diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json index 0398702..9fc4209 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1", "id": "TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e", "title": "Separate candidate source qualification from live control-plane initialization", - "description": "Explicit owner a970326b-87a5-4292-8f22-e1bec0c15f11/92f7fd36 corrects the inventory: no explicit existing check-engine separation item exists. Add ONE proposed bounded item in the existing backlog. Incident observed on canonical cb145e56 and Kernel reservation candidate be1ae951: candidate CLI initialized production schema3 during qualification, installed/canonical schema2 writers relabel it, and native CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED currentVersion2 requiredVersion3 then prevents qualification, causing activation/landing circularity. Design supported separation of exact candidate-source execution engine from a versioned, independently fingerprinted compatible receipt/control-plane adapter without migrating live production state merely to test candidate. Preserve actual authenticated native project/area/commit/definition/run/resource/guard/outcome evidence and immutable artifacts. Work owns src/checks, Kernel src/control-plane, Release CLI wiring and QA scenarios/acceptance; agree exact contract, owned paths and scenario consent before any implementation. No old-checker shortcut, fake isolated real-project receipts, gate waiver, install activation, production DB recovery, new identity or parallel queue. TASK-4dc metadata/candidate preparation remains completed; its retained deeper provenance roadmap was not an explicit task until this proposal.", + "description": "Explicit owner a970326b-87a5-4292-8f22-e1bec0c15f11/92f7fd36 corrects the inventory: no explicit existing check-engine separation item exists. Add ONE proposed bounded item in the existing backlog. Incident observed on canonical cb145e56 and Kernel reservation candidate be1ae951: candidate CLI initialized production schema3 during qualification, installed/canonical schema2 writers relabel it, and native CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED currentVersion2 requiredVersion3 then prevents qualification, causing activation/landing circularity. Design supported separation of exact candidate-source execution engine from a versioned, independently fingerprinted compatible receipt/control-plane adapter without migrating live production state merely to test candidate. Preserve actual authenticated native project/area/commit/definition/run/resource/guard/outcome evidence and immutable artifacts. Work owns src/checks, Kernel src/control-plane, Release CLI wiring and QA scenarios/acceptance; agree exact contract, owned paths and scenario consent before any implementation. No old-checker shortcut, fake isolated real-project receipts, gate waiver, install activation, production DB recovery, new identity or parallel queue. TASK-4dc metadata/candidate preparation remains completed; its retained deeper provenance roadmap was not an explicit task until this proposal.\n\nCurrent authorized phase (owner36788020/21997bf1, QAa0e8ae17): bounded Phase A implementation preparation/development on this SAME Work assignment. Only NEW src/checks/candidate-engine.mjs and src/checks/artifact-manifest.mjs, new QA-consented test/fleet/candidate-engine.test.mjs and test/fleet/candidate-artifact-manifest.test.mjs, and append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Extract reviewed pure raw-terminal execution and trusted parent artifact-collection seams; frozen inputs/args/env/artifact limits, parent-only observed terminal/envelope with no candidate writer capability, capped canonical regular-file manifest and strict traversal/link/special/overwrite/seal-drift rejection. Hermetic fixture/fake-adapter evidence is permanently development-only/nonpromotable. No existing conditions behavior changes or CheckService/CLI/integration/consumer wiring; no store/provisioner/schema/DDL/receipt-consumer/gate-policy/resource-lease changes, live recovery, installation/host/provider/wake/publication actions. QA remains final test owner. Phase A does not complete this full task or qualify native/operational acceptance. Later Kernel store/context/adapter, Release CLI and Work explicit source-consumer phases remain proposed and require separate scoped decisions; retain actual native guards and all existing full acceptance criteria.", "priority": "high", "affectedDomains": [ "work-integration", @@ -31,14 +31,18 @@ "message:28f03fa6-ff6e-4af8-87e0-631218f1ec55:owner-bounded-design-document-phase", "message:7f3964b1-7c4e-464e-8d8e-8cdb8e7e61b8:Kernel-owned-interface-reviewed", "message:9f974c64-0d46-4825-97b4-5a9b02cab30a:three-axis-draft", - "message:0c3462cf-d312-407c-9b09-eacda53ad080:tuple-scoped-compatibility-and-artifact-transport-correction" + "message:0c3462cf-d312-407c-9b09-eacda53ad080:tuple-scoped-compatibility-and-artifact-transport-correction", + "message:59933112-c99e-486a-b186-9aca37cc0174:reviewed-phased-engine/store/transport-proposal", + "message:36788020-8960-4fbc-8ed9-db8d5cacbe04:owner-exact-Phase-A-conditional-authorization", + "message:a0e8ae17-8525-46d7-b213-0031aa85f2a0:QA-named-Phase-A-source/test-path/scenario-contributor-consent", + "message:21997bf1-b1c1-4808-88fe-9d673c55fb23:owner-condition-resolved-record-same-assignment-phase" ], "commit": null, "integrationRequest": null, "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:14:01.401Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T12:17:15.519Z", - "revision": 3, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T13:45:39.303Z", + "revision": 4, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -60,6 +64,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T12:17:15.519Z", "note": "Assign ONE bounded DESIGN-DOCUMENT phase under owner28f, after native Work nextreadyTHIS/noactive. Work is design lead/reviewer, not code implementer in this phase. Named contributor Project Kernel alone drafts two owned paths: nonnormative clearly PROPOSED additions inside docs/PORTABLE_AGENT_FLEET_SPEC.md sections18/20, additive next-free ADR in docs/ARCHITECTURE_DECISIONS.md; do not rewrite accepted rules/ADR024 or existing proposedADR025. Work pins/reviews versioned engine/result envelope and immutable digests, Kernel authenticated subject/no-DDL registered adapter/opaque fresh attempt transport, Release CLI worker/env/artifact boundary, QA strict scenario/interface truth. Mark missing policy decisions explicitly. No src/schema/config/test edit, live DB/control-plane initialization, gate-semantic change, fixture promotion, operational acceptance, install/provider/wake/host action. Kernel inbox565 blocked7 at a4 and inventory/reservation histories remain blocked, not reactivated or duplicated. Runtime e440 and Console workflow remain their existing single implementations. Return exact proposed amendment and named peer decisions for final review before any code scope." + }, + { + "from": "assigned", + "to": "assigned", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T13:45:39.303Z", + "note": "Explicit owner21997bf1 requests reviewed metadata-only phase/revision/evidence amendment after actual owner367 and QAa0 consent. Expected revision3; SAME existing Work assignment, phase A preparation/development now authorized only exact two new modules, two additive hermetic test files and append-only integrity note. No assertion of code begun/finished, no lifecycle transition or duplicate assignment; owner/state/full criteria/dependencies/candidate/integration and all prior history preserved. Service has no metadata-amend API; no transition/gate workaround. Kernel/Release/consumer/store/schema phases remain proposed; no runtime/provider launch or operational acceptance." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json index a2c3be4..edae9bd 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json @@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ "observedAt": "ff0712534829", "feature": "Self-host development readiness", "milestone": "Owner-reviewed first development backlog", - "state": "in_progress", + "state": "blocked", "owner": "owner-console", "evidence": [ "message:89c92c3e-4f00-4213-877d-6c2afeb4b22c:focused-view-routing/mobile-navigation/title-provenance-design-observations", @@ -55,14 +55,23 @@ "message:1b19a436-44d8-4e6c-8868-19f1e65591db:QA-exact-Fleet-markup-and-scenario-contribution-consent", "message:1b2d96bc-ec77-4cb2-b5be-a1b9b6ef47ae:owner-explicit-same-task-scope", "message:6a37283a-5baf-4b3f-b84c-1aa7cdecf223:actual-bounded-peer-request", - "message:22df881a-9d38-4706-b0bf-da05c6b674c8:stale-wait-evidence-refresh-required" + "message:22df881a-9d38-4706-b0bf-da05c6b674c8:stale-wait-evidence-refresh-required", + "source-cli:test:4ca6a5ab-3fbb-45f4-a6d6-76838c9b4b73:PASS:candidate=e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891", + "source-cli:check:00a9b411-caec-4205-b0c5-d6e205c4dbdd:PASS:candidate=e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891", + "source-cli:test-dashboard:43d7b57f-48a8-4131-8906-7ebde0112c8e:PASS:11-generated-PNG-artifacts:candidate=e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891", + "source-cli:lint:111f3067-d8dc-4d2d-8b96-b3dbd5dbad39:PASS:candidate=e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891", + "QA-review-request-pending:full-diff-and-receipts", + "message:333bf5ab-558b-40f1-8245-f3333032c397:independent-protected-details-driver-toggle-proof", + "message:9a83dde8-af7e-411b-890b-ee1582266e32:independent-focused-corrected-navigation-10/10-development-evidence", + "message:4ff2beb2-8cf5-4a05-96fa-9e09ced8ebb3:independent-exact-e8c-source-acceptance-four-native-PASS-and-11-artifact-hashes-not-full-task/operational", + "message:f9a645d0-8f0a-4539-bbdd-326721aa47bd:exact-source-integration-request-handoff-no-self-landing" ], - "commit": "6870c3a61073b950710eb7720f63ccd21da58f38", + "commit": "e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891", "integrationRequest": null, - "blockedReason": null, + "blockedReason": "Exact clean e8c4c424 independent QA source acceptance received in actual4ff2beb2; all four native PASS and 11 regular-file PNG receipt-manifest hashes verified by QA. The prior QA-pending clause is resolved/historical. Manager requested exact source integration request through Console registered branch (f9a645d0); serialized native authority/clean canonical/ancestry gates still required. Full workflow remains blocked on actual live desktop/mobile/installed-alpha2 and owner acceptance requirements; generated demo screenshots and source acceptance do not prove operational acceptance. No task completion, install switch, live schema recovery or provider/wake/host authority.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.720Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T12:27:44.625Z", - "revision": 13, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T13:49:46.389Z", + "revision": 15, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -154,6 +163,20 @@ "actorId": "owner-console", "at": "2026-10-01T12:27:44.625Z", "note": "Resuming the same workflow on clean HEAD 6870c3a under Manager reassignment revision 12. Actual QA b4449652 and owner 46cd85d9 authorize the exact second-Fleet-section layout/routing scenario and narrow driver scope; preserve strict ownership assertions and all existing coverage." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "owner-console", + "at": "2026-10-01T13:44:07.635Z", + "note": "Forward-corrected only the approved navigation test stimulus, dashboard owning-view driver selection and closed-disclosure interaction. Preserved exact scroll equality and all prior scenarios/captures/artifact safeguards." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T13:49:46.389Z", + "note": "Reviewed Manager-owned authoritative ledger metadata-only reconciliation after fresh current blocked14 and actual QA4ff2 exact source acceptance. Prior QA-pending hold resolved, actual guarded source integration handoff and live full-task acceptance remain open. Preserve owner/state/candidate/full criteria/dependencies/all receipt and failure history; no lifecycle churn or automatic completion. Native service lacks metadata-amend API; no blocked transition bypass or native gate waiver." } ] } diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index f3119cf..0430036 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,5 +1,115 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff +## Phase A authorized and Console exact-source QA accepted at 13:51 UTC + +Fresh canonical brief digest **d7e6d69** was read through the approved narrowly +scoped retry after the ordinary sandbox returned readonly-database failure. +CURRENT tasks were read before explicit addressed unread100; actual Work +**59933112**, owner **36788020/21997bf1**, QA **a0e8ae17**, owner **333bf5ab/9a83dde8**, +Console **6d1eed3f** and QA **4ff2beb2** were understood and individually acknowledged. +Historical own messages **44512241**, **eca7ded3**, Kernel **b952872d/42e3108b** and +QA **d29c68c8** were separately reread; historical pages did not establish inbox +completeness. Final explicit unread100 returned empty at 13:50 UTC. Acknowledged +handoffs remain open until their actual outcomes arrive. + +**Concrete same-assignment Phase A.** Actual owner367 authorizes bounded +implementation after named QA permission; actual QAa0 grants the exact paths and +owner219 confirms the condition resolved. SAME Work **TASK-6e4 assigned3 -> +assigned4** is a reviewed metadata-only phase amendment, preserving owner, state, +all seven full criteria, dependencies, candidate null and complete history. +Only NEW **src/checks/candidate-engine.mjs**, **src/checks/artifact-manifest.mjs**, +NEW **test/fleet/candidate-engine.test.mjs**, **test/fleet/candidate-artifact-manifest.test.mjs** +and append-only **docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md** are authorized. Work receives concrete +handoff **d36ff182**: first pin frozen inputs/args/env/output/artifact limits and +scenario plan, then pure raw-terminal execution and trusted parent artifact +collection; no candidate writer/token/socket/DB authority. Strict capped sorted +regular-file hash/length manifest must reject traversal, links, special files, +overwrite and seal drift. Hermetic fixtures/fake adapters are permanently +nonpromotable development evidence. No current conditions behavior change, +CheckService/CLI/integration wiring, registered store/provisioner/schema/DDL, +consumer/gate/lease policy change or full-task/operational acceptance. QA receives +**beb6f3a3** and remains final test owner. Manager launches no provider; arbiter +controls any resume. Work branch was independently clean at **1a2b5b0** before +handoff; preserve its unique commits and all peer work. + +Actual Work599 synthesized reviewed Kernel **6fdb88ea**, Release CLI/parent +transport and QA contracts. Later phases remain explicitly proposed: **B Kernel +registered-store provisioner/context/adapter**, **C Release candidate-plan/run +before initializer**, **D Work named allowlisted source-requirement consumer**, +with **E QA independent per-phase qualification**. B and D are not authorized by +Phase A, and no current CLI wiring is authorized. Existing exactPasses, compatible +legacy schema2 receipts and be1 schema3/current2 refusal remain intact. UNKNOWN +is durable unfinalized AttemptRecord/no ResultRecord with evidence and fences; +proven FAIL/INCOMPLETE cannot become PASS or new lease-release authority. +Kernel **140cd5e4** and Release **e37d6dd0** receive this exact phase boundary. +Dormant-service roadmap remains Kernel inventory1e688 contract/qualification -> +Runtime2b4 dormant launcher after currente440 -> Release consumes qualified APIs. +No duplicate active assignments or new component queue was created. + +**Console source accepted, full workflow still blocked.** Manager independently +observed clean **e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891**, unchanged clean canonical +**0fdfcb3b68e4511f2993d03e1fff8f89124b731c**, and successful exact ancestry check. +Native receipts on e8c: **4ca6a5ab test**, **00a9b411 check**, **43d7b57f dashboard**, +**111f3067 lint**, all PASS/invalidReason null. The cfb-to-e8c delta contains only +navigation test, narrow demo driver and integrity note: fixed numeric347 with +observed347 baseline/exact equality removes wheel/scrollend/global tracing/async +trace diagnostics; real summary click occurs only when details.open is false; +reset selects the actual approval-count owner. All original Review/token/revision +assertions remain. Owner333's isolated demonstration proves the old unconditional +click closed the protected disclosure; owner9a83 focused10/10 on the prior dirty +correction is separate independent focused evidence, not a native clean receipt. + +After Manager request **f8bb6152**, actual QA **4ff2beb2** independently ACCEPTS +exact-source e8c only: clean ancestry/diff/four receipts, strict numeric scroll +and conditional driver, additive TIN, all11 generated regular-file PNG bytes and +SHA256 equal the dashboard receipt manifest. This resolves the source QA wait; +it does not establish actual live desktop/mobile/installed-alpha2/owner workflow +acceptance. Console self-recorded **blocked14** before this verdict; reviewed +Manager-owned metadata amendment **blocked15** replaces its stale QA-pending +reason with actual source acceptance, pending guarded integration handoff and +remaining live gate. All criteria, owner, exact candidate and historical failures +remain. Console receives **f9a645d0** to submit its own exact-commit integration +request after fresh brief/current/inbox/clean checks; Manager must then evaluate +and use serialized native authority/clean canonical/ancestry gates without +waivers. No source request/landing is claimed by this snapshot; task is not closed. +Generated demo screenshots/source acceptance never become operational acceptance. + +**Implemented API and real refusal retained.** Kernel observeMessages exists at +inbox candidate **a4bba018**, with actual narrow QA source/test-integrity acceptance. +Owner445's WAL mutant exposed the original test gap, not actual read mutation; +strengthened actual connection DML counting/logical-state assertions and multiline +mutant rejection remain. External unreviewed mutation-script execution refusal +was preserved. Native currentControlPlane2/required3 qualification still refuses: +no eligible native receipt/landing or live recovery is inferred. Inventory's +old missing-API clause and inbox's old QA-pending clause are historical. Overview +initial/return title exactly TORCH Dashboard is the resolved delegated eca decision, +not a new owner hold or permission to weaken the original expectation. + +**Fleet judgment and validation.** Current55 tasks are **38 proposed,9 blocked, +6 completed,2 assigned**: Work4 and Runtime6 are the single active assignments; +Console15 keeps genuine full-task acceptance blocked. Readonly check-in refreshed +six reports and own addressed findings; presence idle timestamps do not prove +process absence/completion. Evolution reports8 recurring domain sets, hierarchy10 +signals, changes none. Keep the six coherent domain owners: explicit API/store +contracts, phase boundaries and named handoffs resolve current friction better +than promoting an identity or adding a manager. Health37 stale-observation and2 +resolved-dependency warnings remain observational, no auto-fix or mass cleanup. +Manager reviewed append-only ledger metadata, preserved histories/criteria, +validated55 unique IDs, revision/history consistency, known acyclic dependencies, +one active item per owner and diff whitespace. No new tests are needed for these +metadata/report changes; Console native evidence is distinct from Manager running +any peer checks. Owner-addressed informational send was refused **Unknown Fleet +identity: owner**; no message was delivered and no alternate sender/tool bypass was +attempted. This report is the owner-facing record. + +No automatic wakes, installation switch, live schema recovery, host activation, +extra identity, provider launch, remote push/publication or destructive recovery. +Five-PNG permission remains only the completed exact Runtime recovery. Native +landing gates, approval boundaries and tool refusals are preserved. Open handoffs +are Work Phase A implementation/independent validation and Console exact request/ +serialized integration/live acceptance; no idle/complete outcome is invented. + + ## Precise QA disposition received at 13:33 UTC After checkpoint5dee7c8, CURRENT tasks remain Console in_progress13, Work