TASK-session-manager: record exact peer decisions and bounded next roadmap action

This commit is contained in:
thePR0M3TH3AN committed 2026-10-01 14:44:41 -04:00
1 parent 1f87ac958e
commit 448573e515
6 files changed
+263 -13

No files matched your search

@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@
],
"observedAt": "cb145e56cb7d530f9563b98d4f9920ff0372a67a",
"feature": "Check execution provenance and state isolation",
"milestone": "Reviewed reliability dependencies",
"milestone": "B2 registered policy and no-write native planning admission",
"state": "verification",
"owner": "work-integration",
"evidence": [
@@ -96,8 +96,8 @@
"integrationRequest": "a1789e46-b91e-496c-9204-ab204dac6a6d",
"blockedReason": null,
"createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:14:01.401Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T18:15:19.000Z",
"revision": 15,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T18:42:58.762Z",
"revision": 17,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -204,5 +204,33 @@
"at": "2026-10-01T18:15:19.000Z",
"note": "Record actual owner28 existing Work read-only contract turn WIP; no new assignment/status/schema field, implementation permission, consent assumption or lifecycle change. All original source/criteria/history/refusals preserved; concrete returned contract and QA contributor decisions remain required."
}
],
"classificationHistory": [
{
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T18:39:48.912Z",
"reason": "Actual Workc106/e243 and Kernel2565351a agree narrow registered CheckService pre-snapshot admission, opaque parent/no CP, private FD3/4, real Node/npm/browser dependencies and observed descendant closure. Kernel accepts proposed config applier but not edit authority; candidate_execution_policy optional parser. Exact reproducible package_json_path/package_script_name/vector and artifact-versus-adapter A distinction need recipient decisions52502f15; exact QAaebbf allowlist copy/TIN consent requested8e7bea6a. No B2 implementation, policy registration, DDL, consumer or native acceptance. Preserve verification/full seven criteria, landed316 history, legacy2 and current3/2 refusal.",
"from": {
"feature": "Check execution provenance and state isolation",
"milestone": "Reviewed reliability dependencies"
},
"to": {
"feature": "Check execution provenance and state isolation",
"milestone": "B2 registered policy bytes and private native admission agreement"
}
},
{
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T18:42:58.762Z",
"reason": "Append actual owner784c788c/Release2969 incident: nominal converge plan inherits mutable CLI1714 openControlPlane, Kernelconstructor initializeSchema/INSERT identity and identity/roster refresh. Same6e4 needs precise ReleaseCLI/Kernel readonly initialized compatible state/Work guards interface: no planning writes, missing/incompatible schema refusal and immutable schema/data/identities/tasks/messages/resource before-after scenarios. Separate external SQLite guard from exact QA TIN consent; immediate normal guarded path may request legitimate narrowly scoped tool approval, never live DDL/schema/DB permission workaround or75 activation. No new task/parallel implementation; previous B2 vectors/contributor gates and all seven full criteria retained.",
"from": {
"feature": "Check execution provenance and state isolation",
"milestone": "B2 registered policy bytes and private native admission agreement"
},
"to": {
"feature": "Check execution provenance and state isolation",
"milestone": "B2 registered policy and no-write native planning admission"
}
}
]
}
@@ -23,8 +23,8 @@
"No rollout or frozen-candidate protocol change occurs from proposal alone; independent QA acceptance and guarded integration required for eventual implementation."
],
"observedAt": "1a2b5b0fec32c2dddbfec76e2f0479de9cfc31c4",
"feature": null,
"milestone": null,
"feature": "Immutable test-integrity evidence",
"milestone": "Corrected V1 oracle and approved QA record ownership application",
"state": "blocked",
"owner": "work-integration",
"evidence": [
@@ -46,8 +46,8 @@
"integrationRequest": null,
"blockedReason": "Read-only preparation complete. Actionable INTERNAL Work/QA contract decision: return concrete version-pinned record schema/canonical preimage/exact YAML/test paths/scenarios requested by actual QA1e477 (owner4646), then obtain named contributor/gate consent and sequence bounded implementation. Historical61de permits evidence preparation only. This is not an owner strategic permission hold; no code/migration/acceptance or automatic dependency unblocking.",
"createdAt": "2026-10-01T07:36:25.425Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T18:15:19.000Z",
"revision": 7,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T18:39:45.725Z",
"revision": 8,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -98,5 +98,20 @@
"at": "2026-10-01T18:15:19.000Z",
"note": "Record actual owner28 existing Work read-only contract turn WIP; no new assignment/status/schema field, implementation permission, consent assumption or lifecycle change. All original source/criteria/history/refusals preserved; concrete returned contract and QA contributor decisions remain required."
}
],
"classificationHistory": [
{
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T18:39:45.725Z",
"reason": "Current decisions: QA862dd6d6 rejects original68d missing legacy; complete addressed Work6038b6c1 now includes legacy:null, explicit abc+LF source specimen, 955-byte SHA903157bef00dc68913c628813530f1612fa8e1b51a287b7ad0966c6bfdb0f1ab independently reproduced by Manager. Original941 invalid remains. Anchor143955/hash/61 independently reproduced; 14 mapping QA evidence preserved. Corrected packet still requires actual QA verdict; approved b103 named Kernel two-file amendment not applied, PATH_UNOWNED remains. Preserve blocked lifecycle, full criteria/owner/history/evidence. No code/migration/assignment; current decision ledger in reports/audit/pilot-remaining-work-handoff-report-2026-10-01.md supersedes stale 'packet not returned' text without deleting it.",
"from": {
"feature": null,
"milestone": null
},
"to": {
"feature": "Immutable test-integrity evidence",
"milestone": "Corrected V1 oracle and approved QA record ownership application"
}
}
]
}
@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@
],
"observedAt": "ff0712534829",
"feature": "Self-host development readiness",
"milestone": "Owner-reviewed first development backlog",
"milestone": "Release correction source accepted; guarded lossless convergence and exact final QA",
"state": "blocked",
"owner": "owner-console",
"evidence": [
@@ -122,8 +122,8 @@
"integrationRequest": "cb83a211-9f3f-4688-98fe-3faaece76da6",
"blockedReason": "Exact scoped Overview0c2 source independently QAe454 accepted and single native cb83a211 landed18:06:20; canonical clean0c2 independently observed. Prior accepted4fa/e8 source and histories preserved. Full task remains blocked on actual live/installed desktop/mobile owner flow, truthful served UI/API engine provenance and current durable blockedReason visibility; generated demo/native artifacts do not qualify installed/live acceptance. Human runtime75 remains pending, browser disconnected, alpha3 pointer switch alone cannot fix missing fields. Later93b health/mobile UX is separately proposed; Release9a0 actually QA-rejected invalid-pointer privacy edge; same three-path correction already active, future exact QA/post-advance convergence required. No installation/host/provider/wake/schema/publication.",
"createdAt": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.720Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T18:12:50.000Z",
"revision": 25,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T18:39:51.779Z",
"revision": 26,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -300,5 +300,20 @@
"at": "2026-10-01T18:12:50.000Z",
"note": "Reconcile actual latest QA6b5/ownerdb4 source rejection/correction and completed arbiter exact development push; prior pending-review wording historical. Preserve blocked whole-workflow state/Console owner/source0c2/cb83/fullcriteria/every history/refusal; no further acceptance, assignment, code scope, live/activation or Release integration."
}
],
"classificationHistory": [
{
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T18:39:51.779Z",
"reason": "Actual QA455f3ac7 accepts exact8fb correction source/provenance9focused/four nativePASS/11hashes only, oldbase4fa not integration. Owner7b2 resumed existing Release convergence; Release2969 requests exact one-file TIN resolution and records SQLite readonly external refusal. Named QA requestc9df5bae preserves canonical0c2 full prefix plus unchanged three Release blocks; no Manager substitute. Fresh merged gates/finalQA/single request remain. Overview0c2 landed/pushed, installed alpha2/live blockedReason/provenance/browser/mobile full criteria open; human75 pending distinct PNG consent. No new assignment/source authority.",
"from": {
"feature": "Self-host development readiness",
"milestone": "Owner-reviewed first development backlog"
},
"to": {
"feature": "Self-host development readiness",
"milestone": "Release correction source accepted; guarded lossless convergence and exact final QA"
}
}
]
}
@@ -16,7 +16,7 @@
],
"observedAt": "ff0712534829",
"feature": "Self-host development readiness",
"milestone": "Owner-reviewed first development backlog",
"milestone": "Bounded Console saved-decision timestamps and coverage scenarios",
"state": "proposed",
"owner": null,
"evidence": [],
@@ -24,8 +24,8 @@
"integrationRequest": null,
"blockedReason": null,
"createdAt": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.715Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.715Z",
"revision": 1,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T18:39:55.069Z",
"revision": 2,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -34,5 +34,20 @@
"at": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.715Z",
"note": "Task created."
}
],
"classificationHistory": [
{
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T18:39:55.069Z",
"reason": "Owner4ab asks independent implementable roadmap action. Selected Console-only site/owner-digest.js to render existing decidedAt and saved-window/structured-versus-unindexed coverage; live path ownerConsole and next idle read18:36, not process evidence. Precise scope requesta4f1e68b and QA88aecb41 for additive test/fleet/console-owner-digest.test.mjs plus exact append-only TIN; consent must return before implementation/assignment. No engine/API/schema/timers/external notifications. Preserve proposed unassigned full task, decision indexing/cadence/external opt-in remaining criteria. Health/mobile/thread workflow requests separate; no launch.",
"from": {
"feature": "Self-host development readiness",
"milestone": "Owner-reviewed first development backlog"
},
"to": {
"feature": "Self-host development readiness",
"milestone": "Bounded Console saved-decision timestamps and coverage scenarios"
}
}
]
}
@@ -1,5 +1,111 @@
# Current pilot remaining-work handoff
## Current addressed decisions and next owned actions, 18:40 UTC
Current briefd7e6d69, explicitly addressed unread100, all56 task records, native
queue, manager observations and named approvals were refreshed. Source canonical
0c2 is clean and already landed/pushed; no duplicate316/c532 landing. Full roadmap
remains39proposed/9blocked/6completed/1verification/1assigned. Current check-in
and advisory evolution/hierarchy evidence favor existing owners and precise peer
contracts, not new roles or activation. Doctor healthy does not negate owner18:24
229-unread observation or the50 current backlog findings (49 stale observed commits,
one resolved-dependency warning); no bulk acknowledgements, closes or cleanup.
Actual QA455f3ac7 **ACCEPTS exact8fb58b232ed5e854f00125a3b96922a2c8615b98**
bounded Release source correction/provenance:9strict focused, four fresh native
PASS, all11 artifact hashes and unchanged170135-byte TIN prefix. This supersedes
the historical pending source review below; it is not integration/final merged QA.
Owner7b2c8cb6 actually resumed EXISTING Release for guarded convergence, not Manager
automation. Release2969e1d6 previews exactly one QA-owned conflict: TIN base blob
a2aef473cb21b09a9e420fea9603549924c30bba, canonical0c2
a35e0339b1d9d0e19e823cfd08a1ef6255b2b45e, accepted8fb
6a2bc8c0c49564a2ace18f8a5d2623e17a4d9943. Named QAc9df5bae requests exact full
canonical prefix plus unchanged three Release block bodies in original order.
Manager cannot consent for QA. SQLite readonly convergence-plan refusal is an
external tool guard, distinct from peer consent; exact scoped escalation can be
reviewed, with no DB permissions/state copy/manual merge. Original18/978/9a
failures stay. Lossless clean convergence, new merged SHA/four exact gates/immutable
artifacts/final QA precede one request. No current Release integration acceptance.
Complete addressed Work6038b6c1 now supplies original68d integrity contract plus
its explicit correction: strict ten-key record schema; ordered JSON UTF8/noBOM/LF
digest excluding record_sha256; source/approval binding; append-only discovery and
fail-closed malformed/duplicate/stale/unauthorized/orphan/replay/rewrite/delete
scenarios; anchor and all61sections/14mappings. The original941-byte/a80d vector
is INVALID (required legacy absent), rejected QA862dd6d6/ownerd7ed4a6a, retained.
Manager independently reproduces corrected legacy:null JSON+LF955bytes,
SHA903157bef00dc68913c628813530f1612fa8e1b51a287b7ad0966c6bfdb0f1ab,
explicit sourceabc+LF hex6162630a/4bytes/SHAedeaaff3f1774ad2888673770c6d64097e391bc362d7d6fb34982ddf0efd18cb.
Actual Git anchor07a is143955bytes/SHA239fb5539e9f7cfc8562ac5351c61e7e1d345f00737a557ce9fa1b6d702e941a/61H2.
The first verification attempt threw subprocess EPERM; a read-only Git-to-Node
pipeline subsequently reproduced these values. Fixture serialization is not real
source/approval/admission proof. Same corrected reviewf45947e4 awaits actual QA
decision; full a655 stays blocked, Work6e4 verification. No generic human hold.
Approved ownership amendmentb103revision2 names Kernel to append ONLY QA
docs/test-integrity/records/** in both .torch/torch.yaml and .torch/roster.yaml after
safe current-work checkpoint. Current canonical0c2 hashes still match approved
4e21d6bf/fb17fd5 guards, but actual ownership remains unowned. Kernel52502f15 requests
exact safe continuity/two-config plan under existing approval; no new human answer
or B2 registration inferred. PATH_UNOWNED remains enforced until actual qualifying
landing/readback. Work source integrity-records.mjs and QA test-integrity-records
scenarios do not gain code authority from packet/hash success.
Actual Workc106/e243 and Kernel2565351a ratify narrow future CheckService admission,
opaque parent, private FD3/4 closure and optional candidate_execution_policy parser.
Pinned B2 report now records exact current delta, real dependency/frozen-input/
descendant requirements, and only remaining vector/adapter-versus-artifact/QA
allowlist decisions. Full seven native/source/consumer criteria remain required;
legacy2/current3/2 refusals preserved. No fixture-only or all-refusal completion.
Independent next roadmap action selected under owner4ab: existing proposed
TASK-conversation-owner-digest, Console ONLY site/owner-digest.js saved-decision
timestamps and explicit structured-approval versus unindexed manager coverage.
The API already supplies decidedAt, but the renderer currently drops it. Existing
QA test/fleet/console-owner-digest.test.mjs gains additive deterministic boundary,
malformed/out-of-window/unknown/truncated/privacy/immutable-publication scenarios
and separately consented append-only TIN. Named Consolea4f1e68b/QA88aecb41 decisions
are the next implementation prerequisite; no engine/API/schema/timer/notification
changes. Native nextConsoleidle and ownership were checked, without claiming
process inactivity. This prepares one concrete source action, not a parallel
implementation or full digest completion. Real manager indexing and reviewed
external opt-in/cadence remain whole-task criteria. Health-label/mobile93b,
thread/supersessiond2feed and Kernel one-path current TODO handoff remain separate
existing workflow/documentation requests, not forgotten or duplicated tasks.
Owner784c788c's concrete converge-plan writer incident was independently read at
canonical CLI1714/Kernel constructor264 and recorded in SAME6e4: future compatible
read-only initialized planning, no schema/identity/roster writes, exact missing/
incompatible refusal and immutable before/after evidence. ReleaseCLI/Kernel API/
Work guards/QA scenarios remain named owned contributions, not a parallel queue.
Immediate supported guarded convergence may request legitimate scoped tool
approval after actual QA conflict consent, preserving every external failure.
Owner2f3e9343 corrects the actual QA/Kernel re-entry failure: both initial units
failed before agent turn because an arbiter temporary output probe incorrectly
handled plain codex --version. Its hermetically verified correction/retry belongs
to the arbiter, not an installed TORCH/model/QA refusal. No repo/installed executor
change or guard bypass; old failed receipts/units remain. Current owner reports
Manager+QA+Kernel active, Release prior handle terminal. Manager starts none;
only arbiter may re-enter Release after exact QA consent and slot availability.
Actual browser retry still returns noavailable/list[], so live UX remains open.
Supported owned API updates only classification labels and timestamped reason
history for existing a655revision8,6e4revision17,workflowrevision26,digestrevision2.
All statuses/owners/candidates/integration links/full acceptance criteria/evidence
arrays/lifecycle histories are preserved. No same-state transition or manual ledger
edit manufactured evidence permission; current classification reasons and this
report supersede stale prior summary text while retaining it as history.
Only actual human activation75pending remains human-specific; five-PNG approval
already satisfied does not resolve it. Installed alpha2/current live blockedReason,
served provenance, real browser/mobile acceptance remain unqualified. Owner12657
reports Kernel terminal, Release and Manager active; starts stay arbiter-only and
bounded to three native identities plus root. No installation, live DDL/schema,
host/service/model/publication/default-main action; automatic wakesOFF.
Historical entries below retain their dated evidence and superseded review states.
Latest actual Work **c90d7c8a** confirms the complete integrity-record V1 contract
reached named QA in durable **68d4ea0e-aac8-4d00-bafb-9248266b205b**: schema/preimage/
vector/exact paths and61 legacy-section/14 commit-blob mapping. Manager routes that
@@ -12,6 +12,77 @@ ADR026 at 6fdb88ea supply design context, not normative gate changes.
## Current B2 owned decisions and remaining registration seam, 17:53 UTC
### Addressed native admission and policy delta, 18:40 UTC
The original packet remains pinned at Manager commit683e9f8, SHA256
84d062c358310a1428085b2287f3afbdb62fdbfac2f8554f3b113f1375f77a7b.
Read complete addressed Workc10696f6 and e2435195, plus Kernel2565351a.
These are read-only agreements, not B2 source or config permission.
Work specifies the exact future existing checks/service.mjs admission hunk:
after identity/definition/resource/clean-subject validation and before
captureCheckSnapshot/executeConditionedCheck, issueCandidateNativeAdmissionV2
from the authenticated registered plan, policy and E preflight. Missing policy
refuses CHECK_CANDIDATE_NATIVE_POLICY_UNREGISTERED before channel/spawn/state
transition. No live writer, receipt, migration or legacy consumer change.
The private capability binds project/area/check/plan/commit/definition/cleanGuard,
lease generations/policy/E/run/nonce/expiry (at most60s); no caller selectors,
ControlPlane, writer, DB or adapter handle. Bootstrap consumes it once, rejecting
replay, closure, expiry and cross-generation. Private inherited FD3 carries one
framed record at most64KiB; FD4 observes acknowledgement. Fixed private init
validates nonce/generation and closes both before candidate spawn; the child
inherits neither. Internal provenance does not authenticate hostile same-UID
host processes. The earlier1MiB general descriptor limit does not enlarge this
admission transport limit.
Kernel agrees to the proposed named .torch/torch.yaml applier role. Exact future
registration is ONLY optional strict checks[].candidate_execution_policy on the
four existing test/check/test-dashboard/lint definitions, parsed in EXISTING
src/kernel/config.mjs; old configs remain valid. Parent parses/verifies and returns
an opaque binding/resolved policy without opening CP. Node/npm raw package+lock,
script/dependency bytes and actual Chromium/runtime/transitive dependencies remain
required. In-root .bin link text, lexical/resolved target and target bytes are
bound; product links refuse. Absolute pinned unshare/private PID1 init require
actual namespace/run/generation and tested close/reap barriers: direct exit,
empty PGID or namespace creation is not proof of escaped-descendant closure.
Unknown coverage cannot mint TerminalProof/PASS.
Precise remaining recipient decisions, without another generic design cycle:
- Kernel52502f15: addressed full executable canonical vector, including required
literal package_json_path/package_script_name, framing bytes/length/hash.
Owner12657cf8 and Worke243 identify those omitted frames in the prior932-byte
proposal; its hash alone is not an independently reproducible oracle.
- Kernel/Work52502f15/e4fe45de: distinguish c106's Phase-A sealed artifact manifest
from the pinned adapter-admission A tuple with explicit separate schema fields;
no silent reinterpretation of compatibility evidence.
- QA8e7bea6a: addressed exact aebbf six test paths/scenarios and separate exact
append-only Test Integrity Note consent. Owner reports consent exists; Manager
does not invent its allowlist from a delivery summary.
- Actual reviewed policy registration remains distinct from source implementation
and the separate approved b103 QA-record ownership amendment. No .torch edit,
live DDL, source receipt, installation or operational acceptance is granted here.
Existing Workfull6e4 remains verification with all seven criteria. Positive actual
registered issuance, frozen-file consumption by all four real gates, observed
descendant fencing, compatible native adapter and eventual real consumers remain
required. B1 fixture acceptance, legacy2 receipts and current3/2 refusal are retained.
The supported revision-checked classify API records this current phase in existing
task classificationHistory; it does not alter lifecycle, ownership or native gates.
Owner784c788c identifies a concrete related planning boundary, independently read
on canonical0c2: src/cli.mjs1714 opens normal mutable ControlPlane for converge
plan/guards; service initialization creates schema/inserts identities, and identity
assertion refreshes roster with writes. Future SAME6e4 native planning composition
must read compatible already-initialized state without any schema/identity/roster
writes, refuse precisely when missing/incompatible, and prove immutable schema,
data, identities, tasks, messages and resource guards before/after. Release owns
the CLI use, Kernel the read-only interface, Work convergence guards, QA boundary
scenarios (routed e92a36f1/9f012d8d). This is a source requirement, not permission to
open/migrate live state or substitute an older checker. Immediate convergence
still uses supported guarded tools with legitimate scoped tool approval and exact
QA conflict consent. Current external SQLite refusal and all earlier failures stay.
This section supersedes the 17:02 proposed map only by the specific deltas below.
Actual Work **acc1d43e** and Kernel **9752d155**, with owner **7921552a** correcting
two factual errors, are read-only protocol decisions. No B2 implementation,