diff --git a/reports/audit/fleet-arbiter-checkpoint-2026-10-03.md b/reports/audit/fleet-arbiter-checkpoint-2026-10-03.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d9e6f29 --- /dev/null +++ b/reports/audit/fleet-arbiter-checkpoint-2026-10-03.md @@ -0,0 +1,70 @@ +# Fleet arbiter checkpoint — 2026-10-03, 05:58 UTC + +## Outcome + +The owner-approved blocker-clearing directive produced concrete component +commits and exact QA contributor consent. No new verified fleet landing has +been established in this checkpoint. Automatic usage reached the approved +48-turn cap; no additional provider turns were started or budget increased. + +## Decisions and evidence + +- Work committed its read-only convergence component at + `7e0734ae90314b6182046b1d813efd40b453743f`. +- Release committed read-only CLI routing at + `dd77b7015e5d34851725237d6f424babccf7f7d4`. +- QA message `c3f7ac15-5d40-4f85-a27b-6d5837b141a9` approved the exact + compact-card source/test contribution. Actual browser capability remains + unavailable in those native sessions; this is not visual acceptance. +- Arbiter directive `8865db38-a077-4935-a154-7b566d65aa44` authorized + source-only isolated composition without managed-branch convergence or + integration. Corresponding directives were persisted for all implementers. + +## Concrete compatibility failure + +A detached checkout at canonical +`7e3d333c5467c15d72be950f1fac9c3cd5439aee` was created at +`/tmp/torch-readonly-composition-EirOji/candidate`. Applying exactly Kernel +`18ccb0890d93c8a01e2c2d96db775b1ec14fe973` with `cherry-pick -x` produced +content conflicts in `src/control-plane/service.mjs`. Composition stopped; +Work and Release components were not applied, and no composed test PASS is +claimed. The conflicted detached checkout is retained as diagnostic evidence. +Canonical and managed agent checkouts were not altered by this operation. + +The conflicts expose future schema-v3/reservation prerequisites absent from +canonical, which initializes schema version 2. The reader requires +`runtime_launch_reservations`, and its branch-local refusal scenario treats +version 2 as incompatible. Pulling the entire future branch would therefore +broaden this narrow current-branch unblock into an architecture upgrade. + +The existing Kernel reader tests passed 2/2 on the Kernel branch under hermetic +fixtures (`/tmp/torch-reader-component-review-20261003.log`). This is source +review evidence only: it does not establish canonical compatibility, composed +CLI behavior, operational receipts, independent QA, or installed qualification. + +## Next bounded action + +Kernel should supply a current-canonical-compatible reader slice without +future reservation APIs, schema migration or live writer initialization. QA +must approve strict version-relative refusal scenarios, not weaken assertions. +Immutable SQLite observation also needs a demonstrated consistent snapshot or +fail-closed behavior under concurrent writers, not only a sidecar precheck. +Correction request `34a90b11-a64d-4ed7-a7ae-cf2ba8ef46f2` and corresponding +manager/peer requests preserve the exact evidence and composition boundary. + +## Controller handoff + +The old three-slot controller drained without termination. At 05:57:52 UTC, +the replacement seven-slot worker ran, obtained the released controller lock, +and returned `daily-turn-cap` with `launched: []`. This verifies a cap-preserving +handoff, not seven concurrent native workers or reboot persistence. The +replacement timer remains configured; the ledger was not reset. + +## Remaining gates + +Current-base compatible composition, strict composed CLI scenarios, exact +source gates, independent QA, guarded serialized integration and next-work +continuation remain open. Native execution cannot continue today without an +explicit new budget decision; the existing policy resets its daily allowance +at UTC midnight. No deployment, installed-runtime upgrade, live DDL, authority +expansion or completion assertion follows from this checkpoint.