise missing seam for review rather than bypass it. + +The derived immutable tuple binds independently: + +- E: exact engine commit/module bytes, dependency/tree/runtime digests and versioned interface. +- S: tagged candidate-source or operational-runtime, authenticated identity/root, + exact clean product commit and product-schema digest or explicit null. +- A: registered adapter bytes/identity/interface, receipt schema and observed + compatible control-plane schema under the reviewed compatibility matrix. +- Frozen check definition, verified immutable input digest, attempt ID/generation, + exact guards and lease IDs/fence generations, and sealed artifact manifest. + +A candidate-source subject never becomes operational-runtime through landing or +caller labels. Fixture identities are permanently nonpromotable. Missing or +incompatible store/context refuses before worker, lease acquisition or writes; +no fallback checker, root redirect, DB copy, schema relabel or new identity. + +## B2: hermetic attempt store and atomic result finalizer + +Pin issue/start/seal/finalize/read-only reconciliation APIs and exact bounded +serialized envelopes before implementation. Trusted parent owns attempt authority, +terminal observation and result transport. Candidate code receives no writer +handle/token/socket/DB/root/manifest; withholding these is an API authority +boundary, not proven same-user OS filesystem containment. + +AttemptRecord progresses issued -> executing -> sealed -> finalized; binds the +full tuple, immutable inputs/definitions, guard and lease generations, process +identity/group observation, manifest seal and timestamps. FinalizeV1 performs one +BEGIN IMMEDIATE compare-and-swap for the exact sealed open attempt: finalize plus +ResultRecord PASS/FAIL/INCOMPLETE; eligible PASS additionally creates one receipt +in the same transaction. No consumed PASS without its receipt or consumed non-PASS +without its result. Preserve existing check_receipts/exactPasses semantics; initial +prototype rows are fixture-only and never gate native Integration/Backlog/Delivery. + +Before any native receipt eligibility, independently prove actual child consumption +of the bound immutable input and attributable parent terminal/fence evidence; +Phase A copied-byte attestation alone cannot supply that proof. Verify/seal does +not claim an atomic snapshot against concurrent writers or OS containment. + +Validate manifest path/length/hash/canonical order and actual bounded regular-file +bytes with link/special/traversal/overwrite/replacement/post-seal drift rejection. +Error/signal/timeout/overflow and zero-exit mutation never become PASS. Live or +unobservable descendants, cancellation-only proof and ambiguous commit are UNKNOWN: +retain durable AttemptRecord, seals/guards/leases, no final ResultRecord or replay. +Reconcile only the exact attempt/tuple read-only; never rerun a writer to repair +uncertainty. Proven FAIL/INCOMPLETE may use only existing-policy attempt scratch +cleanup; no new lease-release authority or receipt eligibility is implied. + +## Proposed independent scenarios and integrity gates + +QA decides exact additions and expected behavior before contributor permission. +Use synthetic fixture identity/temp root, fixed clock/IDs, deterministic terminal +and filesystem boundary inputs. Control transaction interruptions at declared +persistence boundaries; no sleeps/retries, weakened assertions or mutable goldens. + +| Scenario | Given / When | Required observable outcome | +| --- | --- | --- | +| SCN-store-fixture-isolation | Fixture provisioner receives a registered/foreign root or incompatible existing schema | Refuse before DDL; schema and logical rows unchanged; no native receipt | +| SCN-context-authenticated-tuple | Caller supplies foreign selector, dirty source, digest/schema/adapter mismatch | Refuse before execution; registered state/guards/messages unchanged | +| SCN-atomic-result | Exact sealed attempt finalizes PASS or proven non-PASS; interrupt each persistence boundary | One atomic result/eligible receipt or retained UNKNOWN, never partial consumption | +| SCN-finalize-replay-fence | Duplicate/wrong tuple, stale guard/lease generation or nonsealed attempt | No extra result/receipt or release; exact prior evidence preserved | +| SCN-artifact-seal | Root/manifest/file link, special file, traversal, cap overflow, replacement or seal drift | Explicit refusal, bounded retained evidence, zero qualifying receipt | +| SCN-terminal-unknown | Cancellation, descendant uncertainty, timeout/error/overflow, ambiguous commit | No false PASS; attributable proven result or guarded UNKNOWN with read-only reconciliation | +| SCN-fixture-nonpromotion | Attempt fixture result is presented to any current native receipt consumer | Reject; no integration/closure/delivery/operational acceptance | +| SCN-schema-legacy-boundary | Legacy schema2 tuple remains valid while schema3 initializing candidate targets current2 | Legacy behavior retained; original native downgrade refusal preserved | + +Required evidence: equally strict additive Test Integrity Note, original valid +scenario passes and deliberately corrupting/replay/partial-write variants fail for +the intended reason, independently reviewed exact candidate and hashes. Focused +fixture success remains a fixture result. After approved code and clean guarded +convergence, native exact required checks on the resulting commit, independent QA +and serialized authority-gated integration still apply. Tool/schema refusals remain +blockers; prose does not qualify native receipts or waive existing landing gates. + +## Arbiter decision and later boundaries + +For review: accept/revise/defer the exact hermetic B0-B2 trial after entry evidence, +Kernel/Work/Release interface review and named QA path/scenario consent. Recommended +choice is the isolated trial, with no native/live store provisioning. Record any +accepted scope on one existing continuity-preserving assignment only; provider +start remains a separate arbiter act. Store/context native activation, live DDL, +CLI Phase C wiring, source-requirement allowlist Phase D, resource policy changes, +installed alpha3 switch and operational/browser qualification each retain their +separate approval/verification requirements. No automatic wakes, extra identity, +installation/host change, release/deployment or full55-roadmap completion.