From abda08e6cd115db425af8177b002d8e60bfce918 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: thePR0M3TH3AN Date: Wed, 30 Sep 2026 21:20:54 -0400 Subject: [PATCH] TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes: checkpoint qualified scenarios and remaining gates --- .../backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json | 24 +++++-- ...emaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md | 66 +++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 84 insertions(+), 6 deletions(-) create mode 100644 reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json index 4034df4..a13e671 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes.json @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ "observedAt": "d636cae93c5a", "feature": null, "milestone": null, - "state": "in_progress", + "state": "blocked", "owner": "provider-runtime", "evidence": [ "receipt:b346e435-f3e2-45f8-935d-0d4fe67dd3ea:test:pass", @@ -27,14 +27,19 @@ "receipt:6a9197a8-fe6f-4bae-a01b-87e43c65faad:lint:pass", "message:a15b31cf-d9d3-4c7c-8e8e-f45dd1da8902:clean-checkpoint-dashboard-unrun-QA-request", "message:35873142-9510-4dda-b8f4-7893557a726f:late-early-ID-safe-diagnostics-native-boundary-gates", - "message:ee08d4d4-c170-44ae-81be-f26ca7456dda:independent-six-scenarios-not-full-qualification" + "message:ee08d4d4-c170-44ae-81be-f26ca7456dda:independent-six-scenarios-not-full-qualification", + "receipt:9c471c24-28a5-41e5-a6b5-c2024d52d1f0:test:pass:5bbd81a", + "receipt:eb4fe200-c7cb-481d-b8cb-2e9a06739d68:check:pass:5bbd81a", + "receipt:720ef36e-bbf1-461e-882a-68878c78a5b0:lint:pass:5bbd81a", + "message:7b8bab75-d086-4083-9182-a557aae2e429:QA-nine-scenarios-accepted-not-final-integration", + "reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md" ], - "commit": "12e1e33cc80d8babda008e2d65bdcb1f64675e3f", + "commit": "5bbd81a01fa5281ee17c4b4fbafc2e58d1327f7d", "integrationRequest": null, - "blockedReason": null, + "blockedReason": "Clean candidate5bbd81a has exact test/check/lint PASS and QA9/9 acceptance of the pre-launch fail-open concern. Required test-dashboard remains UNRUN/unwaived: artifact-isolation candidatee350 is accepted but unlanded, integrationcce22c51 ready/UNAUTHORIZED pending owner2b2dfb35 after automatic approval-review rejection. No supported peer-source guarded convergence route confirmed. Preserve candidate, old receipts/verdicts and invalid earlier hermetic run; not final integration acceptance. Recovery406ff remains separately pending under interruption hold; no retry, landing, start or wake enablement.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T20:20:17.000Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T00:32:36.466Z", - "revision": 4, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T01:18:42.559Z", + "revision": 5, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -63,6 +68,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T00:32:36.466Z", "note": "Reconcile actual implemented clean checkpoint and immutable three PASS receipts after specialist next returned resume/assigned rev3; do not leave code committed with empty assigned ledger. Work remains in_progress because candidate12e1e33 emits thread ID only at child.close and omits actionable free-form startup diagnostics; owner late review requires early retained identity, allowlisted diagnostics and native spawn/signal/failed-terminal/full CLI-scheduled evidence. Dashboard gate unrun and artifact/convergence dependency unresolved; not verification acceptance or integration readiness. Diagnostics remains blocked, no second active Runtime item, wakes paused, no starts/landing." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T01:18:42.559Z", + "note": "Owner24878d40 requested an authoritative remaining-work handoff using actual QA disposition. Record actual unresolved dashboard/artifact-convergence dependency instead of idle/in_progress with stale12e1e33 candidate. Next lookup returned resume before transition; no task completion or second dispatch. QA7b8 confirms current strict9/9 and cleanworktree; immutable5bb test/check/lint verified, dashboard absent. Preserve all earlier evidence/history." } ] } diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1572d00 --- /dev/null +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +# Current pilot remaining-work handoff + +Reconciled 2026-10-01 01:18 UTC by Session Manager under canonical instruction +digest `0e4eafe9870c7a6d6edd406f248c86b27861a26c1a4329c3fc1d5622b2b56706`. +This is the current coordination handoff; the existing revisioned backlog remains +the only task queue. Earlier reports retain historical evidence. + +Two explicit decision holds and one external browser failure prevent further +qualification. Recommend retaining the candidates and resolving those boundaries +before another development slice or provider start. Resume alone is not consent. + +| Item / owner | Current evidence | Remaining gate and re-entry | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Generated check artifacts / Work and Integration | `e35046908f741799be9e814cecc6470cf1983b86`, clean; backlog ready to integrate revision 6; four exact checks and independent QA accepted | Integration request `cce22c51-1fa8-4324-8e28-bf8cbfc56165` is ready, unauthorized and unlanded. Owner approval `2b2dfb35-46ac-4adb-ac14-5680f7a85e80` remains pending after automatic approval review rejected authorization under the no-landing bundle. No retry or workaround. Only fresh explicit human clarification resolving that conflict permits reconsideration; then reread instructions and exact guards. | +| Executor outcomes / Provider Runtime | `5bbd81a01fa5281ee17c4b4fbafc2e58d1327f7d`, clean; QA accepted 9/9 unchanged scenarios for the pre-launch fail-open concern; exact test/check/lint PASS | Backlog blocked revision 5 on required dashboard gate, UNRUN and unwaived. Accepted artifact dependency remains unlanded; no supported peer-source guarded convergence route is confirmed. After an authorized dependency resolution, converge cleanly, rerun required checks on the resulting exact commit, obtain final QA acceptance and submit exact integration request. No completion or new Runtime assignment. | +| Runtime diagnostics / Provider Runtime | `ae18a98e2911aa515d0484518013061b05ff6adf`; blocked revision 6, code/scenario acceptance and previous receipts retained | Dashboard receipt `214a5830-7238-4188-82bd-eb6e9cd568bc` remains INCOMPLETE after tracked outputs changed, despite exit 0. Resolve artifact/convergence gates and requalify resulting exact commit; do not relabel the old receipt or complete to free a queue. | +| Routine coordination / Project Kernel | `8350e47b0f92f7d41454a8e9a1b59e645b95eefe`; blocked revision 7; exact five PNG changes archived, hashes and public pre-run clean provenance independently verified | Recovery approval `406ff30e-b317-4733-b39e-f63c9a57506d` is pending revision 1. Its attempted QA decision was interrupted; no approval or restoration occurred. Owner hold prohibits retry, cancellation or decision absent fresh human clarification. Earlier `c2a1702b` rejection remains rejected. If clarified, QA owns the exact five-path disposition; Kernel alone applies any approved restoration after rechecking hashes/HEAD/dirty list. Then resolve artifact dependency and exact checks; manual dashboard success is unqualified. | +| Console audit / Owner Console | Blocked revision 5 at `13fe10b765736984d02f6bca02f690d63dbb3a64`; latest clean report-sync HEAD `eab85dd61dd42302d1160b60449d801dbe911dea` | Mobile visual evidence incomplete: `Page.captureScreenshot` timed out. Arbiter's independent fresh read-only tab attempt also failed, saved no image and exposed unstable viewport/DPR behavior; the owned tab was closed and separate viewport reset requested. Do not infer project CSS overflow or exact visual proof. Re-enter only when actual computer-use capture is functional, with verified viewport and inspected images across remaining views. External browser transport repair is outside the audit implementation slice; otherwise retain blocker. No retry loops, generated substitutes or redesign authority. | + +Runtime exact candidate receipts verified by Manager: + +- test: `9c471c24-28a5-41e5-a6b5-c2024d52d1f0`, PASS, exit 0, no invalid reason. +- check: `eb4fe200-c7cb-481d-b8cb-2e9a06739d68`, PASS, exit 0, no invalid reason. +- lint: `720ef36e-bbf1-461e-882a-68878c78a5b0`, PASS, exit 0, no invalid reason. +- QA disposition: `7b8bab75-d086-4083-9182-a557aae2e429`, accepted the + previously blocked pre-launch concern, explicitly not final integration acceptance. +- Release scoped amendment: `b1d4c763-880a-4f9c-9a9e-875be61410bb`, tagged + native-spawn guard in CLI only, exact fixture env/PATH/marker before delegation. + +The earlier actual-CLI attempt that invoked host Codex stays INVALID. Missing +environment now fails before native delegation in the accepted scenario; valid +execution delegates to real native spawn with the isolated fake executable and +observable marker. Neither current passing scenarios nor an idle badge rewrite +the incident or qualify an absent dashboard gate. No tests were edited or run by +Manager. [Incident evidence](runtime-fixture-isolation-incident-report-2026-10-01.md) +and [Kernel provenance](kernel-generated-artifact-provenance-report-2026-10-01.md) +remain retained. + +Canonical is clean at `3ea8d6e47a0a2a0daa20ebfb6c83c41a1ef1a246` on +`rewrite/portable-agent-fleet`. All specialist worktrees are clean except Kernel's +five known PNGs; unique commits and archived outputs are preserved. Default main +was untouched. Roster presence is idle; assignments/blockers are determined by +the ledger. After Runtime's actual gate-block transition, next lookup is idle; +no new item is dispatched. Backlog is 44 tasks: 39 proposed, four blocked and one +ready to integrate. Health remained healthy after this reviewed transition, with +historical activity incomplete/truncated at 1,000 commits. + +Fleet evolution and 30-day hierarchy assessment reach advisory thresholds from +seeded domain overlaps and four coordination requests. Compare process repair, +existing specialist ownership, promotion and a new coordinating role: existing +owners have handled the actual CLI/test boundary and no coherent owner gap is +demonstrated. Retain six specialists, preserve direct peer consent and per-action +receipts; no split, merge, promotion, retirement or activation is justified here. + +Real UX incidents remain task-linked in the existing improvement path: explicit +owner CLI request routing (`TASK-owner-agent-chat`), bounded check preflight +provenance (`TASK-pilot-generated-check-artifacts`), active-turn inbox attention, +and interrupted partial batches (`TASK-pilot-executor-outcomes` / owner chat). +Readback precedes outcome claims; ACK means read, not resolved. These supplements +do not expand implementation authority or create a parallel queue. + +Automatic AI wakes remain paused; machine coordination may queue check-ins. +Managers do not start specialists, alter timers/budgets/models, waive gates, +publish, install, deploy or land. Pipeline work, migration and the other proposed +items remain queued. End this cycle after the checkpoint; resume on a concrete +decision or new evidence rather than recurring model polling.