diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json index a539cba..2e4b499 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1", "id": "TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e", "title": "Separate candidate source qualification from live control-plane initialization", - "description": "Explicit owner a970326b-87a5-4292-8f22-e1bec0c15f11/92f7fd36 corrects the inventory: no explicit existing check-engine separation item exists. Add ONE proposed bounded item in the existing backlog. Incident observed on canonical cb145e56 and Kernel reservation candidate be1ae951: candidate CLI initialized production schema3 during qualification, installed/canonical schema2 writers relabel it, and native CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED currentVersion2 requiredVersion3 then prevents qualification, causing activation/landing circularity. Design supported separation of exact candidate-source execution engine from a versioned, independently fingerprinted compatible receipt/control-plane adapter without migrating live production state merely to test candidate. Preserve actual authenticated native project/area/commit/definition/run/resource/guard/outcome evidence and immutable artifacts. Work owns src/checks, Kernel src/control-plane, Release CLI wiring and QA scenarios/acceptance; agree exact contract, owned paths and scenario consent before any implementation. No old-checker shortcut, fake isolated real-project receipts, gate waiver, install activation, production DB recovery, new identity or parallel queue. TASK-4dc metadata/candidate preparation remains completed; its retained deeper provenance roadmap was not an explicit task until this proposal.\n\nCurrent authorized phase (owner36788020/21997bf1, QAa0e8ae17): bounded Phase A implementation preparation/development on this SAME Work assignment. Only NEW src/checks/candidate-engine.mjs and src/checks/artifact-manifest.mjs, new QA-consented test/fleet/candidate-engine.test.mjs and test/fleet/candidate-artifact-manifest.test.mjs, and append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Extract reviewed pure raw-terminal execution and trusted parent artifact-collection seams; frozen inputs/args/env/artifact limits, parent-only observed terminal/envelope with no candidate writer capability, capped canonical regular-file manifest and strict traversal/link/special/overwrite/seal-drift rejection. Hermetic fixture/fake-adapter evidence is permanently development-only/nonpromotable. No existing conditions behavior changes or CheckService/CLI/integration/consumer wiring; no store/provisioner/schema/DDL/receipt-consumer/gate-policy/resource-lease changes, live recovery, installation/host/provider/wake/publication actions. QA remains final test owner. Phase A does not complete this full task or qualify native/operational acceptance. Later Kernel store/context/adapter, Release CLI and Work explicit source-consumer phases remain proposed and require separate scoped decisions; retain actual native guards and all existing full acceptance criteria.\n\nCurrent B1 contribution is separately authorized by actual owner b819ecbc after corrected QA c3e0241 exact-path/scenario consent and Work4a3c8ab6 protocol agreement. SAME Work-owned task, named Kernel contributor only: NEW src/kernel/managed-subject-metadata.mjs, NEW src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs, NEW test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Bounded data-only V1 fixture/untrusted observation parsing, opaque issued fixtures, strict clone/expiry/reuse/selectors-before-parse negatives and explicit missing native composition. V1 refuses parent/native/loaded-engine claims and V2-shaped fields; no fixture promotion. V2 dependency/snapshot binding remains reserved, not implemented parent/consumer authority. Exact source candidate needs independent QA; actual frozen execution, enforced fences, compatible native adapter/consumers and operational acceptance remain mandatory later phases. No DB/DDL/writer/adapter/receipt/parent/consumer/CLI/runtime/host/provider/wake/publication scope. Owner reports existing Kernel active3473803; no new assignment or manager start.", + "description": "Explicit owner a970326b-87a5-4292-8f22-e1bec0c15f11/92f7fd36 corrects the inventory: no explicit existing check-engine separation item exists. Add ONE proposed bounded item in the existing backlog. Incident observed on canonical cb145e56 and Kernel reservation candidate be1ae951: candidate CLI initialized production schema3 during qualification, installed/canonical schema2 writers relabel it, and native CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED currentVersion2 requiredVersion3 then prevents qualification, causing activation/landing circularity. Design supported separation of exact candidate-source execution engine from a versioned, independently fingerprinted compatible receipt/control-plane adapter without migrating live production state merely to test candidate. Preserve actual authenticated native project/area/commit/definition/run/resource/guard/outcome evidence and immutable artifacts. Work owns src/checks, Kernel src/control-plane, Release CLI wiring and QA scenarios/acceptance; agree exact contract, owned paths and scenario consent before any implementation. No old-checker shortcut, fake isolated real-project receipts, gate waiver, install activation, production DB recovery, new identity or parallel queue. TASK-4dc metadata/candidate preparation remains completed; its retained deeper provenance roadmap was not an explicit task until this proposal.\n\nCurrent authorized phase (owner36788020/21997bf1, QAa0e8ae17): bounded Phase A implementation preparation/development on this SAME Work assignment. Only NEW src/checks/candidate-engine.mjs and src/checks/artifact-manifest.mjs, new QA-consented test/fleet/candidate-engine.test.mjs and test/fleet/candidate-artifact-manifest.test.mjs, and append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Extract reviewed pure raw-terminal execution and trusted parent artifact-collection seams; frozen inputs/args/env/artifact limits, parent-only observed terminal/envelope with no candidate writer capability, capped canonical regular-file manifest and strict traversal/link/special/overwrite/seal-drift rejection. Hermetic fixture/fake-adapter evidence is permanently development-only/nonpromotable. No existing conditions behavior changes or CheckService/CLI/integration/consumer wiring; no store/provisioner/schema/DDL/receipt-consumer/gate-policy/resource-lease changes, live recovery, installation/host/provider/wake/publication actions. QA remains final test owner. Phase A does not complete this full task or qualify native/operational acceptance. Later Kernel store/context/adapter, Release CLI and Work explicit source-consumer phases remain proposed and require separate scoped decisions; retain actual native guards and all existing full acceptance criteria.\n\nCurrent B1 contribution is separately authorized by actual owner b819ecbc after corrected QA c3e0241 exact-path/scenario consent and Work4a3c8ab6 protocol agreement. SAME Work-owned task, named Kernel contributor only: NEW src/kernel/managed-subject-metadata.mjs, NEW src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs, NEW test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Bounded data-only V1 fixture/untrusted observation parsing, opaque issued fixtures, strict clone/expiry/reuse/selectors-before-parse negatives and explicit missing native composition. V1 refuses parent/native/loaded-engine claims and V2-shaped fields; no fixture promotion. V2 dependency/snapshot binding remains reserved, not implemented parent/consumer authority. Exact source candidate needs independent QA; actual frozen execution, enforced fences, compatible native adapter/consumers and operational acceptance remain mandatory later phases. No DB/DDL/writer/adapter/receipt/parent/consumer/CLI/runtime/host/provider/wake/publication scope. Owner reports existing Kernel active3473803; no new assignment or manager start.\n\nCurrent B1 exact955672c fixture-source is independently ACCEPTED by QAa13 after actual prefix/blob verification, not native or whole-branch acceptance. Existing9b pre-copy defect and b375 TIN rejection retained. Next concrete B2 packet is in the Manager PhaseB report: named Kernel no-args parent/explicitV2, Work new bounded frozen-input/actual-child execution/fence modules with positive black-box consumption and escaped-descendant coverage scenarios, followed by compatible no-DDL Kernel store/adapter and later actual Work/Release consumers. Exact contributors/scenarios/backend/native compatibility decisions requested; no B2 source authority or new assignment. Full real native/operational criteria remain mandatory.", "priority": "high", "affectedDomains": [ "work-integration", @@ -78,14 +78,20 @@ "git:project-kernel:clean-b375037a9ca5c20704204b52e9ffb3d8060494d9:fourpath-c08-delta-diffcheck-observed16:33", "message:bec5581a-bac8-4e49-b1fa-30aba2abdbe9:existing-QA-exact-b375-independent-review-request", "message:5c0378fa-d323-4808-a6f4-cb834c64acf6:Work-exact-b375-protocol-review-handoff", - "message:c73fb0f6-78bf-40c5-87ae-a61c629f382c:QA-b375-REJECTED-only-TIN-placement-independent10/10-zero-copy-technicalPASS-not-sourceacceptance" + "message:c73fb0f6-78bf-40c5-87ae-a61c629f382c:QA-b375-REJECTED-only-TIN-placement-independent10/10-zero-copy-technicalPASS-not-sourceacceptance", + "message:a13b5c37-12a3-4757-832c-1938b392f962:exact955-B1-fixture-source-ACCEPTED-10strict-c08prefix156398-and-threeblobs-unchanged-not-native-wholebranch", + "message:29e80f3b-48d2-4b36-be7e-648bbc791845:actual-prefixproof-after-EPERM-corrects-earlier9982-chronology", + "message:82157432-0001-4aaa-89e3-9f56ea14486c:Work-exact-B2-input/fence-protocol-decision-request", + "message:6797e181-cfbd-4f70-a370-a5c7d9cc1407:Kernel-exact-B2-parentV2/native-transport-request", + "message:239ebf46-7050-4ae1-be74-2b7f548553cb:QA-positive-parent/realinput/fence-scenario-scope-request", + "report:reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md:17:02-B2a-parent-frozeninput-B2b-fence-B2c-adapter-B2d-nativeconsumers-exact-map" ], "commit": "316d8b7480c2e10925ebdff8310fe26ef5a881a8", "integrationRequest": "a1789e46-b91e-496c-9204-ab204dac6a6d", "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:14:01.401Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T16:39:30.000Z", - "revision": 12, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z", + "revision": 13, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -170,6 +176,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T16:39:30.000Z", "note": "Metadata-only exact QA verdict reconciliation expectedrev11. QAc73 narrowly rejects b375 for inserted23line allocation-correction TIN block at line48 violating append-only rule; independently10/10 focused/syntax/clean/namespace/direct1MiB+1 zero-copy technical evidence passes. Same original scope correction only move exact unchanged block to document end; source/test semantics unchanged, existing Kernel through arbiter and exact resulting QA review. No stale source-acceptance wait/owner permission request or full native acceptance. Preserve9b failure,b375 technicalPASS/rejection,state/owner/316a178/sevencriteria/history." + }, + { + "from": "verification", + "to": "verification", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z", + "note": "Reviewed metadata-only expectedrev12 records actual QAa13 narrow exact955 acceptance and owner29e corrected EPERM chronology; b375 placement wait resolved, no source/native/wholebranch gate waiver. Retain Work verification/316a178/sevencriteria/history. Concrete B2a-d owned-path/positive-scenario/native qualification packet requested from existing peers, no implementation or second assignment." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json index 4050067..d284921 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-console-attention-actions.json @@ -82,14 +82,19 @@ "message:33d44dad-3ab1-4ac4-8b76-8017297decad:independent-exact4fa-source-native-qualification-accepted", "integration:0d46fb5c-1027-4ead-b969-f760afb72e9f:landed2026-10-01T16:25:59.349Z:exact4fa:manager-native-plan-no-blockers", "message:0bf6a212:owner-future-cleanunique-worktree-warning-vs-hazard-distinction", - "message:9ab0e108-ac63-4de8-87fe-8986ec05cf21:future-bounded-overview-and-advisorycount-roadmap-requirement" + "message:9ab0e108-ac63-4de8-87fe-8986ec05cf21:future-bounded-overview-and-advisorycount-roadmap-requirement", + "message:1ece397d-ac61-4d5b-8500-4c26cf7ddc8b:exact-four-sitepath-Overview/newdensitytest/appendTIN-proposal-not-implementation", + "message:1b4836fd-2c3c-4983-957d-daf17cb0e45b:QA-concrete-Overview-positive-fullqueue/guards-scenario-request", + "message:d2feed55-f6dc-4c72-92c3-9b55a39af808:message-cohort/newestdecision/supersession-fullhistory-requirement", + "message:a6b8dfa4-a8b4-43b9-908d-bc8d13f84e1f:usable-Overview-sixpath-five-strict-scenario-consent-crowded49plus17-density1440/390-not-sourceauthority", + "message:06f94f44-4789-47f9-a689-1c6b5c9429d6:actual-current-source-uniqueinfo/Work347baseline-preserve-no-duplicatefix-browser-disconnected-Releaseactive" ], "commit": "4fa9bd7d490fb740eb1d0bdf3dc9cafa2f309ba1", "integrationRequest": "0d46fb5c-1027-4ead-b969-f760afb72e9f", "blockedReason": "Exact 4fa9 source independently accepted by QA33d44dad/6dfa and landed once via native request0d46 at16:25:59 with authorized Manager plan no blockers/four native PASS/eleven hashes. Source review and integration are resolved. Full acceptance remains blocked on actual live/installed desktop/mobile owner flow and served UI/API provenance; generated demo artifact checks do not establish live visual acceptance. Pending human runtime75 is separate from satisfied PNG recovery; pointer switch alone cannot qualify missing blockedReason. No installation, host, provider, wakes, schema or publication action.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T22:56:50.255Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T16:28:00.000Z", - "revision": 18, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z", + "revision": 20, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -216,6 +221,20 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T16:28:00.000Z", "note": "Reviewed metadata-only expected revision17 records actual owner0bf/9ab future requirements on existing attention/workflow roadmap after single source4fa landing. No new task, current source scope expansion, assignment, cleanup or test relaxation. Preserve all original16criteria/state/owner/exact4fa/0d46/history and incomplete actual live acceptance." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z", + "note": "Metadata-only expectedrev18. Actual Console1ece names site/console.html,site/console.js,site/attention-projection.js,site/styles.css plus newQA densitytest/appendTIN proposal; route exact contributor scenarios before later authority. Separate provenance consumer, no implementation expansion/new assignment. Preserve source4fa/0d46 blocked liveacceptance/18criteria/history. Ownerd2feed message grouping retains recipient/permission/history integrity and no massack." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z", + "note": "Metadata-only actualQAa6b usable exact Overview four-sitepath/newdensitytest/appendTIN consent resolves routine contributor hold; five strict scenarios/crowded49+17/density1440x1000/390x844 preserve Work347 baseline and existing Fleet3/runtime.review/kernel.info/qa.urgent. Owner06 confirms unique-info already implemented, no duplicate fix/test relaxation. Later exact arbiter source scope separate; no implementation authority/newassignment/state/sourcecommit change. Actual browser disconnected/full liveacceptance remains open; separate Release implementation active." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json index 022332a..e38df80 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ "schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1", "id": "TASK-conversation-console-workflow", "title": "Complete scoped owner workflow controls and live dashboard qualification", - "description": "Existing Console supports several previewed actions and live refresh. Audit remaining desired owner controls (assignment/routing, lifecycle, integration and release views) against spec and current capabilities; implement only individually authorized operations. Qualify real provider activity and native background/back-cache refresh while preserving edits and private artifact provenance.", + "description": "Existing Console supports several previewed actions and live refresh. Audit remaining desired owner controls (assignment/routing, lifecycle, integration and release views) against spec and current capabilities; implement only individually authorized operations. Qualify real provider activity and native background/back-cache refresh while preserving edits and private artifact provenance.\n\nCurrent partial Release contribution is authorized by owner15c48fa3 under actual QA818/f0bad: ONLY NEW src/self-host/runtime-metadata.mjs, NEW test/fleet/runtime-metadata.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md after guarded clean convergence to4fa. Console retains full owner. Inventory-only internal relative links hash bounded link text without target content traversal; metadata/UI file links refuse; fixed active pointer separate. readerModuleEvaluation reports only reader/local artifact observations, authunknown and memory/delivery null. Native authority and Console consumer/source UI changes excluded. Four exact native source gates/immutable artifacts and independent QA precede single guarded integration. Separate future Overview four-sitepath/newdensitytest and snapshot.mjs consumer proposals require their own exact QA scopes; no code authority from this metadata recording.", "priority": "normal", "affectedDomains": [ "owner-console", @@ -16,7 +16,8 @@ "Live owner flow exposes served UI and API engine version plus exact immutable artifact/source provenance separately from repository HEAD; mixed loaded versions, stale immutable candidates and unavailable provenance are explicitly truthful, never inferred from source PASS or pointer labels", "A later independently qualified current release and actual desktop/mobile live owner flow display each current blocked task's durable blockedReason with provenance; missing or stale runtime fields remain explicit unknown/mismatch. Canonical316 source already contains blockedReason, while reported activealpha2 and immutablealpha3 omit it; alpha3 pointer switch alone does not satisfy this criterion", "Observed local runtime version, declared source commit and recomputed artifact/UI hash consistency remain useful visible diagnostic observations separately from authentication unknown. Local unsigned metadata is not loaded-memory or delivered-browser-byte proof; absent signing infrastructure does not erase observations or prevent bounded dashboard diagnostics. Mixed/stale/unavailable provenance and actual live blockedReason coverage remain explicit.", - "Later independently reviewed compact Overview prioritizes genuine owner decisions and urgent hazards with safe existing quick actions, summary counts and explicit View all Fleet handling destination/filter. Bounded previews retain every item and full evidence in dedicated queue/detail views; advisory/recheck counts are separate from actionable named-next-step counts. Preserve drafts, unsafe risks and show-all access. Owner9ab observed generated1440x1000 d469 desktop artifact, not actual live desktop/mobile acceptance; exact paths/scenarios/QA holdout and authorization precede later edits." + "Later independently reviewed compact Overview prioritizes genuine owner decisions and urgent hazards with safe existing quick actions, summary counts and explicit View all Fleet handling destination/filter. Bounded previews retain every item and full evidence in dedicated queue/detail views; advisory/recheck counts are separate from actionable named-next-step counts. Preserve drafts, unsafe risks and show-all access. Owner9ab observed generated1440x1000 d469 desktop artifact, not actual live desktop/mobile acceptance; exact paths/scenarios/QA holdout and authorization precede later edits.", + "Future reviewed message/thread UX supports version-pinned shared contract or artifact references with concise attributable recipient-specific decision/delta, exact permission provenance/current task revision and explicit supersession, retaining all recipients/history/failed decisions and full referenced content. Grouping never auto-acknowledges/resolves/discards messages or hides older failures; newest actionable decisions remain accessible. Pagination/unread completeness uses existing Kernel565/Runtimee440 identity-bound observation contract. Ownerd2feed aggregate115messages/275123bodybytes/22repeatedgroups-cover57 since16:00 is local traffic evidence, not provider token/cost data or proof multi-recipient copies are invalid." ], "observedAt": "ff0712534829", "feature": "Self-host development readiness", @@ -93,14 +94,24 @@ "message:83cb229d-9d46-4cc2-ab38-7f0387792ec7:Kernel-displayonly-native-authority-exclusion-request", "message:d1750568-6205-4bd6-912c-dd03dadf36ab:Console-fixed14allowlist-and-consumer-review-request", "message:9adfc75d-69eb-4da3-b8bc-d081fcb1f63f:Release-exact-scope/hash/vector-corrections", - "message:02981960-924b-40ac-817f-6052adaeabc5:QA-exact-threepath/vector-scenario-request-after-existing-B1-review" + "message:02981960-924b-40ac-817f-6052adaeabc5:QA-exact-threepath/vector-scenario-request-after-existing-B1-review", + "message:8184bc03-40b8-431e-b7ec-86b3949148ff:actual-Release-threepath-eightscenario-contributor-consent", + "message:f0bad6b0-8769-420d-bc1e-3424f41770ef:usable-inventorylinktext-hash-vs-metadata/UIlink-refusal-addendum", + "message:15c48fa3-ec5d-4358-95e5-4356e125de26:owner-exact-threepath-Release-implementation-authorized-after-guardedconvergence-no-consumeredits", + "message:e7fa7fe6-0b2b-40e0-88a0-7699e5eb11ce:existing-Release-exact-authorization-handoff", + "message:1ece397d-ac61-4d5b-8500-4c26cf7ddc8b:concrete-Console-four-sitepath-Overview-vs-separate-snapshotconsumer-proposal", + "message:1b4836fd-2c3c-4983-957d-daf17cb0e45b:QA-newdensitytest/appendTIN-and-distinct-consumer-scope-decision-request", + "message:2cf2c03c-a290-42f8-91cb-5c5496fe37ba:readerModuleEvaluation-not-Consoleloadedengine-claim", + "message:d2feed55-f6dc-4c72-92c3-9b55a39af808:aggregate-local115messages275123bodybytes22repeatedgroups57messages-since16:00-not-providercost", + "message:a6b8dfa4-a8b4-43b9-908d-bc8d13f84e1f:usable-Overview-sixpath-five-strict-scenario-consent-crowded49plus17-density1440/390-not-sourceauthority", + "message:06f94f44-4789-47f9-a689-1c6b5c9429d6:actual-current-source-uniqueinfo/Work347baseline-preserve-no-duplicatefix-browser-disconnected-Releaseactive" ], "commit": "e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891", "integrationRequest": "6cbac9cb-445f-45d7-8bb1-10902e840211", "blockedReason": "Exact e8c source QA acceptance and native6cb serialized landing remain RESOLVED with four native PASS/11 hashes. Attention cohort exact4fa is independently QA accepted and natively landed once0d46; canonical4fa is clean as observed16:27, not whole-workflow acceptance. Actualownereb1 live4174 eight blocked entries omit blockedReason: activealpha2 and immutablealpha3 omit a field already present canonical316. Served UI/APIengine exact version/artifact/source provenance must be distinct from repositoryHEAD and truthful for mixed/stale/unknown state; alpha3switch75 alone cannot qualify current UI. Full workflow remains blocked on later qualified current release and actual live/installed/desktop/mobile owner-flow/full-criteria acceptance; current owner browser list remains empty. Source/demo artifact PASS is not live acceptance. Human75 remains pending revision1; PNG recovery is not activation. No install/restart/hotpatch/host/provider/wake/schema action.", "createdAt": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.720Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T16:38:00.000Z", - "revision": 19, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z", + "revision": 21, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -234,6 +245,20 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T16:38:00.000Z", "note": "Metadata-only expectedrev18 records complete actual Release5d377 proposal/vector addendum and owner ee430 precise scope/spec corrections. Future exact contribution only new src/self-host/runtime-metadata.mjs, new QA-owned test/fleet/runtime-metadata.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md; excludes proposed test/fleet/TIN. Preserve actual candidate recursive per-directory localeCompare inventory traversal and raw hash preimage, any.git/rootvalidation exclusions; independent nested/case/punctuation vectors reject changed ordering. Full contract forwarded existing QA/Kernel/Console with no code authority/new task/assignment. Useful observations separate authentication unknown, no native E/S/A/memory/deliveredbyte claim, no DB/status/reconcile. All state/owner/e8/request/sevencriteria/history retained." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z", + "note": "Metadata-only expectedrev19. Actual QA818/f0bad resolves Release contributor/link precision; actual owner15c48 grants bounded named Release implementation on SAMEworkflow, not fullowner transfer/lifecycle/new assignment or consumer edits. Preserve blocked state/e8 request/fullcriteria/history and actual live/API/browser gaps. Record concrete Console separate Overview/consumer scopes and ownerd2feed message UX requirement; existing roadmap only, no source/schema permission or summary replacing attributable authority." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z", + "note": "Metadata-only actualQAa6b usable exact Overview four-sitepath/newdensitytest/appendTIN consent resolves routine contributor hold; five strict scenarios/crowded49+17/density1440x1000/390x844 preserve Work347 baseline and existing Fleet3/runtime.review/kernel.info/qa.urgent. Owner06 confirms unique-info already implemented, no duplicate fix/test relaxation. Later exact arbiter source scope separate; no implementation authority/newassignment/state/sourcecommit change. Actual browser disconnected/full liveacceptance remains open; separate Release implementation active." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-e440d8c1-479b-418e-bb0f-a693594d891c.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-e440d8c1-479b-418e-bb0f-a693594d891c.json index d36aec8..4607339 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-e440d8c1-479b-418e-bb0f-a693594d891c.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-e440d8c1-479b-418e-bb0f-a693594d891c.json @@ -19,7 +19,8 @@ "Exact clean candidate checks, independent QA acceptance and guarded serialized integration are required; no fixture-only output, omitted unread filter or acknowledgement counts substitute for real current evidence.", "Before publishing a final blocked/waiting-on-approval/needs-owner report, refresh authoritative unread inbox, current named permission and task evidence; distinguish a timestamped earlier observation from current state and reconcile already-resolved routine waits without asking the owner again. A mechanical observation-watermark/status protocol, if needed, requires an owned reviewed proposal before schema/API implementation.", "Before a failed-check repair/check iteration, refresh the current authoritative brief, actual addressed unread inbox, current task and named consent revisions; apply already-resolved peer direction before further edits or checks. A pending wheel/rAF/scrollend stimulus or an acknowledged historical handoff cannot substitute for current instructions, justify trial timing patches, weakened assertions, duplicate dispatch or a missing-owner-permission claim. Preserve strict behavior, failed receipts and attributable historical evidence; any new mechanical refresh/status protocol needs separately reviewed owned scope.", - "Before classifying a same-task contribution as duplicate, completed or waiting, refresh the actual addressed unread inbox and compare the exact named current handoff, candidate and requested scope with superseded/completed contributions, even when the task revision is unchanged. Startup/resume UX must distinguish a stale orchestration hint from a pending current contribution and show its provenance; a reused followup flag or terminal old contribution cannot close a new handoff. Any mechanical handoff/version/status schema or activation change remains a separately reviewed owned proposal." + "Before classifying a same-task contribution as duplicate, completed or waiting, refresh the actual addressed unread inbox and compare the exact named current handoff, candidate and requested scope with superseded/completed contributions, even when the task revision is unchanged. Startup/resume UX must distinguish a stale orchestration hint from a pending current contribution and show its provenance; a reused followup flag or terminal old contribution cannot close a new handoff. Any mechanical handoff/version/status schema or activation change remains a separately reviewed owned proposal.", + "Future reviewed coordination-message reference/pagination UX keeps immutable version-pinned full contracts accessible while returning concise attributable recipient-specific current decision/delta with explicit supersession and exact permission/task revision. Newest actionable decisions are not obscured by repeated long contracts; all recipients, unacknowledged pages, older failed decisions and identity-bound complete/truncated observation remain intact through Kernel565. No summary, repeated-body cohort, read/ack count or historical page can imply resolution, complete unread coverage or transferred approval. Local aggregate traffic is not provider cost/token evidence; this is a requirement only, no new API/schema/code scope." ], "observedAt": "0fdfcb3b68e4511f2993d03e1fff8f89124b731c", "feature": "Identity-bound inbox selection and observation integrity", @@ -36,14 +37,15 @@ "message:22df881a-9d38-4706-b0bf-da05c6b674c8:Console12:22-stale-QA-wait-after12:19-consent", "message:c9bd14d0-f006-4b65-9f4e-54c77c58cb42:failed-check-recovery-current-brief-unread-consent-refresh-boundary", "receipt:8ac4a6ab-99b9-4fa5-a941-eac1d03842ba:a7e84cf:fail507-vs327-after-resolved-QA8009-numeric-stimulus", - "message:7a6eb8ca-bc61-4b1e-860b-d4f87f521855:reused-arbiter-followup-flag-obscured-new-Work2f8-Manager5ab-attempt-store-contribution" + "message:7a6eb8ca-bc61-4b1e-860b-d4f87f521855:reused-arbiter-followup-flag-obscured-new-Work2f8-Manager5ab-attempt-store-contribution", + "message:d2feed55-f6dc-4c72-92c3-9b55a39af808:measured-115messages275123bytes22repeatgroups57messages-reference/pagination-UX-requirement-no-autoack" ], "commit": null, "integrationRequest": null, "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:32:53.996Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T13:28:26.706Z", - "revision": 6, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z", + "revision": 7, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -86,6 +88,13 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T13:28:26.706Z", "note": "Owner 7a6eb8ca explicitly requests existing stale-brief/task-startup UX recording of exact named current handoff versus superseded/completed/pending contribution, including shared arbiter orchestration incident. Reviewed metadata-only amendment, expected revision5. Preserve owner/state/candidate/dependencies, eight prior criteria and full history. Native service has no metadata-amend operation; no lifecycle transition, new task/assignment, API/status/schema implementation, provider launch or acceptance." + }, + { + "from": "assigned", + "to": "assigned", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z", + "note": "Reviewed metadata-only expectedrev6 at explicit ownerd2feed existing inbox/coordination requirement. Runtime retains assigned e440/no candidate and Kernel565 blocked source/native history; append one strict sharedreference/supersession/pagination requirement/evidence preserving ninecriteria/fullhistory. No second assignment,new backlog,providerstart,API/schema/code permission,autoack or fabricated token/cost measurement." } ] } diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index 6dfb3d1..b8328ab 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,5 +1,102 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff +## Actual usable Overview consent and current browser boundary, 17:07 UTC + +Actual **QAa6b8dfa4** grants named Console contribution on four site paths plus +NEW density test and appenddocsTIN, preserving five strict priority/count/fullqueue/ +draft/owner/nav scenarios and crowded49advisory+17Fleet geometry1440x1000/390x844. +Existing driver/fixtures/goldens/tests excluded, Work347 refresh and Fleet3/runtime.review/ +kernel.info/qa.urgent unchanged. Owner06 confirms clean-unique worktree information +already exists in current source; do not implement a duplicate fix. Workflow21 and +attention20 record usable consent, not a source implementation decision or assignment. +Console receives exact decision; no stale QA wait. Separate Release contribution +is actually active per owner06, no consumer edits. User browser connection request +is already pending through arbiter; actual browser disconnected/liveDesktopMobile +unverified, not another user question here. Activation75 remains genuine human wait. + +## Current B1 verdict, concrete B2 and authorized Release slice, 17:04 UTC + +Fresh installed Manager brief **d7e6d69**, explicit addressed unread100 and all56 +tasks refreshed; native check-in16:55 is observational, not proof of process absence. +Canonical remains clean **4fa9bd7d490fb740eb1d0bdf3dc9cafa2f309ba1**; its single +Console0d46 landing and arbiter development-ref push are resolved. cce still +needs_convergence, duplicatec532 ready/unauthorized and proposedc178 are preserved. +No new landing/request or task completion occurred. + +Actual **QA a13b5c37** narrowly ACCEPTS B1 fixture-source exact clean +**955672c1db15ebde99788eaa87759b6020de5d25**:10 strict scenarios, c08 document prefix +156398 bytes unchanged, three B1 source/test blobs unchanged and exact TIN body +relocated to end. Manager observes clean exact955 with b375..955 docs-only delta. +Owner **29e80f3b** corrects earlier9982: initial child-git probe failed spawnSyncEPERM; +legitimate retry subsequently verifies prefix SHA5c595f1c and unchanged blobs. +Do not turn the earlier premature statement into PASS. Retain9b copy failure and +b375 placement rejection. SAME6e4 verification13, Work full owner, landed316/a178 +and all seven native/operational criteria stay intact; B1 review is resolved, no +whole-branch/native/integration/full-task acceptance. + +Concrete **B2a-d implementation packet** is pinned in the PhaseB report's17:02 +section: Kernel no-args candidate-source-parent and explicit contextV2, Work new +bounded input-snapshot/source-execution/fence modules, then Kernel compatible +store/receipt-adapter and actual Work/Release consumers. Exact paths/quotas/interfaces, +positive real child input consumption after source mutation, snapshot UNKNOWN, +E/A substitution and real setsid/double-fork descendant fence scenarios are named. +Candidate fence backend is ephemeral PID namespace with fixed init lifetime, +subject to actual platform qualification; absent coverage yields no TerminalProof, +never PGID-only PASS or same-user containment claim. No platform activation or +registered DDL/code permission. Existing Work82157432/Kernel6797e181/QA239ebf46 +receive concrete contributor/protocol/backend decisions, not a generic design loop. +Future native adapter must independently prove actual compatible schema/writer/ +identity/CAS/receipt transport; legacy2 and required3/current2 refusal remain. +Fixtures/all-refusal are not permanent substitutes for the complete real path. + +Actual **QA8184bc03** three-path/eight-scenario Release consent plus **f0bad6b0** +link addendum is now usable. Seven admitted immutablealpha3 internal .bin links +motivate hash-only inventory lstat/bounded readlink text with existing raw path/type/ +mode/link-text preimage, no target-content traversal; relative internal existing +permitted entry only. External/absolute/dangling/invalid/oversize/special cases refuse +without partial match. Metadata and UI files remain no-follow regular-only; fixed +runtime/active is a separate bounded intentional link. readerModuleEvaluation does +not prove Console server bytes; authunknown and loaded-memory/delivery null remain. + +Actual owner **15c48fa3** now authorizes named Release contribution on SAMEworkflow: +guarded clean convergence to4fa, ONLY NEW src/self-host/runtime-metadata.mjs, NEW +test/fleet/runtime-metadata.test.mjs, append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md, strict scenarios/ +hash ordering/caps, clean task-named commit then four fresh exact native source +checks/immutable artifacts and independent QA before one guarded request. Manager +**e7fa7fe6** routes that exact authority. Arbiter manually resumes existing Release; +Manager starts none. Console retains full owner, workflow blocked20 for full live +criteria; no consumer edits or runtime75/host/schema authorization. + +Actual Console **1ece397d** pins separate future Overview: four site paths +console.html/console.js/attention-projection.js/styles.css, NEW QA density test and +append TIN; owner/urgent first, exact actionable/advisory counts, bounded preview +and full Fleet filter/detail reachability preserving all records, ten destinations, +drafts/current preview/deep links/Back/Forward/mobile/unsafe hazards. Manager1b4836fd +requests exact QA additive consent before separate implementation decision. +Separate provenance consumer is snapshot.mjs no-args helper/display-only observeProject +object; server.mjs snapshot transport remains unchanged. Helper cannot authenticate +loaded API engine, and consumer needs distinct named QA scenario/path scope. +Existing attention blocked19/source4fa and workflow20 own these phases, not duplicates. + +Owner **d2feed55** measures115 messages/275123 local body bytes since16:00, +max13362 bytes,11 bodies>8000,22 repeated groups covering57 messages. These are +aggregate local traffic, not provider token/cost measurement or invalid-copy proof. +Existing workflow20/Runtime e440 assigned7 record version-pinned full contract +references with concise recipient-specific decision/delta, explicit supersession +and current permission/revision; all recipient ownership/history/failed decisions +and unread/page completeness remain readable. Kernel565 remains blocked/native +unqualified. No autoack/close/discard or summary-as-permission behavior is authorized. + +Evolution eight recurring boundaries and hierarchy ten signals favor precise +interfaces/reference process/scenario ownership among the existing six specialists, +over a new role, promotion, split or merge; no activation/proposal needed on current +evidence. Health49 stale observations/two resolved-dependency warnings remain surfaced +without auto-fix. Full56 roadmap:39 proposed,9 blocked,6 completed,1 Work verification, +1 Runtime assigned; no extra active assignment. Human approval75 remains pending1, +PNG recovery satisfied. Latest peer browser/live-installed-alpha2 evidence remains +unqualified; source4fa and an alpha3 switch do not prove blockedReason/live UI. +No peer source edits, DB/schema, installation, host/provider/wake or publication. + ## Actual B1 QA verdict and exact corrective handoff, 16:39 UTC Actual **QAc73fb0f6** narrowly REJECTS exactb375 only for TIN placement: the diff --git a/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md b/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md index cc29dc9..639f0d5 100644 --- a/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md @@ -10,6 +10,118 @@ no new assignment, identity, queue or full-task closure is requested here. Current authoritative brief is d7e6d69. Kernel's proposed sections18/20 and ADR026 at 6fdb88ea supply design context, not normative gate changes. +## Current B1 acceptance and concrete B2 implementation packet, 17:02 UTC + +Actual QA **a13b5c37-12a3-4757-832c-1938b392f962** ACCEPTS only clean exact +**955672c1db15ebde99788eaa87759b6020de5d25** B1 fixture source:10/10 strict scenarios, +156398-byte c08 document prefix unchanged, three B1 source/test blobs unchanged, +allocation correction body unchanged and physically final. Preserve9b pre-copy +failure and b375 placement rejection. Owner29e verifies the prefix/blob proof only +after a legitimate retry of initial child-git spawnSync EPERM; the earlier9982 +claim preceded completed verification and is not retrospective PASS evidence. +No native/whole-branch/integration/full-task acceptance follows. Full6e4 remains +Work-owned verification at landed316/a178; B1 acceptance closes this source review. + +The following is a concrete proposed implementation packet on SAME task, with +named peer decisions requested82157432/6797e181/239ebf46. It grants no code authority. +It advances real composition; fixtures and blanket refusals are not the endpoint. +Each row requires exact contributor/scenario consent and separate arbiter scope +authorization. No new assignment, registered DDL or host activation is requested. + +| Phase | Exact proposed source paths | Owner and deliverable | Exact proposed QA paths | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| B2a parent and input composition | NEW src/kernel/candidate-source-parent.mjs; additive explicitly V2 surface in src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs; NEW src/checks/candidate-input-snapshot.mjs; NEW src/checks/candidate-source-execution.mjs | Kernel fixed no-args parent/binding; Work bounded file snapshot and real child consumption. Do not change existing fixtureV1 or existing CheckService/CLI consumers. | NEW test/fleet/candidate-source-parent.test.mjs; NEW test/fleet/candidate-input-consumption.test.mjs; additive V2-only cases in test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs; append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md | +| B2b attributable terminal coverage | NEW src/checks/candidate-execution-fence.mjs; only its reviewed integration seam in new candidate-source-execution.mjs | Work fixed fence backend, parent-only observed exit/coverage proof and strict UNKNOWN handling. No resource/lease policy edits. | NEW test/fleet/candidate-execution-fence.test.mjs; append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md | +| B2c store/adapter and native transport | src/control-plane/candidate-attempt-store.mjs; src/control-plane/candidate-attempt-store-provisioner.mjs; NEW src/control-plane/check-receipt-adapter.mjs | Kernel exact versioned no-DDL finalizer/adapter and compatibility/provisioner qualification. B0 fixture issuance is not registered authority. | additive test/fleet/candidate-attempt-store.test.mjs; NEW test/fleet/check-receipt-adapter.test.mjs; append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md | +| B2d actual consumers and release qualification | later separately scoped src/checks/service.mjs, src/integration/service.mjs and src/cli.mjs | Work existing consumer/gate semantics; Release fixed CLI-to-parent binding, only after actual compatible native transport proves exact receipts. | QA independently pins actual service/CLI/integration scenarios before any edits | + +Ownership queries confirm Kernel src/kernel/** and src/control-plane/**, Work +src/checks/**, Console src/observability/**/src/console/**, QA test/**. The specific +future check-receipt-adapter name preserves the existing reviewed map, not the +alternative candidate-receipt-adapter sketch. Existing files outside the listed +later rows remain excluded; no implicit permission to wire a consumer. + +B2a contract to pin before source: openCandidateSourceParentV1() has zero caller +arguments; derives its fixed installed module and actual startup working directory, +validates install/project/managed common-dir/registered branch/clean source, and +retains opaque parent state. A registered identity issuer must be an actual reviewed +bound native seam; branch labels, caller JSON, private WeakMaps and same-user access +are not authentication. CanonicalCheckSubjectEsaBytesV2 or explicitly named successor +binds E interface/module plus fixed entry and dependency-manifest length/SHA; A +declaration bytes/schema/interface plus actual adapter entry/dependency length/SHA; +S project/commit/clean tree, snapshot-policy and frozen-manifest digests, total input +bytes/count. Inputs include definition/args/allowlisted env and run/guard generations +at admission. private inputRoot never crosses caller serialization. Pre/post fixed +E/A reads detect substitution; disk re-read is not loaded-memory attestation. + +Work's snapshot is a NEW bounded stream/copy seam, not a declaration that existing +snapshot.mjs or PhaseA input.directory is qualified. Proposed concrete maxima to +ratify:8192 input records,64MiB per regular file,512MiB aggregate,4096 UTF8 path bytes, +1MiB descriptor/manifest frame. Enforce original lengths/counters before allocation, +no symlink/special/traversal, owned unique scratch outside source, explicit canonical +relative-path/byte/mode records and policy-version digest. Streaming copies and +pre/post source/frozen manifests detect drift; they do not prove an atomic directory +snapshot or same-user filesystem containment. Worker cwd is ONLY private snapshot +inputRoot, never caller input.directory. Fixed trusted command/dependencies come +from reviewed parent E binding; candidate child receives no writer/DB/adapter token. +Do not reuse copied-byte descriptor truth as proof that real files were consumed. + +B2b backend decision must cover escaped sessions/descendants. A proposed concrete +candidate is an ephemeral Linux PID namespace with fixed reviewed namespace-init +wrapper lifetime: every descendant stays in that namespace, init termination ends +its population; parent holds namespace identity/generation and observes closure. +This mechanism must first be supported and independently qualified in the approved +execution environment, with bounded output/time/signal cancellation; no host-service, +cgroup/timer setup or provider launch is authorized. Work must accept this backend +or name a precise already available enforceable alternative and ownership. No +fallback to process-group emptiness, kill-command exit, process name or fake fence. +If namespace creation/coverage/lifetime is denied or unknown, return UNKNOWN with +no TerminalProof/PASS and retain attributable run evidence. This is descendant +lifetime coverage, not protection from a malicious same-user outside process. + +Positive black-box scenarios, not only forged-input refusal: + +1. Actual child reads known captured files via relative paths from snapshot cwd and + emits their contents/digest. Alter original worktree after capture via deterministic + barrier; child still emits original captured bytes. Include nested files and a + file larger than1MiB so descriptor size cannot substitute for product consumption. +2. Alter frozen snapshot before or during execution: manifest verification yields + UNKNOWN/refusal and no eligible result/receipt; no source-policy relaxation. +3. Fixed parent captures E/A, then same-ID entry/dependency bytes change before import + or after execution: substitution refuses. Positive unchanged pre/post tuple passes + context admission only with an actual issued binding; JSON/spread clones do not. +4. Real child creates a setsid/double-fork descendant that waits beyond its direct + parent's exit. Supported fence observes containment/termination; parent cannot + finalize while coverage is open. Unknown coverage and PGID-only fake each refuse. +5. Known-good confined run with unchanged files and sealed artifact produces one + attributable terminal proof. Timeout/signal/error/ENOBUFS/overflow, zero-exit drift, + stale generation and cancellation ambiguity cannot yield eligible PASS. +6. Actual supported adapter on exact compatible schema/tuple finalizes one sealed + attempt/result/eligible receipt atomically; duplicate/replay and interrupted CAS + preserve history without second receipt or ambiguous retry. Wrong adapter/schema + and fixture authority refuse. Fixture positive transaction is separately labelled. + +B2c has additional executable prerequisites, not a prose waiver: exact DDL bytes +and canonical semantic schema digest; compatible existing receipt-table/writer +matrix; authenticated native identity/attempt transport; issued->executing->sealed +->finalized CAS; result and eligible receipt in one short transaction; ambiguous +commit/read-only reconcile policy; writer/lease/fence generation evidence. Inspect +and independently qualify actual compatible registered adapter state without +opening a migrating initializer. Current required3/schema2 refusal remains intact; +any missing registered store or DDL recovery is a separate genuine decision with +exact state/risk evidence. Never copy fixture receipts, assume old installed engine +equivalence or alter exactPasses to land. Native receipts can qualify an unlanded +clean candidate only through that supported protocol; post-landing-only receipts +would recreate the circular gate. Full four exact source checks/current definitions, +immutable artifacts, independent QA and native serialized landing remain required. + +Immediate peer decisions are concrete: Work ratifies snapshot/execution APIs, +quotas and one supported fence backend; Kernel pins V2 bytes and real bound issuer/ +adapter transport compatibility; QA grants exact listed test/contribution scopes +and positive barrier/descendant/CAS scenarios; Release pins later fixed parent CLI +invocation. Source code remains unauthorized pending those decisions and the +arbiter's bounded scope choice. This packet retains the complete real native path. + ## Actual B1 four-path authorization and real composition roadmap, 16:29 UTC Latest16:39 **QAc73fb0f6** REJECTS b375 narrowly for append-only TIN placement: