diff --git a/reports/audit/fleet-arbiter-checkpoint-2026-10-03.md b/reports/audit/fleet-arbiter-checkpoint-2026-10-03.md index d9e6f29..2467960 100644 --- a/reports/audit/fleet-arbiter-checkpoint-2026-10-03.md +++ b/reports/audit/fleet-arbiter-checkpoint-2026-10-03.md @@ -68,3 +68,105 @@ continuation remain open. Native execution cannot continue today without an explicit new budget decision; the existing policy resets its daily allowance at UTC midnight. No deployment, installed-runtime upgrade, live DDL, authority expansion or completion assertion follows from this checkpoint. + +## Subsequent verification and delivery blockers + +The sections above describe the earlier checkpoint, not the latest outcome. +Canonical source subsequently reached `3bb9c55`; the installed accepted runtime +was not upgraded by the following source reviews. + +### Current-v2 reader and CLI + +The corrected Kernel slice `c79f8d4`, Work convergence slice `7e0734a`, and +Release CLI slice `dd77b70` applied cleanly to canonical `3bb9c55` in the +detached review tree `/tmp/torch-current-reader-review-vFjsSi/candidate`. +The resulting candidate was `62629b806b00b4ceb8701c754c65b22738614eb9`. +Root's full suite passed 282 tests with four explicit skips. A focused command +named nonexistent `cli.test.mjs`; its 11 passing tests therefore did not prove +CLI coverage. The actual full-suite glob did include `cli-scenarios.test.mjs`. + +Root then removed the reader's `BEGIN` and transaction-open flag in an isolated +mutant. The original four reader scenarios still passed: a demonstrated +coverage gap, not proof of a production-reader defect. QA granted an additive +correlated-generation scenario, delivered as +`85914d3ef8a310878cec8345d976e78b3128d47e` atop `62629b8`. +Root independently verified five reader scenarios passing on that exact +candidate. The same no-transaction mutant failed the new scenario because a +single reader combined generation A and generation B, not because close failed. +Evidence was delivered to QA and Manager in owner messages `23102515` and +`fd088d9f`. The review-only mutant remains in +`/tmp/torch-reader-oracle-independent-W4arvj/candidate`; do not promote it. + +Work separately delivered `cdc3aa9b800f7f2c1c925e1d8ecd21d9948fd3d2`, a sibling +of `85914d3` atop `62629b8`. Its additive CLI scenario invokes actual `brief`, +`converge plan`, and `converge guards` against a sidecar-free, write-refusing +fixture and checks unchanged database bytes. Root verified that exact targeted +scenario passing in `/tmp/torch-cli-reader-independent-YpA8xa/candidate` after +providing dependencies. An initial invocation used the wrong working directory +and failed importing `zod` before assertions; that setup failure is not a +behavioral test result. No composed `85914d3` plus `cdc3aa9` candidate, native +check receipt, installed qualification, or integration is asserted here. + +### Compact-card source corrections + +Candidate `29afa15` initially left long title/domain metadata unbounded: an +isolated headless reproduction grew a card from 407px to 2,803px. Its current +controls link also left the modal open over the destination. Correction +`063034274a9e42b589aed6ef6071780b06f9a3b7` bounds those fields and closes/routes +the modal. Root independently ran all six focused browser scenarios successfully. +QA reported full-suite/check/dashboard/lint success for that source candidate. +This is hermetic demo evidence, not connected live desktop/mobile qualification, +uniform-height acceptance across every card type, or installed delivery. + +The correction contains `Closes: TASK-console-compact-details`; the full task +remains incomplete. Manager reported that automatic closure refuses a blocked +task that is not ready to integrate. Preserve that boundary rather than making +the task integration-ready solely to land a source slice. Existing managed +Console branch `2261e9b` and its history remain separate from the detached source. + +### Failed gates and operational requests + +Runtime's converged `0bb5ca4a084ad19a99cef1d8ea3162bf29272f8f` and Kernel's +`85914d3` both reported full-suite cancellation at the existing 60-second +`cli-scenarios.test.mjs` boundary. Neither is a green full-suite result. +Runtime preserved its excerpt and audit in its worktree under +`test_logs/cli-suite-timeout-0bb5ca4a.observed-output.log` and +`reports/test-audit/cli-suite-timeout-report-2026-10-03.md`. +There is no TORCH check receipt for that direct `npm run test` invocation. +The captured file-level output does not identify an internal CLI subscenario. +No timeout increase, assertion relaxation, or retry-until-green was authorized. + +Root submitted these concrete findings through durable owner requests: + +- `700f9ac7`: live snapshot response took 9.182 seconds; the following static + page response took 0.003552 seconds. Synchronous doctor/Git observation is a + candidate cause, not a proven root cause. Profile without hiding stale state. +- `db2380f0`: configuration defines a one-slot browser resource, but full-test + and dashboard-check resource lists are empty. Direct test commands have no + queue receipt. This coordination gap is verified; its role in the timeout + is not. Avoid new competing full/browser suites while diagnosing it. +- `0d25bf3e`: ordinary integration intake requires a registered specialist + branch tip equal to the candidate SHA. Detached `626`/`859`/`cdc` do not meet + that boundary, and Session Manager is not a feature-source identity. A + reviewed lossless adoption path is needed; do not impersonate a specialist, + reset its branch, import its whole future branch, or fabricate receipts. +- `ea12134f`: Owner Console had both live parent and native Codex child for + approximately 42 minutes while its durable progress report remained old. + Separate executor liveness from recent activity and actual waiting reasons. + Age alone does not authorize termination, guard cleanup, or restart. + +### Launch allowance and next actions + +An audited one-day allowance permitted 96 automatic launches on UTC +2026-10-03, while the ordinary future daily cap remains 48. The ledger reached +96 and the live observation returned `daily-turn-cap`. In-flight turns were +allowed to finish; no ledger reset or further allowance was granted. The policy +uses UTC midnight, not local midnight. It is an invocation allowance, not proof +of token/cost governance or reboot-persistent scheduling. + +Next work remains: independent current-candidate QA; deterministic diagnosis +of the failed CLI gate and correct resource admission; lossless candidate +adoption/intake; exact-SHA qualifying receipts; serialized integration; +installed sandbox/startup verification; connected live UI review; and the +remaining roadmap. Durable manager backlog and owner messages remain the +authoritative queue. This report does not close those tasks or broaden authority.