From a7c4cc50f63f394aa4334b19869591c3530b61c3 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: thePR0M3TH3AN Date: Thu, 1 Oct 2026 03:20:52 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] Checkpoint TASK-bounded-routine-coordination verification and Runtime owner guard hold --- ...-20d313f8-bec3-4926-b9ef-2f0be687e2cc.json | 46 ++++++++++ .../TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json | 31 ++++++- .../backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json | 19 +++- ...emaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md | 91 ++++++++++++++++++- 4 files changed, 177 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .torch/backlog/TASK-20d313f8-bec3-4926-b9ef-2f0be687e2cc.json diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-20d313f8-bec3-4926-b9ef-2f0be687e2cc.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-20d313f8-bec3-4926-b9ef-2f0be687e2cc.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0b13add --- /dev/null +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-20d313f8-bec3-4926-b9ef-2f0be687e2cc.json @@ -0,0 +1,46 @@ +{ + "schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1", + "id": "TASK-20d313f8-bec3-4926-b9ef-2f0be687e2cc", + "title": "Make approval requests atomic and idempotent across concurrent Fleet handoffs", + "description": "Owner79720701 observed actual duplicate Kernel101fe731/Manager6f85e138 and Runtime925643d6/Manager99ef7a45 exact recovery requests. Record one proposed existing-backlog requirement, not a competing approval queue: atomic durable request idempotency keyed project/task/exact candidate/action/resource set/named approver. Preserve each request attempt and evidence lineage, return one actionable request identity to concurrent callers, and keep meaningful evidence/scope conflicts explicit. Current existing approvals and rejected-as-superseded histories remain unchanged. Manager queries existing requests before creating; this procedural precheck does not solve races. Implementation unassigned pending reliability sequence, domain ownership, peer consent and QA; no new authority/provider starts.", + "priority": "high", + "affectedDomains": [ + "project-kernel", + "provider-runtime", + "owner-console", + "qa", + "work-integration" + ], + "dependencies": [ + "TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes", + "TASK-bounded-routine-coordination" + ], + "acceptanceCriteria": [ + "Concurrent identical requests at the durable boundary resolve one actionable approval ID without losing attempt/evidence audit; key includes project, task, exact candidate, action, canonical resource set and named approver.", + "Different candidates, approvers, actions or resource scopes remain distinct; incompatible evidence revisions are visible and cannot silently broaden an existing decision.", + "Named approver authority, evidence sufficiency, revision checks, pause and ownership controls remain enforced; deduplication never approves, executes or transfers ownership.", + "Interrupted request creation/retry returns the existing durable outcome with no second actionable pending or approved request, retaining superseded historical records.", + "Independent deterministic concurrency/recovery scenarios observe durable request IDs, evidence lineage and refusals at API/CLI boundaries; no weakening of existing approval assertions." + ], + "observedAt": "1a2b5b0fec32c2dddbfec76e2f0479de9cfc31c4", + "feature": null, + "milestone": null, + "state": "proposed", + "owner": null, + "evidence": [], + "commit": null, + "integrationRequest": null, + "blockedReason": null, + "createdAt": "2026-10-01T07:15:25.892Z", + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T07:15:25.892Z", + "revision": 1, + "history": [ + { + "from": null, + "to": "proposed", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T07:15:25.892Z", + "note": "Task created." + } + ] +} diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json index 02d25c4..db1d337 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-bounded-routine-coordination.json @@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ "observedAt": "7b7c6584b9d3", "feature": null, "milestone": null, - "state": "blocked", + "state": "verification", "owner": "project-kernel", "evidence": [ "npm run test: 195 passed", @@ -37,14 +37,21 @@ "message:9d671f19-4184-4dc0-b98f-0b0d9cb2d868:QA-exact-note-reconciliation-consent", "receipt:108f3607-c9c6-4135-8f39-3b57e6accbfa:incomplete:worktree-changed-during-check", "message:c293d46a-0e20-40cb-bdcf-1e45f434ee22:installed-checker-correction", - "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:owner-technical-routing" + "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:owner-technical-routing", + "approval:6f85e138-27f6-47ea-bf63-96cb46553496:approved-rev2", + "message:76628552-924e-4a56-a52a-5f8945bdf040:clean-native-recovery-four-fresh-gates", + "checks:20aef427-24f91aab-6f2ba896-7859860a:exact-dd62-PASS", + "receipt:20aef427-a098-4dbd-a1d8-b1c37b7a275d:pass", + "receipt:24f91aab-7ca7-483b-9b20-5de29c17d72c:pass", + "receipt:6f2ba896-b0c5-4253-b222-f398ba8bd048:pass", + "receipt:7859860a-6eee-4648-8b63-1a27ef8c44fa:pass" ], "commit": "dd62c7787737e35138cef7871489d6be1ee696c9", "integrationRequest": null, - "blockedReason": "Merged candidate is gate-blocked after installed alpha.2 check runtime (not candidate CLI) ran dashboard and rewrote exactly five QA-owned tracked PNGs. Dashboard exit0 receipt 108f3607-c9c6-4135-8f39-3b57e6accbfa is incomplete/worktree-changed-during-check. Preserve NEW bytes, external archive/hash and clean-before provenance; obtain NEW named QA bounded recovery disposition before any restoration. Lint unrun; no new four-gate qualification/integration. Re-entry uses explicit candidate bin/torch.mjs from canonical cwd, registered area, after approved recovery.", + "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-09-30T23:06:51.644Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T06:44:09.098Z", - "revision": 11, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T07:16:13.394Z", + "revision": 13, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -122,6 +129,20 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T06:44:09.098Z", "note": "Actual merge finished; preserve new exact candidate and previous strict QA/receipt history. Landed isolation1a2 not shown faulty: installed alpha2 check service lacks output environment propagation, native Kernel admitted installed launcher. Native owner must archive new byte set and exact pre-clean receipts then request QA recovery for THIS candidate/path set; old4068350 approval cannot cover this incident. No peer dirty-file edits/restore/stash/gate waiver. Candidate CLI/source version explicit for all resulting checks; Release read-only activation/rollback plan pending arbiter, wakes paused." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "in_progress", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T07:15:30.691Z", + "note": "Resume SAME owned task after actual new scoped QA-approved native recovery. Independently read four exact dd62 PASS receipts with no invalidReason and clean live worktree. Old108f remains INCOMPLETE, archives/406/c2 retained. No completion/integration acceptance inferred; independent QA review still required, canonical1a2 clean unchanged. Preserve original owner/candidate/history, no second assignment." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "verification", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T07:16:13.394Z", + "note": "All four immutable exact dd62 fresh receipts verified PASS/noinvalidReason and clean native branch after approved recovery. Move SAME task to independent QA verification, retaining native owner, historical incomplete108f and all archives/approval histories. QA must review actual generated policy/scenario boundaries/TestIntegrity and exact engine provenance; this is not acceptance or landing." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json index 99140a7..cf03ed4 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json @@ -38,14 +38,18 @@ "message:9d671f19-4184-4dc0-b98f-0b0d9cb2d868:QA-exact-note-reconciliation-consent", "receipt:fc8da04b-76fb-4e5d-9ca9-dacfddd31332:incomplete:worktree-changed-during-check", "message:c293d46a-0e20-40cb-bdcf-1e45f434ee22:installed-checker-correction", - "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:owner-technical-routing" + "message:9590d8b1-8ccd-478e-9e47-6b7e319404a0:owner-technical-routing", + "message:df000c30-f0e4-4720-96d1-13e9dc58dd23:actual-public-guard-refusal", + "message:0cfd47cc-3c48-4632-b095-a471ff05c745:supersedes-mistaken-interpretation", + "approval:99ef7a45-82d4-4dc7-a558-c52bde768d53:approved-rev2-insufficient-to-bypass-external-guard", + "approval:d1f74d6e-768b-4b89-921f-3f7b1e56a1a3:owner-pending-post-risk-runtime-recovery" ], "commit": "286bfa72e3202ec0806f7c3075821c8057d6e132", "integrationRequest": null, - "blockedReason": "Merged candidate is gate-blocked after installed alpha.2 check runtime (not candidate CLI) ran dashboard and rewrote exactly five QA-owned tracked PNGs. Dashboard exit0 receipt fc8da04b-76fb-4e5d-9ca9-dacfddd31332 is incomplete/worktree-changed-during-check. Preserve NEW bytes, external archive/hash and clean-before provenance; obtain NEW named QA bounded recovery disposition before any restoration. Lint unrun; no new four-gate qualification/integration. Re-entry uses explicit candidate bin/torch.mjs from canonical cwd, registered area, after approved recovery.", + "blockedReason": "Actual automatic approval-review guard rejected native Runtime five-QA-PNG restoration at public tool call 2026-10-01T07:12:06.460Z: trusted instructions reserve recovery to Project Kernel and prohibit retry, indirect execution or policy circumvention. New QA99ef approved scoped286 recovery but cannot bypass this guard. Arbiter has asked actual user for new post-risk exact-scope decision; owner-addressed wait pending. Candidate286/five dirty originals/archives and historical incompletefc8 receipts retained; no cross-worktree Kernel routing, policy override or retry until actual trusted user response and applicable guard permits.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T20:20:17.000Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T06:44:06.318Z", - "revision": 9, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T07:19:22.987Z", + "revision": 10, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -109,6 +113,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T06:44:06.318Z", "note": "Actual merge finished; preserve new exact candidate and previous strict QA/receipt history. Landed isolation1a2 not shown faulty: installed alpha2 check service lacks output environment propagation, native Kernel admitted installed launcher. Native owner must archive new byte set and exact pre-clean receipts then request QA recovery for THIS candidate/path set; old4068350 approval cannot cover this incident. No peer dirty-file edits/restore/stash/gate waiver. Candidate CLI/source version explicit for all resulting checks; Release read-only activation/rollback plan pending arbiter, wakes paused." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T07:19:22.987Z", + "note": "Ownerdf000c30 requests precise actual guard-hold reconciliation. Expectedrev9; same blocked state/owner/candidate/criteria/dependencies preserved. Manager-owned metadata amendment only; no lifecycle resume, approval decision, recovery execution or guard bypass. Arbiter actual-user question remains pending." } ] } diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index 474f709..9c695e2 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,6 +1,95 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff -## Current closing coordination at 07:03 UTC +## Current guard hold at 07:19 UTC + +**Actual owner decision pending:** approval +`d1f74d6e-768b-4b89-921f-3f7b1e56a1a3`, addressed to owner, records Runtime286 +recovery's real automatic approval-review refusal. Owner `df000c30` confirms +PUBLIC tool call at 07:12:06.460 rejected five QA-owned PNG overwrites because +trusted instructions reserve restoration to Project Kernel and explicitly +prohibit retry, indirect execution and policy circumvention. Arbiter has already +asked the actual user for a new post-risk exact-scope decision. Earlier general +development consent and QA99ef approval are insufficient to bypass this guard. + +Manager's earlier `2c70c796` interpretation treated the blocker as clause scope +ambiguity; that was incomplete and is explicitly superseded by `0cfd47cc` after +the actual guard evidence arrived. Do not retry from peer clauses, edit policy +to override, or route Kernel into Runtime's dirty worktree. Original candidate, +five dirty originals, archives and old incomplete receipts remain preserved. +Same Runtime task stays **blocked revision 10** with the precise guard reason; +no owner decision, restoration or resumed qualification is inferred. + +Scheduled self-check `7af7e222` was read and fresh check-in at07:18:46 found no +unacknowledged findings or peer approval waits. The explicit owner wait was then +created once, after querying existing pending approvals. Acknowledgement does +not resolve that hold. Kernel remains verification13 with four fresh PASS +receipts, and Console/Release local work continues within existing assignments. +Automatic wakes stay paused; Manager performs no provider start or installation. + +## Historical resume reconciliation at 07:17 UTC + +Installed startup brief succeeds under scoped exact-command escalation after a +sandbox readonly-DB refusal; canonical digest remains `d7e6d69`. Canonical is +clean at `1a2b5b0`; no new integration request qualifies at this reconciliation. +Manager started at clean `c65ae5c`. All six specialists retain their boundaries. +Backlog health is healthy; bounded historical scan remains incomplete. Evolution +has seven recurring domain-set signals; hierarchy has 30 recurrences and ten +direct coordination requests over 30 days, advisory only, no Fleet changes. +Existing domain ownership and procedural improvements are preferable to another +specialist or coordination role: much evidence is seeded proposals, while actual +friction concerns engine provenance, exact recovery and duplicate approval races. +Promoting a current identity or adding a manager has no demonstrated outcome or +authority benefit at this point. No proposal or identity activation is performed. + +QA new recoveries `6f85e138` (Kernel dd62) and `99ef7a45` (Runtime286) are actually +approved revision 2; Manager independently read their bounded decisions. Owner +`7763e6e2` reports native duplicate `101fe731`/`925643d6` rejected as superseded. +These peer-request records are outside Manager's returned approval list; QA was +asked to confirm their crossreferences and preserve all audit, not decide again. +Historical 406/c2 and incomplete dashboard receipts remain untouched. + +Kernel native recovery completed, live `dd62c778` worktree is clean, and Manager +independently read fresh exact PASS receipts: test +`20aef427-a098-4dbd-a1d8-b1c37b7a275d`, check +`24f91aab-7ca7-483b-9b20-5de29c17d72c`, dashboard +`6f2ba896-b0c5-4253-b222-f398ba8bd048`, lint +`7859860a-6eee-4648-8b63-1a27ef8c44fa`, all without invalidReason. Same task was +resumed revision 12 and moved to **verification revision 13**, preserving owner +and candidate; independent QA requested via `0e327975`. This is not QA acceptance +or landing. Old installed receipt108f remains incomplete. Qualification used the +explicit candidate CLI from canonical cwd; artifact output is external. + +Runtime286 remains blocked revision 9 with exactly five PNGs dirty at live read. +Its new scoped QA decision allows native Runtime only. Runtime reported a +Kernel-only authority conflict; Manager `2c70c796` explains the historical 406 +Kernel clause versus new99ef scope and explicit owner7763 owner-native direction. +No cross-worktree restoration is routed to Kernel. Native Runtime must reread +the exact decisions and immediately recheck unchanged HEAD/paths/hashes before +applying; any applicable guard refusal stays visible. Manager changes no peer +files and does not claim resolution before native clean recovery/fresh gates. + +All three Release version-only consents (QA e625, Kernel9c65, Runtime8ce8) are now +approved revision 2 and read independently; Release was notified by `9a772036`. +Live Release branch converged to1a2 and contains only its three metadata edits. +Its alpha.3 task remains the same assignment, with exact candidate gates, +independent QA and guarded source landing before reviewed plan/isolated build. +Console attention remains in_progress revision5, with owned local edits in +site/console.js, site/styles.css and src/observability/snapshot.mjs. Separate +Console audit/final real-browser acceptance remain blocked. No dirty work is +touched or inferred abandoned from a presence badge. Wakes remain paused. + +Owner `79720701` requested atomic approval-request idempotency after parallel +Kernel/Runtime recovery duplicates. ONE high-priority proposed existing-backlog +task `TASK-20d313f8-bec3-4926-b9ef-2f0be687e2cc` records project/task/exactcandidate/ +action/resource-set/named-approver keys, retained audit/evidence lineage, strict +scope/revision checks and deterministic concurrency/recovery outcomes. It remains +unassigned after reliability; a preflight query alone cannot prevent a race. +Kernel was routed the proposal, without changing frozen dd62. Owner e854's typed +handoff hardening was routed alongside it after shell interpolation8360/6013; +use structured bound-MCP message arguments, preserve corrected audit and guards. +Neither followup grants authority, creates a new queue or weakens tests. + +## Historical closing coordination at 07:03 UTC Console has now resumed attention implementation as in_progress revision 5 at 07:01:51, preserving its separate blocked audit and final browser gate. Release