# NIP Compliance Report - 2025-02-12

## Summary
Performed a comprehensive audit of NIP compliance for `bitvid` (unstable). Verified P0 items (Encryption, Relay Lists, Video Notes) via automated regression tests.

## Findings

### P0 Items (Critical)
| Item | NIPs | Status | Verification |
|------|------|--------|--------------|
| **Encryption** | NIP-04, NIP-44 | **Compliant** | Verified `createNip46Cipher` prefers NIP-44 v2 and falls back to NIP-04. Verified decryption handles both formats. |
| **Relay Lists** | NIP-65 (Kind 10002) | **Compliant** | Verified `relayManager.loadRelayList` requests Kind 10002 and parses `read`/`write` markers correctly. |
| **Video Notes** | Kind 30078, NIP-71 | **Compliant** | Verified `prepareVideoPublishPayload` constructs Kind 30078 with proper `d` tag and embeds NIP-71 tags (`title`, `t`ags, etc). |
| **Auth** | NIP-07 | **Compliant** | Verified permissions handling and async `window.nostr` detection logic in `nip07Permissions.js`. |

### Other Findings
- **Kind 30078** events do not include the `summary` tag from NIP-71 metadata, which is correct as NIP-71 defines `content` as summary for Kind 21/22.
- **NIP-10** threading is implemented in `buildCommentEvent`.
- **NIP-51** Lists (Mute/Subscription) follow standard specs.

## Remediation
- No code changes were required for compliance.
- Added regression tests in `tests/compliance/`.

## Next Steps
- Monitor `magnet-uri` dependency status (currently extraneous in environment).
- Continue monitoring NIP-17 rollout.