bitvid/PR_REVIEWS.md

Automated PR Review Report

1. PR: codex/add-centralized-permission-gate

Target: main Status: ❌ Request Changes

❌ Test Failures

tests/nostr-login-permissions.test.mjs failed (6 subtests).

Suggestion: Inspect tests/nostr-login-permissions.test.mjs. It seems related to extension.enable assertions. Run npm run test:unit locally.

🚀 Release Channel Checks

⚠️ Warning: Targets main but modifies critical config (config/instance-config.js, js/constants.js).

Guidance: Ensure feature flags are safe defaults.

🛡️ Guardrails

requires-security-review requires-protocol-review

• Touched 41 sensitive files including js/auth/signingAdapter.js, js/dmDecryptor.js, js/nostr/nip07Permissions.js.

---

2. PR: codex/remove-nip04-and-nip44-from-default-permissions

Target: main Status: ❌ Request Changes

❌ Test Failures

tests/nostr-login-permissions.test.mjs failed (6 subtests).

Suggestion: Same failure as above. Likely an environmental issue or regression in NIP-07 logic.

🚀 Release Channel Checks

⚠️ Warning: Targets main but modifies critical config.

🛡️ Guardrails

requires-security-review requires-protocol-review

• Touched 41 sensitive files.

---

3. PR: fix/optimize-nip07-login-perf-4235940878368250470

Target: main Status: ❌ Failure / Timeout

❌ Test Failures

Tests timed out during execution.

Suggestion: Run npm run test:unit:shard1 locally to verify changes without timeout.

---

Audit Log

Branch	Lint	Format	Tests	Security
codex/add-centralized-permission-gate	✅ Pass	✅ Pass	❌ Fail	🛡️ Req
codex/remove-nip04-and-nip44...	✅ Pass	✅ Pass	❌ Fail	🛡️ Req
fix/optimize-nip07-login-perf...	✅ Pass	✅ Pass	❌ Timeout	?

Micro-fixes: No formatting changes detected in the reviewed branches.