diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-565fa463-c9b0-49e6-a902-9f12a49b6615.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-565fa463-c9b0-49e6-a902-9f12a49b6615.json index b9ba89b..55bccf8 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-565fa463-c9b0-49e6-a902-9f12a49b6615.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-565fa463-c9b0-49e6-a902-9f12a49b6615.json @@ -21,21 +21,28 @@ "observedAt": "0fdfcb3b68e4511f2993d03e1fff8f89124b731c", "feature": "Unread-first inbox dependency", "milestone": "Before Runtime inbox integration and dormant service components", - "state": "assigned", + "state": "in_progress", "owner": "project-kernel", "evidence": [ "message:7abee039-9bde-4706-9876-4e50385d9ddb:Runtime-wrapper-contract", "message:da0d22aa-0796-489f-b485-fd0c3dfef723:Kernel-owned-reviewed-API/separate-assignment-needed", "message:1dfe8f90-a381-469a-9041-915480cf4bce:QA-exact-Kernel-source/test-contribution-and-strict-scenarios", "TASK-1e688a36-9df7-47ad-a540-99de15979717:blocked4:sequenced-after-inbox", - "current-brief:d7e6d69:read-before-this-item" + "current-brief:d7e6d69:read-before-this-item", + "message:b952872d-40d2-4096-b942-a6df1d1dc9df:implemented-export-focused-evidence-real-source-gate-refusal", + "message:44512241-b862-4695-b7fd-2aa0851116c9:hermetic-WAL-mutant-survives-six-scenarios", + "message:6e4ae798-5847-4dc4-878a-444748c52669:QA-test/doc-only-mutation-killing-strengthening", + "message:019aff91-71f5-42c2-9573-c1abd1b45c6b:same-assignment-bounded-strengthening", + "message:44c76670-194b-4011-83bc-a03872fa0188:7908d1b-amended-clean-source-unchanged-original/mutant/restored-evidence-and-refusal", + "git:7908d1b:only-test/fleet/control-plane.test.mjs-and-docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md-delta-from-f67:independently-inspected", + "message:c55359eb-08e8-45be-8ed5-4b2902fae52c:independent-both-mutants-fail-remaining-leading-whitespace-DML-count-gap" ], - "commit": null, + "commit": "7908d1b06e701184c04fedefaf3af977422ae976", "integrationRequest": null, "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:57:51.775Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T10:58:59.162Z", - "revision": 3, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T11:25:28.661Z", + "revision": 6, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -57,6 +64,27 @@ "actorId": "session-manager", "at": "2026-10-01T10:58:59.162Z", "note": "Fresh current brief/ownership and native next readyTHIS/no active Kernel assignment after inventory blocked4; actual prior Kernel branch clean e8e33f1, preserve unique reservation/design commits. Assign actual da0/954701d4 observeMessages API dependency of e440. Implement ONLY src/control-plane/service.mjs plus exact QA1dfe-consented additive test/fleet/control-plane.test.mjs; keep legacy readMessages ASC/history array, one shared SQLite observation snapshot, strict registered recipient/selection/limit, literal all visibility, zero DML/ack and no source schema guard/version alteration. Return exact API/candidate and strict Test Integrity Note through agreed destination/review note; unconsented doc edits forbidden. Runtime only later consumes Kernel export, no Kernel contribution permission to Runtime. Fresh source gates/independent QA/native integration policy remain required; real schema/engine/tool refusal blocks qualification, fixture tests alone never PASS receipt. Inventory1e688 remains blocked4 contract pending; reservation125 blocked5 preserved, no duplicate active Kernel item or live DB/host/install/activation/provider action. Arbiter controls provider turn." + }, + { + "from": "assigned", + "to": "in_progress", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T11:18:15.617Z", + "note": "Record actual implemented Kernel observeMessages at clean f67f47f; continuing SAME assignment only for exact QA-authorized WAL mutation-killing test/doc strengthening. This is an open implementation-validation phase, not ready/accepted/completed. Owner445 actual audit INSERT mutant survives6/6 because state.db comparison omits WAL; no evidence actual SELECT source writes. Preserve all original assertions; assert actual connection DML zero and logical durable-state equality, original implementation PASS/mutant FAIL for forbidden-read mutation. Exact test/fleet/control-plane.test.mjs plus additive docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md, confirm actual named QA6d9 constraints. Source guard CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED current2 required3 remains unresolved genuine qualification blocker; no native PASS/integration request or installation/live schema recovery. Runtime task stays assigned3, inventory1e688 and reservation125 remain blocked; no duplicate active Kernel item." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T11:23:03.969Z", + "note": "Actual Kernel amendment finished during this cycle; refresh native task and clean exact Git state before recording genuine blocked qualification outcome. Preserve f67 candidate/history, all original scenarios/assertions and owner445 mutant gap, complete acceptance criteria and owner. Manager inspected exact two-path diff/logical-state+connection instrument assertions, but did not run tests or grant independent QA acceptance. Candidate source exists; native schema refusal/no required exact receipts still real. Blocked state frees no automatic new assignment; inventory contract remains unresolved and no specialist launched." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "in_progress", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T11:25:28.661Z", + "note": "Fresh actual owner independent7908 review: normal6/6 PASS/helper audit mutant FAIL on instrumented calls/direct multilineINSERT mutant FAIL on logical equality. A precise remaining zero-DML instrumentation gap requires existing test/doc-only strengthening on SAME task: leading whitespace after start-of-string is not classified; count actual direct multilineINSERT and preserve every existing assertion/source/schema behavior. Resume bounded test-only correction within actual QA6d9/6e4 consent, no new assignment/provider turn or production source edits. Real native schema2/3 refusal remains an unresolved qualification gate, not waived by these source results. Return amended exact candidate and independent review before acceptance." } ] } diff --git a/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json b/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json index d26866d..dc43002 100644 --- a/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json +++ b/.torch/backlog/TASK-conversation-console-workflow.json @@ -29,14 +29,31 @@ "evidence:existing-console-ux-audit-and-live-console-arbiter-audit", "message:46d4a7a7-4c03-431a-a967-6136af2478f8:arbiter-accepts-design37f4/exact-three-source-paths;reports-QA6ce049-consent", "message:6ce049e1-9021-4c9f-9b4b-8f8ff3f9768c:named-QA-additive-path/scenarios-consent-as-attested-by-arbiter", - "current-brief:d7e6d69:read-before-same-task-implementation-resume" + "current-brief:d7e6d69:read-before-same-task-implementation-resume", + "source-cli:test:c5886fee-55bc-44f1-9e03-dcf9f537e182:PASS:commit=a67a04d57f400782b01ba6087b9741fb0c54e21f", + "source-cli:check:d62d880d-320d-4162-bd9c-9c86e5461008:PASS:commit=a67a04d57f400782b01ba6087b9741fb0c54e21f", + "source-cli:test-dashboard:713f8acc-5315-4f98-a5cb-7465d57ff3a5:FAIL:commit=a67a04d57f400782b01ba6087b9741fb0c54e21f:output=/home/user/.local/share/torch/projects/3dc11932-6e3c-42aa-9a8a-ca7b8f818b54/checks/713f8acc-5315-4f98-a5cb-7465d57ff3a5/output.json", + "source-cli:lint:6d3df011-e16b-4916-98b1-d0cfd8f375fc:PASS:commit=a67a04d57f400782b01ba6087b9741fb0c54e21f", + "systemd-parser:executed-in-source-test-with-XDG_RUNTIME_DIR=/run/user/1000:uid1000:mode0700:no-service-activation", + "qa-consent-read:55f0abd8-6de7-4757-947c-8015d9ef94b1:already-acknowledged", + "qa-question:737efaa4-88e6-42f0-a504-5065a4122843:title-assertion-versus-router-initial-title", + "message:eca7ded3-6110-4d16-80f1-179937bec143:exact-Overview-title-compatibility-decision", + "message:6e4ae798-5847-4dc4-878a-444748c52669:QA-source/test/doc-only-consent-and-strict-scenarios", + "message:019aff91-71f5-42c2-9573-c1abd1b45c6b:same-task-terminal-resume", + "current-brief:ac0264593d4b61bf1e593682b79958dd37b9bce0edf8f590c9a9afb9249adf1a", + "manager-assigned-revision:9", + "qa-consent:482f5c4b-5185-4cd5-940e-771c685f98b4", + "qa-title-mapping:d3e5a001-69dd-464d-ae54-c766c93fb153", + "owner-decision:a8a0c5db-6c4f-4fbe-890a-987a1542b06f", + "owner-diagnostics:eeb93c8f-22ac-45ad-a84e-9002344cf579", + "owner-deeplink-diagnostic:f5016dea-788c-47e8-83bf-81ffa91e7784" ], - "commit": null, + "commit": "a67a04d57f400782b01ba6087b9741fb0c54e21f", "integrationRequest": null, "blockedReason": null, "createdAt": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.720Z", - "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T10:02:17.190Z", - "revision": 7, + "updatedAt": "2026-10-01T11:24:07.534Z", + "revision": 10, "history": [ { "from": null, @@ -86,6 +103,27 @@ "actorId": "owner-console", "at": "2026-10-01T10:02:17.190Z", "note": "Fresh brief and native backlog read confirm assigned revision 6 on the same task; exact three owned site paths and QA-consented scenario file are authorized. Beginning implementation while retaining actual browser desktop/mobile acceptance as a later gate." + }, + { + "from": "in_progress", + "to": "blocked", + "actorId": "owner-console", + "at": "2026-10-01T11:09:53.597Z", + "note": "Exact candidate is clean and remains on the task branch. Preserve every receipt, including failed test-dashboard evidence. Do not request integration or claim visual acceptance." + }, + { + "from": "blocked", + "to": "assigned", + "actorId": "session-manager", + "at": "2026-10-01T11:18:12.037Z", + "note": "Resume SAME Console task after actual owner-delegated eca7 decision and current QA6e4/d3e5 consent resolve title hold. Fresh next idle/no other active Console item; actual branch clean a67a04d. Correct only owned site/console.js Overview initial/return title exactly TORCH Dashboard, retaining contextual exact titles for other views and unchanged original demo assertion. QA authorizes equally strict new navigation mapping/additive integrity note, plus already-consented N-to-N+1 preview invalidation preserving drafts/current previews and secondary deep-link direct/Back/Forward target focus/viewport coverage. Confirm actual own addressed QA constraints before contributing. No new task, backend/live-refresh/config scope, test relaxation, source-gate waiver or provider launch. Preserve all old receipts including failed dashboard713; fresh exact candidate-source four gates and independent QA required, mandatory actual live desktop/mobile acceptance still open." + }, + { + "from": "assigned", + "to": "in_progress", + "actorId": "owner-console", + "at": "2026-10-01T11:24:07.534Z", + "note": "Resuming the same task at Manager-assigned revision 9. Implementing only QA-approved site/console.js behavior, additive console-view-navigation scenarios, script navigation/strict preview coverage preserving every existing assertion/capture/artifact safeguard, and additive Test Integrity Note. Keep prior receipts and visual-acceptance boundary." } ] } diff --git a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md index 98a12c1..cb9aa5a 100644 --- a/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md +++ b/reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md @@ -1,6 +1,141 @@ # Current pilot remaining-work handoff -## Current peer contracts and sequenced implementation at 11:04 UTC +## Current decisions and qualification boundaries at 11:25 UTC + +Fresh owner **c55359eb** independently verifies7908 normal6/6 PASS, original +helper audit mutant FAIL on counted writes, and a direct multiline audit INSERT +mutant FAIL on logical-state equality. It identifies one remaining precise +instrumentation gap: the start-of-string regex branch misses leading whitespace, +so actual multiline audit INSERT is not counted (helper counts identity writes). +The SAME565 task resumed **in_progress6** only for existing QA-consented +test/doc strengthening: whitespace-aware classification and an actual strict +direct multiline-write count case. Both external mutation failures and every +existing invariant remain required. Kernel and QA received the concrete +correction;7908 is not final accepted/native qualified. The schema2/3 refusal +remains open. No new implementation item or provider was launched. +Console independently reports SAME workflow **in_progress10** after assigned9, +implementing actual approved title/stale-preview/deep-link fixes. Ledger at this +refresh: **55 tasks,39 proposed,7 blocked,6 completed,1 assigned,2 in_progress**; +each of Runtime, Kernel and Console has only one active item. These current +facts supersede the earlier in-cycle7908 blocked5/two assigned counts below. + +Final-cycle refresh received Kernel **44c76670**: amended clean +**7908d1b06e701184c04fedefaf3af977422ae976**, changing only the consented test +and integrity note from f67. Source/API/schema are unchanged. Manager inspected +the two-path delta: connection execution-count instrumentation, all logical +durable fixture tables, visible messages/ownership comparison, retained original +assertions, audit-INSERT mutation failure and restored-original invariant. +Kernel reports focused6/6, test224 PASS/5 intentional SKIP and check/lint PASS; +Manager did not run these tests or grant independent acceptance. QA handoff +**022eb810** requests exact original PASS/external owner mutant FAIL for the +correct forbidden-write reason/restored PASS. The native test guard still refuses +current2/required3 before execution, no receipt/request. After fresh task/Git +read, SAME565 is now **blocked5 at7908**, with all f67 history retained; Kernel's +code/test amendment is finished while independent QA and native qualification +remain open. Runtime/Kernel handoffs **d3ca5583/0d10f84b** carry this newer truth. +No automatic inventory assignment follows the blocked transition. + +Work **a377c8c3** corrects its garbled **6c01d8f8** revision: reusable exact +engine, separately Kernel-authenticated FixtureContext/NativeContext, permanent +fixture nonpromotion and only fresh compatible native receipts satisfying +integration/backlog/delivery gates. Current exactPasses consumers remain +authoritative. The fixture-only contradiction and proposed attestation landing +waiver are withdrawn; the bootstrap circularity is explicitly retained. Exact +context/spec18/20/ADR and CLI/contributor/scenario peer reviews remain pending, +routed through **0d10f84b**, **1e1f2ce9**, **38d76cca**; Work **7592f1fd** records +direction reviewed, no implementation/policy acceptance. Task6e4 stays proposed1. + +The new scheduled self check-in **d1b90688** was read and acknowledged only after +current manager-check-in refreshed its stale findings. All four new messages +were individually acknowledged; acknowledgment does not settle their waits. +Current ledger: **55 tasks,39 proposed,8 blocked,6 completed,2 assigned** +(Runtime e4403 and Console workflow9), no duplicate active owner. This paragraph +supersedes earlier in-cycle f67/in_progress4 and unrevised Work statements below. + +Canonical brief digest remains `d7e6d69`; the exact brief retry alone crossed the +startup SQLite sandbox boundary. Current canonical is clean `0fdfcb3`; Manager +starts at `d835ac1`. The explicit own unread query +`{recipient:"session-manager",unacknowledged_only:true,limit:100}` returned seven +current messages, all individually understood and acknowledged. This refresh +supersedes the 11:04 status below; historical presence does not prove idle work. + +Owner **eca7ded3** delegates the concrete compatibility decision: Overview's +initial and return document title is exactly **TORCH Dashboard**; other views +retain exact contextual titles. QA **6e4ae798** confirms actual contributor +consent (`d3e5a001` to Console), retaining the original demo title assertion. +Console's clean `a67a04d` has three source-gate PASS records and dashboard FAIL +`713f8acc` at that assertion before navigation captures/new stale-evidence +scenario execute. These records remain evidence for that exact candidate only. +Fresh native next lookup was idle with no active Console item; the existing +workflow moved **blocked8 → assigned9**, keeping owner, candidate, all receipts, +criteria and history. Manager handoff **11685229** routes the narrow console.js +correction, equally strict new navigation mapping/integrity note, existing +secondary deep-link target focus/viewport and N→N+1 stale-preview invalidation +requirements. Preserve drafts and unchanged-current previews. No original demo +assertion change, backend/live-refresh expansion or new UI task is authorized. +Fresh four exact candidate-source gates, independent QA and actual live +desktop/mobile acceptance remain required; no final acceptance is claimed. + +Kernel **b952872d** hands off the implemented `observeMessages` export at clean +**f67f47f95e492a30d868e64021b7090b4ca36f6e**. Manager inspected its single +MATERIALIZED CTE SELECT and unchanged legacy read API. Kernel reports focused +6/6, full npm test224 PASS/5 intentional SKIP, check/lint PASS. These are focused +and direct source evidence, not qualified native receipts: the actual source +guard refused before execution with **CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED, +current2 required3**; no receipt, integration request or dashboard run followed. + +Owner **44512241** proves a validation gap, not a production-source write: its +hermetic wrapper performs four audit INSERTs after original observation, while +the same suite still passes6/6. The assertion compares state.db bytes and misses +WAL writes. QA **6e4ae798** (`6d9c8a03` to Kernel) authorizes test/doc-only +strengthening: actual connection DML write-count zero and logical durable-state +equality across observations, preserving every assertion; original source must +PASS and the demonstrated mutating variant must FAIL for the forbidden-write +reason. Manager inspected the test and mutant without opening production state. +The SAME inbox component is now **in_progress4**, candidate recorded, with this +remaining bounded validation work and real qualification refusal in its history. +It is not accepted or landed. Handoff **a0a4a463** names only +test/fleet/control-plane.test.mjs and additive docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md for this +strengthening; no production source/schema/guard alteration follows. + +Runtime **e440 remains assigned3**. Handoff **b889c9d6** corrects the stale +"unimplemented inbox API" dependency: candidate source exists; qualified API +acceptance/landing does not. QA **008df147** receives both actual decisions for +independent resulting-candidate review. No specialist has a duplicate active +implementation, and no provider session was launched by Manager. + +Dormant-service APIs remain separate, unimplemented phases: Kernel inventory +**1e688 blocked4** needs its exact export/input/output and QA contract after inbox +qualification; Runtime dormant launcher **2b4 proposed1** follows e440 and the +qualified inventory. Release handoff **6ed4c5cf** preserves persistent-operations +blocked5 and its full roadmap; the older QA contributor prohibition is resolved +by cc381/167, while actual API contract/qualification gates remain open. +Reservation125 and starting-presence blocked histories are preserved. + +Work's source-qualification **6e4 remains proposed/unassigned**. Handoff +**e351b653** requests the reviewed protocol revision: resolve fixture-only engine +versus eventual authenticated native execution, identify exact Kernel/Release/QA +context bindings, actual spec/scenario authority and integration consumer changes +for any source-landing policy change. A byte digest does not authenticate an +actor; fixture attestations cannot become native receipts. Existing native PASS +landing gates remain unchanged. No code assignment or prose waiver follows. + +Fleet evolution shows eight recurring domain sets; the 30-day hierarchy scan +shows nine domain-set signals and eleven historical direct coordination requests. +Existing six specialists still coherently own the actual work. Improve exact +contracts, test integrity and reviewed qualification policy first; no new domain, +coordination identity, retirement or hierarchy activation is justified here. +Fleet changes are empty. Health reports37 stale observed-commit findings and two +resolved-dependency warnings; warnings are observational, not cleanup/unblock +authority. Genuine remaining schema/scope gates are retained. + +Owner-only runtime-switch approval **75a8ebae remains pending**. The five-PNG +human consent covers only completed exact Runtime recovery; it grants no pending +runtime switch or live schema recovery. No automatic wakes, installation switch, +live schema recovery, host activation, extra identities or provider launches. +Final acceptance must refresh inbox, exact candidate and task evidence again. + +## Historical peer contracts and sequenced implementation at 11:04 UTC Canonical briefs still match `d7e6d69`; startup readonly DB failure was retried only with the narrowly authorized exact brief. Own branch starts clean at