Use uppercase tags for comment events

docs/nostr-event-schemas.md

@@ -137,11 +137,10 @@ import { updateWatchHistoryListWithDefaultClient } from "./nostrWatchHistoryFaca
 | Video post (`NOTE_TYPES.VIDEO_POST`) | `30078` | `['t','video']`, `['d', <stable video identifier>]` plus optional schema append tags | JSON payload using Content Schema v3 (`version`, `title`, optional `url`, `magnet`, `thumbnail`, `description`, `mode`, `videoRootId`, `deleted`, `isPrivate`, `isNsfw`, `isForKids`, `enableComments`, `ws`, `xs`) |
 | NIP-94 mirror (`NOTE_TYPES.VIDEO_MIRROR`) | `1063` | Tags forwarded from `publishVideo` (URL, mime type, thumbnail, alt text, magnet) | Plain text alt description |
 | Repost (`NOTE_TYPES.REPOST`) | `6` | `['e', <event id>, <relay?>]` with optional address pointer `['a', <kind:pubkey:identifier>, <relay?>]`, and `['p', <pubkey>]` when the origin author is known; inherits schema append tags | Empty content |
-| Video comment (`NOTE_TYPES.VIDEO_COMMENT`) | `1111` | NIP-22 root scope tags `['A'\|`E`\|`I`, <pointer>, <relay?>?], `['K', <root kind>]`, and `['P', <root author pubkey>, <relay?>?]` plus parent metadata `['a'\|`e`\|`i`, <parent pointer>, <relay?>?, <author?>], `['k', <parent kind>]`, `['p', <parent author>, <relay?>?]`; builder retains legacy lowercase fallbacks (`['a', ...]`/`['e', ...]`/`['p', ...]`) alongside the uppercase set for compatibility; inherits schema append tags | Plain text body sanitized to valid UTF-8 |
+| Video comment (`NOTE_TYPES.VIDEO_COMMENT`) | `1111` | NIP-22 root scope tags `['A'\|`E`\|`I`, <pointer>, <relay?>?], `['K', <root kind>]`, and `['P', <root author pubkey>, <relay?>?]` plus parent metadata `['E'\|`I`, <parent pointer>, <relay?>?, <author?>], `['K', <parent kind>]`, `['P', <parent author>, <relay?>?]`; inherits schema append tags | Plain text body sanitized to valid UTF-8 |
 
 > **Publishing note:** Session actors only emit passive telemetry (for example, view counters) and must **not** sign video comments. Require a logged-in Nostr signer for comment publishing via [`commentEvents`](../js/nostr/commentEvents.js).
 
-> **Compatibility tip:** When a comment anchors itself to a video definition address, emit both the uppercase root pointer and a legacy `['e', <root event id>]` tag. This mirrors the [NIP-22 addressable events example](./nips/22.md#addressable-events) so clients that only understand `#e` tags can still follow the thread.
 | NIP-71 video (`NOTE_TYPES.NIP71_VIDEO`) | `21` | `['title', <title>]`, optional `['published_at', <unix seconds>]`, optional `['alt', <text>]`, repeated `['imeta', ...]` entries describing NIP-92 media variants, optional `['duration', <seconds>]`, repeated `['text-track', <url>, <kind>, <language>]`, optional `['content-warning', <reason>]`, repeated `['segment', <start>, <end>, <title>, <thumbnail>]`, repeated hashtags `['t', <tag>]`, repeated participants `['p', <pubkey>, <relay?>]`, repeated references `['r', <url>]` | Plain text summary carried in the content field. Publishing is gated by the `FEATURE_PUBLISH_NIP71` runtime flag while the rollout stabilizes. |
 | NIP-71 short video (`NOTE_TYPES.NIP71_SHORT_VIDEO`) | `22` | Same as `NOTE_TYPES.NIP71_VIDEO`; the kind differentiates short-form presentations. | Plain text summary; gated by `FEATURE_PUBLISH_NIP71`. |
 | Relay list (`NOTE_TYPES.RELAY_LIST`) | `10002` | Repeating `['r', <relay url>]` tags, optionally with a marker of `'read'` or `'write'` to scope the relay; marker omitted for read/write relays | Empty content |

js/nostr/commentEvents.js

@@ -799,16 +799,10 @@ function createVideoCommentFilters(targetInput, options = {}) {
   const filters = [];
 
   const eventFilter = {
-    kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds(),
-    "#e": [descriptor.videoEventId],
-  };
-  filters.push(applyFilterOptions(eventFilter, options));
-
-  const uppercaseEventFilter = {
     kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds(),
     "#E": [descriptor.videoEventId],
   };
-  filters.push(applyFilterOptions(uppercaseEventFilter, options));
+  filters.push(applyFilterOptions(eventFilter, options));
 
   const uppercaseFilter = { kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds() };
   let hasUppercasePointer = false;
@@ -817,12 +811,6 @@ function createVideoCommentFilters(targetInput, options = {}) {
     uppercaseFilter["#I"] = [descriptor.rootIdentifier];
     hasUppercasePointer = true;
 
-    const lowercaseRootFilter = {
-      kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds(),
-      "#i": [descriptor.rootIdentifier],
-    };
-
-    filters.push(applyFilterOptions(lowercaseRootFilter, options));
   } else if (
     typeof descriptor.videoDefinitionAddress === "string" &&
     descriptor.videoDefinitionAddress
@@ -859,12 +847,6 @@ function createVideoCommentFilters(targetInput, options = {}) {
     descriptor.parentCommentId &&
     descriptor.parentCommentId !== descriptor.videoEventId
   ) {
-    const parentFilter = {
-      kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds(),
-      "#e": [descriptor.parentCommentId],
-    };
-    filters.push(applyFilterOptions(parentFilter, options));
-
     const parentUppercaseFilter = {
       kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds(),
       "#E": [descriptor.parentCommentId],
@@ -873,17 +855,6 @@ function createVideoCommentFilters(targetInput, options = {}) {
   }
 
   if (descriptor.videoDefinitionAddress) {
-    const definitionFilter = {
-      kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds(),
-      "#a": [descriptor.videoDefinitionAddress],
-    };
-
-    if (descriptor.parentCommentId) {
-      definitionFilter["#e"] = [descriptor.parentCommentId];
-    }
-
-    filters.push(applyFilterOptions(definitionFilter, options));
-
     const definitionUppercaseFilter = {
       kinds: getAllowedCommentKinds(),
       "#A": [descriptor.videoDefinitionAddress],
@@ -976,21 +947,8 @@ function isVideoCommentEvent(event, descriptor) {
     targetDescriptor.parentAuthorPubkey,
   );
 
-  let sawRootKindTag = false;
-  let rootKindMatches = !expectedRootKind;
-  let rootKindMismatch = false;
-
-  let sawRootAuthorTag = false;
-  let rootAuthorMatches = !expectedRootAuthor;
-  let rootAuthorMismatch = false;
-
-  let sawParentKindTag = false;
-  let parentKindMatches = !expectedParentKind;
-  let parentKindMismatch = false;
-
-  let sawParentAuthorTag = false;
-  let parentAuthorMatches = !expectedParentAuthor;
-  let parentAuthorMismatch = false;
+  const kindTagValues = [];
+  const authorTagValues = [];
 
   for (const tag of tags) {
     if (!Array.isArray(tag) || tag.length < 2) {
@@ -998,20 +956,20 @@ function isVideoCommentEvent(event, descriptor) {
     }
     const [rawName, rawValue] = tag;
     const trimmedName = typeof rawName === "string" ? rawName.trim() : "";
-    const lowerName = trimmedName.toLowerCase();
+    const upperName = trimmedName.toUpperCase();
     const normalizedValue = normalizeTagValue(rawValue);
-    if (!lowerName || !normalizedValue) {
+    if (!upperName || !normalizedValue) {
       continue;
     }
 
-    if (lowerName === "i") {
+    if (upperName === "I") {
       if (
         normalizedRootIdentifier &&
         normalizedValue === normalizedRootIdentifier
       ) {
         hasIdentifierTag = true;
       }
-    } else if (lowerName === "a") {
+    } else if (upperName === "A") {
       if (
         normalizedVideoDefinitionAddress &&
         normalizedValue === normalizedVideoDefinitionAddress
@@ -1019,7 +977,7 @@ function isVideoCommentEvent(event, descriptor) {
         hasDefinitionTag = true;
         matchedDefinitionPointer = true;
       }
-    } else if (lowerName === "e") {
+    } else if (upperName === "E") {
       if (
         normalizedVideoEventId &&
         normalizedValue === normalizedVideoEventId
@@ -1033,37 +991,28 @@ function isVideoCommentEvent(event, descriptor) {
       ) {
         hasParentTag = true;
       }
-    } else if (trimmedName === "K") {
-      sawRootKindTag = true;
-      if (!expectedRootKind || normalizedValue === expectedRootKind) {
-        rootKindMatches = true;
-      } else {
-        rootKindMismatch = true;
-      }
-    } else if (trimmedName === "P") {
-      sawRootAuthorTag = true;
-      if (!expectedRootAuthor || normalizedValue === expectedRootAuthor) {
-        rootAuthorMatches = true;
-      } else {
-        rootAuthorMismatch = true;
-      }
-    } else if (trimmedName === "k") {
-      sawParentKindTag = true;
-      if (!expectedParentKind || normalizedValue === expectedParentKind) {
-        parentKindMatches = true;
-      } else {
-        parentKindMismatch = true;
-      }
-    } else if (trimmedName === "p") {
-      sawParentAuthorTag = true;
-      if (!expectedParentAuthor || normalizedValue === expectedParentAuthor) {
-        parentAuthorMatches = true;
-      } else {
-        parentAuthorMismatch = true;
-      }
+    } else if (upperName === "K") {
+      kindTagValues.push(normalizedValue);
+    } else if (upperName === "P") {
+      authorTagValues.push(normalizedValue);
     }
   }
 
+  const sawRootKindTag = kindTagValues.length > 0 && Boolean(expectedRootKind);
+  const sawRootAuthorTag = authorTagValues.length > 0 && Boolean(expectedRootAuthor);
+  const sawParentKindTag = kindTagValues.length > 0 && Boolean(expectedParentKind);
+  const sawParentAuthorTag =
+    authorTagValues.length > 0 && Boolean(expectedParentAuthor);
+
+  const rootKindMatches =
+    !expectedRootKind || kindTagValues.includes(expectedRootKind);
+  const rootAuthorMatches =
+    !expectedRootAuthor || authorTagValues.includes(expectedRootAuthor);
+  const parentKindMatches =
+    !expectedParentKind || kindTagValues.includes(expectedParentKind);
+  const parentAuthorMatches =
+    !expectedParentAuthor || authorTagValues.includes(expectedParentAuthor);
+
   if (!hasDefinitionTag && requiresAddressMatch && matchedEventPointer) {
     hasDefinitionTag = true;
   }
@@ -1107,14 +1056,6 @@ function isVideoCommentEvent(event, descriptor) {
     return false;
   }
 
-  if ((sawRootKindTag && rootKindMismatch) || (sawRootAuthorTag && rootAuthorMismatch)) {
-    return false;
-  }
-
-  if ((sawParentKindTag && parentKindMismatch) || (sawParentAuthorTag && parentAuthorMismatch)) {
-    return false;
-  }
-
   if (sawRootKindTag && expectedRootKind && !rootKindMatches) {
     return false;
   }

js/nostrEventSchemas.js

@@ -334,16 +334,16 @@ const BASE_SCHEMAS = {
     type: NOTE_TYPES.VIDEO_COMMENT,
     label: "Video comment",
     kind: 1111,
-    videoEventTagName: "e",
-    videoDefinitionTagName: "a",
-    parentCommentTagName: "e",
-    parentAuthorTagName: "p",
+    videoEventTagName: "E",
+    videoDefinitionTagName: "A",
+    parentCommentTagName: "E",
+    parentAuthorTagName: "P",
     rootEventPointerTagName: "E",
     rootDefinitionPointerTagName: "A",
     rootIdentifierPointerTagName: "I",
     rootKindTagName: "K",
     rootAuthorTagName: "P",
-    parentKindTagName: "k",
+    parentKindTagName: "K",
     appendTags: DEFAULT_APPEND_TAGS,
     content: {
       format: "text",
@@ -1199,11 +1199,12 @@ export function buildCommentEvent({
   const rootIdentifierPointerTagName = schema?.rootIdentifierPointerTagName || "I";
   const rootKindTagName = schema?.rootKindTagName || "K";
   const rootAuthorTagName = schema?.rootAuthorTagName || "P";
-  const videoDefinitionTagName = schema?.videoDefinitionTagName || "a";
-  const videoEventTagName = schema?.videoEventTagName || "e";
-  const parentCommentTagName = schema?.parentCommentTagName || "e";
-  const parentAuthorTagName = schema?.parentAuthorTagName || "p";
-  const parentKindTagName = schema?.parentKindTagName || "k";
+  const parentIdentifierTagName = schema?.parentIdentifierTagName || "I";
+  const videoDefinitionTagName = schema?.videoDefinitionTagName || "A";
+  const videoEventTagName = schema?.videoEventTagName || "E";
+  const parentCommentTagName = schema?.parentCommentTagName || "E";
+  const parentAuthorTagName = schema?.parentAuthorTagName || "P";
+  const parentKindTagName = schema?.parentKindTagName || "K";
 
   const appendPointerTag = (tagName, value, relay, authorHint) => {
     if (!tagName || !value) {
@@ -1272,7 +1273,11 @@ export function buildCommentEvent({
   }
 
   if (normalizedParentIdentifier) {
-    appendPointerTag("i", normalizedParentIdentifier, normalizedParentIdentifierRelay);
+    appendPointerTag(
+      parentIdentifierTagName,
+      normalizedParentIdentifier,
+      normalizedParentIdentifierRelay,
+    );
   }
 
   if (parentCommentTagName && normalizedParentCommentId) {

js/services/discussionCountService.js

@@ -131,7 +131,7 @@ export default class DiscussionCountService {
     const filters = [];
     const eventId = typeof video.id === "string" ? video.id.trim() : "";
     if (eventId) {
-      filters.push({ kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND], "#e": [eventId] });
+      filters.push({ kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND], "#E": [eventId] });
     }
 
     const address = buildVideoAddressPointer(video);
@@ -181,7 +181,7 @@ export default class DiscussionCountService {
     }
 
     if (address) {
-      filters.push({ kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND], "#a": [address] });
+      filters.push({ kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND], "#A": [address] });
     }
 
     return filters;

tests/comment-event-builder.test.mjs

@@ -48,10 +48,9 @@ test("buildCommentEvent emits NIP-22 root metadata while keeping legacy fallback
     ["A", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-1"],
     ["K", "30078"],
     ["P", "deadbeefcafebabe"],
-    ["e", "video-event-id"],
-    ["a", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-1"],
-    ["k", "30078"],
-    ["p", "deadbeefcafebabe"],
+    ["E", "video-event-id"],
+    ["A", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-1"],
+    ["K", "30078"],
   ]);
   assert.equal(event.content, "Great video!");
 });
@@ -72,11 +71,11 @@ test("buildCommentEvent includes parent pointers, kinds, and authors for replies
     ["A", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-1"],
     ["K", "30078"],
     ["P", "deadbeefcafebabe"],
-    ["e", "video-event-id"],
-    ["a", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-1"],
-    ["e", "parent-comment-id", "parent-author"],
-    ["k", String(VIDEO_COMMENT_KIND)],
-    ["p", "parent-author"],
+    ["E", "video-event-id"],
+    ["A", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-1"],
+    ["E", "parent-comment-id", "parent-author"],
+    ["K", String(VIDEO_COMMENT_KIND)],
+    ["P", "parent-author"],
   ]);
 });
 
@@ -101,11 +100,11 @@ test("buildCommentEvent normalizes relays and preserves explicit overrides", ()
     ["A", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-2", "wss://video.def"],
     ["K", "30078"],
     ["P", "deadbeefcafebabe", "wss://video.def"],
-    ["e", "event123", "wss://comments.main"],
-    ["a", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-2", "wss://video.def"],
-    ["e", "root-comment", "wss://parent", "cafecafe"],
-    ["k", String(VIDEO_COMMENT_KIND)],
-    ["p", "cafecafe", "wss://profile"],
+    ["E", "event123", "wss://comments.main"],
+    ["A", "30078:deadbeefcafebabe:clip-2", "wss://video.def"],
+    ["E", "root-comment", "wss://parent", "cafecafe"],
+    ["K", String(VIDEO_COMMENT_KIND)],
+    ["P", "cafecafe", "wss://profile"],
     ["client", "bitvid"],
   ]);
   assert.equal(event.content, " Appreciated! ");
@@ -128,9 +127,9 @@ test("buildCommentEvent falls back to event pointers when no address is supplied
     ["E", "legacy-event", "wss://legacy.example", "legacy-author"],
     ["K", "1063"],
     ["P", "legacy-author"],
-    ["e", "legacy-event", "wss://legacy.example"],
-    ["k", "1063"],
-    ["p", "legacy-pubkey"],
+    ["E", "legacy-event", "wss://legacy.example"],
+    ["K", "1063"],
+    ["P", "legacy-pubkey"],
   ]);
 });
 
@@ -152,10 +151,10 @@ test("buildCommentEvent accepts partial metadata for parent overrides", () => {
   assert.deepStrictEqual(event.tags, [
     ["E", "file-event"],
     ["K", "1063"],
-    ["e", "file-event"],
-    ["e", "parent-comment", "wss://parent", "parent-only"],
-    ["k", "1111"],
-    ["p", "parent-only", "wss://parent-author"],
+    ["E", "file-event"],
+    ["E", "parent-comment", "wss://parent", "parent-only"],
+    ["K", "1111"],
+    ["P", "parent-only", "wss://parent-author"],
   ]);
 });
 

tests/comment-thread-service.test.mjs

@@ -608,18 +608,18 @@ test(
       topLevelEvent.tags.some(
         (tag) =>
           Array.isArray(tag) &&
-          tag[0] === "e" &&
+          tag[0] === "E" &&
           tag[1] === videoEventId &&
           tag[2] === relayUrl,
       ),
-      "builder should retain legacy #e tag for the root event when address pointer is present",
+      "builder should retain uppercase #E tag for the root event when address pointer is present",
     );
     assert.ok(
       topLevelEvent.tags.some(
         (tag) =>
-          Array.isArray(tag) && tag[0] === "a" && tag[1] === videoDefinitionAddress,
+          Array.isArray(tag) && tag[0] === "A" && tag[1] === videoDefinitionAddress,
       ),
-      "builder should include #a pointer for the scoped video definition",
+      "builder should include #A pointer for the scoped video definition",
     );
 
     const replyEvent = {
@@ -645,18 +645,18 @@ test(
       replyEvent.tags.some(
         (tag) =>
           Array.isArray(tag) &&
-          tag[0] === "e" &&
+          tag[0] === "E" &&
           tag[1] === videoEventId &&
           tag[2] === relayUrl,
       ),
-      "reply builder should include root #e tag alongside #a pointer",
+      "reply builder should include root #E tag alongside #A pointer",
     );
     assert.ok(
       replyEvent.tags.some(
         (tag) =>
-          Array.isArray(tag) && tag[0] === "a" && tag[1] === videoDefinitionAddress,
+          Array.isArray(tag) && tag[0] === "A" && tag[1] === videoDefinitionAddress,
       ),
-      "reply builder should preserve #a pointer",
+      "reply builder should preserve #A pointer",
     );
 
     const listCalls = [];

tests/discussion-count-service.test.mjs

@@ -40,7 +40,7 @@ async function testRefreshCountsCachesResults() {
       const [eventFilter, uppercaseFilter, addressFilter] = filters;
       assert.deepEqual(eventFilter, {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#e": ["count-video-1"],
+        "#E": ["count-video-1"],
       });
       assert.deepEqual(uppercaseFilter, {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
@@ -50,7 +50,7 @@ async function testRefreshCountsCachesResults() {
       });
       assert.deepEqual(addressFilter, {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#a": ["30078:pubkey-1:identifier-1"],
+        "#A": ["30078:pubkey-1:identifier-1"],
       });
       return {
         total: 5,
@@ -123,7 +123,7 @@ async function testUnsupportedRelaysUpdateDomState() {
       const [eventFilter, uppercaseFilter, addressFilter] = filters;
       assert.deepEqual(eventFilter, {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#e": ["unsupported-video"],
+        "#E": ["unsupported-video"],
       });
       assert.deepEqual(uppercaseFilter, {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
@@ -133,7 +133,7 @@ async function testUnsupportedRelaysUpdateDomState() {
       });
       assert.deepEqual(addressFilter, {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#a": ["30078:pubkey-2:identifier-2"],
+        "#A": ["30078:pubkey-2:identifier-2"],
       });
       return {
         total: 7,

tests/nostr/comment-events.test.mjs

@@ -118,13 +118,13 @@ test("publishComment prefers active signer when available", async () => {
       ["A", "30078:deadbeef:clip", "wss://definition-relay"],
       ["K", "30078"],
       ["P", "deadbeef", "wss://definition-relay"],
-      ["e", "video-event-id", "wss://video-relay"],
-      ["a", "30078:deadbeef:clip", "wss://definition-relay"],
-      ["e", "parent-comment-id", "thread-participant"],
-      ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-      ["p", "thread-participant"],
+      ["E", "video-event-id", "wss://video-relay"],
+      ["A", "30078:deadbeef:clip", "wss://definition-relay"],
+      ["E", "parent-comment-id", "thread-participant"],
+      ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+      ["P", "thread-participant"],
     ],
-    "comment event should include NIP-22 root tags while preserving fallback markers",
+    "comment event should include uppercase pointers and participant metadata",
   );
 });
 
@@ -193,9 +193,9 @@ test("publishComment accepts legacy targets with only an event id", async () =>
     [
       ["E", "legacy-event-id"],
       ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-      ["e", "legacy-event-id"],
-      ["e", "parent-legacy"],
-      ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+      ["E", "legacy-event-id"],
+      ["E", "parent-legacy"],
+      ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
     ],
     "legacy publish should emit uppercase root metadata with lowercase fallbacks",
   );
@@ -213,10 +213,10 @@ test("publishComment derives root and parent metadata from parent comment tags",
       ["K", "30078"],
       ["P", "videopk", "wss://author"],
       ["A", "30078:videopk:root", "wss://definition"],
-      ["e", "video-event", "wss://root"],
-      ["e", "parent-comment", "wss://parent", "parentpk"],
-      ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-      ["p", "parentpk", "wss://parent"],
+      ["E", "video-event", "wss://root"],
+      ["E", "parent-comment", "wss://parent", "parentpk"],
+      ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+      ["P", "parentpk", "wss://parent"],
     ],
   };
 
@@ -240,11 +240,11 @@ test("publishComment derives root and parent metadata from parent comment tags",
     ["A", "30078:videopk:root", "wss://definition"],
     ["K", "30078"],
     ["P", "videopk", "wss://author"],
-    ["e", "video-event", "wss://root"],
-    ["a", "30078:videopk:root", "wss://definition"],
-    ["e", "parent-comment", "wss://parent", "parentpk"],
-    ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-    ["p", "parentpk", "wss://parent"],
+    ["E", "video-event", "wss://root"],
+    ["A", "30078:videopk:root", "wss://definition"],
+    ["E", "parent-comment", "wss://parent", "parentpk"],
+    ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+    ["P", "parentpk", "wss://parent"],
   ]);
 });
 
@@ -255,11 +255,11 @@ test("listVideoComments matches comments even when tag casing and whitespace dif
     created_at: 1700000300,
     tags: [
       [" A ", " 30078:AUTHOR:CLIP ", " WSS://Definition "],
-      ["e", " VIDEO-1 "],
+      ["E", " VIDEO-1 "],
       [" E ", " VIDEO-1 "],
-      ["e", " PARENT-1 "],
-      ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-      ["p", " THREAD-PARTICIPANT "],
+      ["E", " PARENT-1 "],
+      ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+      ["P", " THREAD-PARTICIPANT "],
     ],
   };
 
@@ -293,7 +293,7 @@ test("listVideoComments matches uppercase definition addresses without lowering"
     created_at: 1700000400,
     tags: [
       ["A", uppercasePointer],
-      ["e", "video-1"],
+      ["E", "video-1"],
     ],
   };
 
@@ -324,11 +324,11 @@ test("listVideoComments matches comments even when tag casing and whitespace dif
     created_at: 1700000300,
     tags: [
       [" A ", " 30078:AUTHOR:CLIP ", " WSS://Definition "],
-      ["e", " VIDEO-1 "],
+      ["E", " VIDEO-1 "],
       [" E ", " VIDEO-1 "],
-      ["e", " PARENT-1 "],
-      ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-      ["p", " THREAD-PARTICIPANT "],
+      ["E", " PARENT-1 "],
+      ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+      ["P", " THREAD-PARTICIPANT "],
     ],
   };
 
@@ -354,11 +354,11 @@ test("listVideoComments matches comments even when tag casing and whitespace dif
   );
 });
 
-    ["p", "parentpk", "wss://parent"],
+    ["P", "parentpk", "wss://parent"],
   ]);
 });
 
-test("publishComment emits only video event #e tag when address and parent are absent", async () => {
+test("publishComment emits only uppercase video event pointer when address and parent are absent", async () => {
   const { client, publishCalls } = createMockClient();
 
   const signer = {
@@ -389,9 +389,8 @@ test("publishComment emits only video event #e tag when address and parent are a
     tags,
     [
       ["E", "video-only"],
-      ["e", "video-only"],
     ],
-    "event should include an uppercase root pointer along with the legacy #e tag",
+    "event should include a single uppercase pointer",
   );
 });
 
@@ -404,9 +403,9 @@ test("listVideoComments builds filters with uppercase roots plus legacy fallback
       ["A", "30078:author:clip"],
       ["K", "30078"],
       ["P", "author"],
-      ["e", "parent-1"],
-      ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-      ["p", "thread-participant"],
+      ["E", "parent-1"],
+      ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+      ["P", "thread-participant"],
     ],
   };
 
@@ -415,8 +414,8 @@ test("listVideoComments builds filters with uppercase roots plus legacy fallback
     kind: COMMENT_EVENT_KIND,
     created_at: 1690000000,
     tags: [
-      ["a", "30078:author:clip"],
-      ["e", "parent-1"],
+      ["A", "30078:author:clip"],
+      ["E", "parent-1"],
     ],
   };
 
@@ -424,7 +423,7 @@ test("listVideoComments builds filters with uppercase roots plus legacy fallback
     id: "comment-3",
     kind: COMMENT_EVENT_KIND,
     created_at: 1700000100,
-    tags: [["a", "30078:author:clip"]],
+    tags: [["A", "30078:author:clip"]],
   };
 
   const {
@@ -473,9 +472,9 @@ test("listVideoComments builds filters with uppercase roots plus legacy fallback
     "event filter should target comment kind",
   );
   assert.deepEqual(
-    eventFilter["#e"],
+    eventFilter["#E"],
     ["video-1"],
-    "event filter should target the video via #e",
+    "event filter should target the video via #E",
   );
   assert.equal(
     uppercaseFilter.kinds[0],
@@ -511,11 +510,11 @@ test("listVideoComments builds filters with uppercase roots plus legacy fallback
     parentFilter,
     {
       kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-      "#e": ["parent-1"],
+      "#E": ["parent-1"],
       since: 1700000000,
       limit: 10,
     },
-    "parent filter should scope the thread via #e",
+    "parent filter should scope the thread via #E",
   );
   assert.equal(
     eventFilter.since,
@@ -534,12 +533,12 @@ test("listVideoComments builds filters with uppercase roots plus legacy fallback
     "definition filter should target comment kind",
   );
   assert.deepEqual(
-    definitionFilter["#a"],
+    definitionFilter["#A"],
     ["30078:author:clip"],
-    "definition filter should bind the video definition via #a",
+    "definition filter should bind the video definition via #A",
   );
   assert.deepEqual(
-    definitionFilter["#e"],
+    definitionFilter["#E"],
     ["parent-1"],
     "definition filter should continue scoping to the parent comment",
   );
@@ -555,14 +554,14 @@ test("listVideoComments builds filters with uppercase roots plus legacy fallback
   );
 });
 
-test("listVideoComments adds lowercase root filters when only the identifier is known", async () => {
+test("listVideoComments emits uppercase root filters when only the identifier is known", async () => {
   const matchingEvent = {
     id: "comment-root",
     kind: COMMENT_EVENT_KIND,
     tags: [
       ["I", "root-only"],
       ["P", "root-author"],
-      ["e", "video-rooted"],
+      ["E", "video-rooted"],
     ],
   };
 
@@ -589,44 +588,21 @@ test("listVideoComments adds lowercase root filters when only the identifier is
   assert.ok(receivedFilters, "pool.list should receive filters");
   assert.equal(
     receivedFilters.filters.length,
-    4,
-    "root identifier requests should include lowercase fallbacks",
+    2,
+    "root identifier requests should emit uppercase filters only",
   );
 
-  const [eventFilter, uppercaseEventFilter, lowercaseRootFilter, uppercaseRootFilter] =
-    receivedFilters.filters;
+  const [eventFilter, uppercaseRootFilter] = receivedFilters.filters;
 
   assert.deepEqual(
     eventFilter,
-    {
-      kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-      "#e": ["video-rooted"],
-      since: 1700000000,
-      limit: 5,
-    },
-    "event filter should continue targeting the video event id",
-  );
-
-  assert.deepEqual(
-    uppercaseEventFilter,
     {
       kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
       "#E": ["video-rooted"],
       since: 1700000000,
       limit: 5,
     },
-    "uppercase event filter should continue targeting legacy #E pointers",
-  );
-
-  assert.deepEqual(
-    lowercaseRootFilter,
-    {
-      kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-      "#i": ["root-only"],
-      since: 1700000000,
-      limit: 5,
-    },
-    "root identifier filter should include lowercase #i tag queries",
+    "event filter should target the video event id via #E",
   );
 
   assert.equal(
@@ -660,7 +636,7 @@ test("listVideoComments supports legacy targets without a definition address", a
   const legacyEvent = {
     id: "legacy-comment",
     kind: COMMENT_EVENT_KIND,
-    tags: [["e", "legacy-video"]],
+    tags: [["E", "legacy-video"]],
   };
 
   const { client, pool } = createMockClient();
@@ -688,14 +664,14 @@ test("listVideoComments supports legacy targets without a definition address", a
     [
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#e": ["legacy-video"],
+        "#E": ["legacy-video"],
       },
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
         "#E": ["legacy-video"],
       },
     ],
-    "legacy listing should target the video event id via #e/#E",
+    "legacy listing should target the video event id via #E",
   );
 });
 
@@ -756,7 +732,7 @@ test("subscribeVideoComments forwards matching events and cleans up unsubscribe"
     [
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#e": ["video-1"],
+        "#E": ["video-1"],
       },
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
@@ -766,12 +742,12 @@ test("subscribeVideoComments forwards matching events and cleans up unsubscribe"
       },
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#e": ["parent-1"],
+        "#E": ["parent-1"],
       },
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
         "#a": ["30078:author:clip"],
-        "#e": ["parent-1"],
+        "#E": ["parent-1"],
       },
     ],
     "subscription should emit event, parent, and address filters",
@@ -784,16 +760,16 @@ test("subscribeVideoComments forwards matching events and cleans up unsubscribe"
       ["A", "30078:author:clip"],
       ["K", "30078"],
       ["P", "author"],
-      ["e", "parent-1"],
-      ["k", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
-      ["p", "thread-participant"],
+      ["E", "parent-1"],
+      ["K", String(COMMENT_EVENT_KIND)],
+      ["P", "thread-participant"],
     ],
   });
 
   handler({
     id: "comment-rejected",
     kind: COMMENT_EVENT_KIND,
-    tags: [["e", "video-1"]],
+    tags: [["E", "video-1"]],
   });
 
   assert.equal(receivedEvents.length, 1, "only matching events should reach the callback");
@@ -839,7 +815,7 @@ test("subscribeVideoComments supports video targets without a definition address
     [
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
-        "#e": ["legacy-video"],
+        "#E": ["legacy-video"],
       },
       {
         kinds: [COMMENT_EVENT_KIND],
@@ -854,7 +830,7 @@ test("subscribeVideoComments supports video targets without a definition address
   handler({
     id: "legacy-comment",
     kind: COMMENT_EVENT_KIND,
-    tags: [["e", "legacy-video"]],
+    tags: [["E", "legacy-video"]],
   });
 
   assert.equal(receivedEvents.length, 1, "legacy comment should be forwarded");