TASK-6e4ff870 pin B2 real composition and current Fleet handoffs

This commit is contained in:
thePR0M3TH3AN committed 2026-10-01 13:09:28 -04:00
1 parent 2f4650c3a1
commit d66f3da889
6 files changed
+291 -16

No files matched your search

@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
"schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1",
"id": "TASK-6e4ff870-a386-4a11-a59c-444ebc23732e",
"title": "Separate candidate source qualification from live control-plane initialization",
"description": "Explicit owner a970326b-87a5-4292-8f22-e1bec0c15f11/92f7fd36 corrects the inventory: no explicit existing check-engine separation item exists. Add ONE proposed bounded item in the existing backlog. Incident observed on canonical cb145e56 and Kernel reservation candidate be1ae951: candidate CLI initialized production schema3 during qualification, installed/canonical schema2 writers relabel it, and native CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED currentVersion2 requiredVersion3 then prevents qualification, causing activation/landing circularity. Design supported separation of exact candidate-source execution engine from a versioned, independently fingerprinted compatible receipt/control-plane adapter without migrating live production state merely to test candidate. Preserve actual authenticated native project/area/commit/definition/run/resource/guard/outcome evidence and immutable artifacts. Work owns src/checks, Kernel src/control-plane, Release CLI wiring and QA scenarios/acceptance; agree exact contract, owned paths and scenario consent before any implementation. No old-checker shortcut, fake isolated real-project receipts, gate waiver, install activation, production DB recovery, new identity or parallel queue. TASK-4dc metadata/candidate preparation remains completed; its retained deeper provenance roadmap was not an explicit task until this proposal.\n\nCurrent authorized phase (owner36788020/21997bf1, QAa0e8ae17): bounded Phase A implementation preparation/development on this SAME Work assignment. Only NEW src/checks/candidate-engine.mjs and src/checks/artifact-manifest.mjs, new QA-consented test/fleet/candidate-engine.test.mjs and test/fleet/candidate-artifact-manifest.test.mjs, and append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Extract reviewed pure raw-terminal execution and trusted parent artifact-collection seams; frozen inputs/args/env/artifact limits, parent-only observed terminal/envelope with no candidate writer capability, capped canonical regular-file manifest and strict traversal/link/special/overwrite/seal-drift rejection. Hermetic fixture/fake-adapter evidence is permanently development-only/nonpromotable. No existing conditions behavior changes or CheckService/CLI/integration/consumer wiring; no store/provisioner/schema/DDL/receipt-consumer/gate-policy/resource-lease changes, live recovery, installation/host/provider/wake/publication actions. QA remains final test owner. Phase A does not complete this full task or qualify native/operational acceptance. Later Kernel store/context/adapter, Release CLI and Work explicit source-consumer phases remain proposed and require separate scoped decisions; retain actual native guards and all existing full acceptance criteria.\n\nCurrent B1 contribution is separately authorized by actual owner b819ecbc after corrected QA c3e0241 exact-path/scenario consent and Work4a3c8ab6 protocol agreement. SAME Work-owned task, named Kernel contributor only: NEW src/kernel/managed-subject-metadata.mjs, NEW src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs, NEW test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Bounded data-only V1 fixture/untrusted observation parsing, opaque issued fixtures, strict clone/expiry/reuse/selectors-before-parse negatives and explicit missing native composition. V1 refuses parent/native/loaded-engine claims and V2-shaped fields; no fixture promotion. V2 dependency/snapshot binding remains reserved, not implemented parent/consumer authority. Exact source candidate needs independent QA; actual frozen execution, enforced fences, compatible native adapter/consumers and operational acceptance remain mandatory later phases. No DB/DDL/writer/adapter/receipt/parent/consumer/CLI/runtime/host/provider/wake/publication scope. Owner reports existing Kernel active3473803; no new assignment or manager start.",
"description": "Explicit owner a970326b-87a5-4292-8f22-e1bec0c15f11/92f7fd36 corrects the inventory: no explicit existing check-engine separation item exists. Add ONE proposed bounded item in the existing backlog. Incident observed on canonical cb145e56 and Kernel reservation candidate be1ae951: candidate CLI initialized production schema3 during qualification, installed/canonical schema2 writers relabel it, and native CONTROL_PLANE_SCHEMA_DOWNGRADE_DETECTED currentVersion2 requiredVersion3 then prevents qualification, causing activation/landing circularity. Design supported separation of exact candidate-source execution engine from a versioned, independently fingerprinted compatible receipt/control-plane adapter without migrating live production state merely to test candidate. Preserve actual authenticated native project/area/commit/definition/run/resource/guard/outcome evidence and immutable artifacts. Work owns src/checks, Kernel src/control-plane, Release CLI wiring and QA scenarios/acceptance; agree exact contract, owned paths and scenario consent before any implementation. No old-checker shortcut, fake isolated real-project receipts, gate waiver, install activation, production DB recovery, new identity or parallel queue. TASK-4dc metadata/candidate preparation remains completed; its retained deeper provenance roadmap was not an explicit task until this proposal.\n\nCurrent authorized phase (owner36788020/21997bf1, QAa0e8ae17): bounded Phase A implementation preparation/development on this SAME Work assignment. Only NEW src/checks/candidate-engine.mjs and src/checks/artifact-manifest.mjs, new QA-consented test/fleet/candidate-engine.test.mjs and test/fleet/candidate-artifact-manifest.test.mjs, and append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Extract reviewed pure raw-terminal execution and trusted parent artifact-collection seams; frozen inputs/args/env/artifact limits, parent-only observed terminal/envelope with no candidate writer capability, capped canonical regular-file manifest and strict traversal/link/special/overwrite/seal-drift rejection. Hermetic fixture/fake-adapter evidence is permanently development-only/nonpromotable. No existing conditions behavior changes or CheckService/CLI/integration/consumer wiring; no store/provisioner/schema/DDL/receipt-consumer/gate-policy/resource-lease changes, live recovery, installation/host/provider/wake/publication actions. QA remains final test owner. Phase A does not complete this full task or qualify native/operational acceptance. Later Kernel store/context/adapter, Release CLI and Work explicit source-consumer phases remain proposed and require separate scoped decisions; retain actual native guards and all existing full acceptance criteria.\n\nCurrent B1 contribution is separately authorized by actual owner b819ecbc after corrected QA c3e0241 exact-path/scenario consent and Work4a3c8ab6 protocol agreement. SAME Work-owned task, named Kernel contributor only: NEW src/kernel/managed-subject-metadata.mjs, NEW src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs, NEW test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md. Bounded data-only V1 fixture/untrusted observation parsing, opaque issued fixtures, strict clone/expiry/reuse/selectors-before-parse negatives and explicit missing native composition. V1 refuses parent/native/loaded-engine claims and V2-shaped fields; no fixture promotion. V2 dependency/snapshot binding remains reserved, not implemented parent/consumer authority. Exact source candidate needs independent QA; actual frozen execution, enforced fences, compatible native adapter/consumers and operational acceptance remain mandatory later phases. No DB/DDL/writer/adapter/receipt/parent/consumer/CLI/runtime/host/provider/wake/publication scope. Owner reports existing Kernel active3473803; no new assignment or manager start.\n\nCurrent B1 exact955672c fixture-source is independently ACCEPTED by QAa13 after actual prefix/blob verification, not native or whole-branch acceptance. Existing9b pre-copy defect and b375 TIN rejection retained. Next concrete B2 packet is in the Manager PhaseB report: named Kernel no-args parent/explicitV2, Work new bounded frozen-input/actual-child execution/fence modules with positive black-box consumption and escaped-descendant coverage scenarios, followed by compatible no-DDL Kernel store/adapter and later actual Work/Release consumers. Exact contributors/scenarios/backend/native compatibility decisions requested; no B2 source authority or new assignment. Full real native/operational criteria remain mandatory.",
"priority": "high",
"affectedDomains": [
"work-integration",
@@ -78,14 +78,20 @@
"git:project-kernel:clean-b375037a9ca5c20704204b52e9ffb3d8060494d9:fourpath-c08-delta-diffcheck-observed16:33",
"message:bec5581a-bac8-4e49-b1fa-30aba2abdbe9:existing-QA-exact-b375-independent-review-request",
"message:5c0378fa-d323-4808-a6f4-cb834c64acf6:Work-exact-b375-protocol-review-handoff",
"message:c73fb0f6-78bf-40c5-87ae-a61c629f382c:QA-b375-REJECTED-only-TIN-placement-independent10/10-zero-copy-technicalPASS-not-sourceacceptance"
"message:c73fb0f6-78bf-40c5-87ae-a61c629f382c:QA-b375-REJECTED-only-TIN-placement-independent10/10-zero-copy-technicalPASS-not-sourceacceptance",
"message:a13b5c37-12a3-4757-832c-1938b392f962:exact955-B1-fixture-source-ACCEPTED-10strict-c08prefix156398-and-threeblobs-unchanged-not-native-wholebranch",
"message:29e80f3b-48d2-4b36-be7e-648bbc791845:actual-prefixproof-after-EPERM-corrects-earlier9982-chronology",
"message:82157432-0001-4aaa-89e3-9f56ea14486c:Work-exact-B2-input/fence-protocol-decision-request",
"message:6797e181-cfbd-4f70-a370-a5c7d9cc1407:Kernel-exact-B2-parentV2/native-transport-request",
"message:239ebf46-7050-4ae1-be74-2b7f548553cb:QA-positive-parent/realinput/fence-scenario-scope-request",
"report:reports/protocol/candidate-source-phase-b-proposal-2026-10-01.md:17:02-B2a-parent-frozeninput-B2b-fence-B2c-adapter-B2d-nativeconsumers-exact-map"
],
"commit": "316d8b7480c2e10925ebdff8310fe26ef5a881a8",
"integrationRequest": "a1789e46-b91e-496c-9204-ab204dac6a6d",
"blockedReason": null,
"createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:14:01.401Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T16:39:30.000Z",
"revision": 12,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z",
"revision": 13,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -170,6 +176,13 @@
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T16:39:30.000Z",
"note": "Metadata-only exact QA verdict reconciliation expectedrev11. QAc73 narrowly rejects b375 for inserted23line allocation-correction TIN block at line48 violating append-only rule; independently10/10 focused/syntax/clean/namespace/direct1MiB+1 zero-copy technical evidence passes. Same original scope correction only move exact unchanged block to document end; source/test semantics unchanged, existing Kernel through arbiter and exact resulting QA review. No stale source-acceptance wait/owner permission request or full native acceptance. Preserve9b failure,b375 technicalPASS/rejection,state/owner/316a178/sevencriteria/history."
},
{
"from": "verification",
"to": "verification",
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z",
"note": "Reviewed metadata-only expectedrev12 records actual QAa13 narrow exact955 acceptance and owner29e corrected EPERM chronology; b375 placement wait resolved, no source/native/wholebranch gate waiver. Retain Work verification/316a178/sevencriteria/history. Concrete B2a-d owned-path/positive-scenario/native qualification packet requested from existing peers, no implementation or second assignment."
}
]
}
@@ -82,14 +82,19 @@
"message:33d44dad-3ab1-4ac4-8b76-8017297decad:independent-exact4fa-source-native-qualification-accepted",
"integration:0d46fb5c-1027-4ead-b969-f760afb72e9f:landed2026-10-01T16:25:59.349Z:exact4fa:manager-native-plan-no-blockers",
"message:0bf6a212:owner-future-cleanunique-worktree-warning-vs-hazard-distinction",
"message:9ab0e108-ac63-4de8-87fe-8986ec05cf21:future-bounded-overview-and-advisorycount-roadmap-requirement"
"message:9ab0e108-ac63-4de8-87fe-8986ec05cf21:future-bounded-overview-and-advisorycount-roadmap-requirement",
"message:1ece397d-ac61-4d5b-8500-4c26cf7ddc8b:exact-four-sitepath-Overview/newdensitytest/appendTIN-proposal-not-implementation",
"message:1b4836fd-2c3c-4983-957d-daf17cb0e45b:QA-concrete-Overview-positive-fullqueue/guards-scenario-request",
"message:d2feed55-f6dc-4c72-92c3-9b55a39af808:message-cohort/newestdecision/supersession-fullhistory-requirement",
"message:a6b8dfa4-a8b4-43b9-908d-bc8d13f84e1f:usable-Overview-sixpath-five-strict-scenario-consent-crowded49plus17-density1440/390-not-sourceauthority",
"message:06f94f44-4789-47f9-a689-1c6b5c9429d6:actual-current-source-uniqueinfo/Work347baseline-preserve-no-duplicatefix-browser-disconnected-Releaseactive"
],
"commit": "4fa9bd7d490fb740eb1d0bdf3dc9cafa2f309ba1",
"integrationRequest": "0d46fb5c-1027-4ead-b969-f760afb72e9f",
"blockedReason": "Exact 4fa9 source independently accepted by QA33d44dad/6dfa and landed once via native request0d46 at16:25:59 with authorized Manager plan no blockers/four native PASS/eleven hashes. Source review and integration are resolved. Full acceptance remains blocked on actual live/installed desktop/mobile owner flow and served UI/API provenance; generated demo artifact checks do not establish live visual acceptance. Pending human runtime75 is separate from satisfied PNG recovery; pointer switch alone cannot qualify missing blockedReason. No installation, host, provider, wakes, schema or publication action.",
"createdAt": "2026-09-30T22:56:50.255Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T16:28:00.000Z",
"revision": 18,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z",
"revision": 20,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -216,6 +221,20 @@
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T16:28:00.000Z",
"note": "Reviewed metadata-only expected revision17 records actual owner0bf/9ab future requirements on existing attention/workflow roadmap after single source4fa landing. No new task, current source scope expansion, assignment, cleanup or test relaxation. Preserve all original16criteria/state/owner/exact4fa/0d46/history and incomplete actual live acceptance."
},
{
"from": "blocked",
"to": "blocked",
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z",
"note": "Metadata-only expectedrev18. Actual Console1ece names site/console.html,site/console.js,site/attention-projection.js,site/styles.css plus newQA densitytest/appendTIN proposal; route exact contributor scenarios before later authority. Separate provenance consumer, no implementation expansion/new assignment. Preserve source4fa/0d46 blocked liveacceptance/18criteria/history. Ownerd2feed message grouping retains recipient/permission/history integrity and no massack."
},
{
"from": "blocked",
"to": "blocked",
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z",
"note": "Metadata-only actualQAa6b usable exact Overview four-sitepath/newdensitytest/appendTIN consent resolves routine contributor hold; five strict scenarios/crowded49+17/density1440x1000/390x844 preserve Work347 baseline and existing Fleet3/runtime.review/kernel.info/qa.urgent. Owner06 confirms unique-info already implemented, no duplicate fix/test relaxation. Later exact arbiter source scope separate; no implementation authority/newassignment/state/sourcecommit change. Actual browser disconnected/full liveacceptance remains open; separate Release implementation active."
}
]
}
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
"schema": "torch.dev/backlog-item/v1alpha1",
"id": "TASK-conversation-console-workflow",
"title": "Complete scoped owner workflow controls and live dashboard qualification",
"description": "Existing Console supports several previewed actions and live refresh. Audit remaining desired owner controls (assignment/routing, lifecycle, integration and release views) against spec and current capabilities; implement only individually authorized operations. Qualify real provider activity and native background/back-cache refresh while preserving edits and private artifact provenance.",
"description": "Existing Console supports several previewed actions and live refresh. Audit remaining desired owner controls (assignment/routing, lifecycle, integration and release views) against spec and current capabilities; implement only individually authorized operations. Qualify real provider activity and native background/back-cache refresh while preserving edits and private artifact provenance.\n\nCurrent partial Release contribution is authorized by owner15c48fa3 under actual QA818/f0bad: ONLY NEW src/self-host/runtime-metadata.mjs, NEW test/fleet/runtime-metadata.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md after guarded clean convergence to4fa. Console retains full owner. Inventory-only internal relative links hash bounded link text without target content traversal; metadata/UI file links refuse; fixed active pointer separate. readerModuleEvaluation reports only reader/local artifact observations, authunknown and memory/delivery null. Native authority and Console consumer/source UI changes excluded. Four exact native source gates/immutable artifacts and independent QA precede single guarded integration. Separate future Overview four-sitepath/newdensitytest and snapshot.mjs consumer proposals require their own exact QA scopes; no code authority from this metadata recording.",
"priority": "normal",
"affectedDomains": [
"owner-console",
@@ -16,7 +16,8 @@
"Live owner flow exposes served UI and API engine version plus exact immutable artifact/source provenance separately from repository HEAD; mixed loaded versions, stale immutable candidates and unavailable provenance are explicitly truthful, never inferred from source PASS or pointer labels",
"A later independently qualified current release and actual desktop/mobile live owner flow display each current blocked task's durable blockedReason with provenance; missing or stale runtime fields remain explicit unknown/mismatch. Canonical316 source already contains blockedReason, while reported activealpha2 and immutablealpha3 omit it; alpha3 pointer switch alone does not satisfy this criterion",
"Observed local runtime version, declared source commit and recomputed artifact/UI hash consistency remain useful visible diagnostic observations separately from authentication unknown. Local unsigned metadata is not loaded-memory or delivered-browser-byte proof; absent signing infrastructure does not erase observations or prevent bounded dashboard diagnostics. Mixed/stale/unavailable provenance and actual live blockedReason coverage remain explicit.",
"Later independently reviewed compact Overview prioritizes genuine owner decisions and urgent hazards with safe existing quick actions, summary counts and explicit View all Fleet handling destination/filter. Bounded previews retain every item and full evidence in dedicated queue/detail views; advisory/recheck counts are separate from actionable named-next-step counts. Preserve drafts, unsafe risks and show-all access. Owner9ab observed generated1440x1000 d469 desktop artifact, not actual live desktop/mobile acceptance; exact paths/scenarios/QA holdout and authorization precede later edits."
"Later independently reviewed compact Overview prioritizes genuine owner decisions and urgent hazards with safe existing quick actions, summary counts and explicit View all Fleet handling destination/filter. Bounded previews retain every item and full evidence in dedicated queue/detail views; advisory/recheck counts are separate from actionable named-next-step counts. Preserve drafts, unsafe risks and show-all access. Owner9ab observed generated1440x1000 d469 desktop artifact, not actual live desktop/mobile acceptance; exact paths/scenarios/QA holdout and authorization precede later edits.",
"Future reviewed message/thread UX supports version-pinned shared contract or artifact references with concise attributable recipient-specific decision/delta, exact permission provenance/current task revision and explicit supersession, retaining all recipients/history/failed decisions and full referenced content. Grouping never auto-acknowledges/resolves/discards messages or hides older failures; newest actionable decisions remain accessible. Pagination/unread completeness uses existing Kernel565/Runtimee440 identity-bound observation contract. Ownerd2feed aggregate115messages/275123bodybytes/22repeatedgroups-cover57 since16:00 is local traffic evidence, not provider token/cost data or proof multi-recipient copies are invalid."
],
"observedAt": "ff0712534829",
"feature": "Self-host development readiness",
@@ -93,14 +94,24 @@
"message:83cb229d-9d46-4cc2-ab38-7f0387792ec7:Kernel-displayonly-native-authority-exclusion-request",
"message:d1750568-6205-4bd6-912c-dd03dadf36ab:Console-fixed14allowlist-and-consumer-review-request",
"message:9adfc75d-69eb-4da3-b8bc-d081fcb1f63f:Release-exact-scope/hash/vector-corrections",
"message:02981960-924b-40ac-817f-6052adaeabc5:QA-exact-threepath/vector-scenario-request-after-existing-B1-review"
"message:02981960-924b-40ac-817f-6052adaeabc5:QA-exact-threepath/vector-scenario-request-after-existing-B1-review",
"message:8184bc03-40b8-431e-b7ec-86b3949148ff:actual-Release-threepath-eightscenario-contributor-consent",
"message:f0bad6b0-8769-420d-bc1e-3424f41770ef:usable-inventorylinktext-hash-vs-metadata/UIlink-refusal-addendum",
"message:15c48fa3-ec5d-4358-95e5-4356e125de26:owner-exact-threepath-Release-implementation-authorized-after-guardedconvergence-no-consumeredits",
"message:e7fa7fe6-0b2b-40e0-88a0-7699e5eb11ce:existing-Release-exact-authorization-handoff",
"message:1ece397d-ac61-4d5b-8500-4c26cf7ddc8b:concrete-Console-four-sitepath-Overview-vs-separate-snapshotconsumer-proposal",
"message:1b4836fd-2c3c-4983-957d-daf17cb0e45b:QA-newdensitytest/appendTIN-and-distinct-consumer-scope-decision-request",
"message:2cf2c03c-a290-42f8-91cb-5c5496fe37ba:readerModuleEvaluation-not-Consoleloadedengine-claim",
"message:d2feed55-f6dc-4c72-92c3-9b55a39af808:aggregate-local115messages275123bodybytes22repeatedgroups57messages-since16:00-not-providercost",
"message:a6b8dfa4-a8b4-43b9-908d-bc8d13f84e1f:usable-Overview-sixpath-five-strict-scenario-consent-crowded49plus17-density1440/390-not-sourceauthority",
"message:06f94f44-4789-47f9-a689-1c6b5c9429d6:actual-current-source-uniqueinfo/Work347baseline-preserve-no-duplicatefix-browser-disconnected-Releaseactive"
],
"commit": "e8c4c4249e49d91393394ac205d918826ddd1891",
"integrationRequest": "6cbac9cb-445f-45d7-8bb1-10902e840211",
"blockedReason": "Exact e8c source QA acceptance and native6cb serialized landing remain RESOLVED with four native PASS/11 hashes. Attention cohort exact4fa is independently QA accepted and natively landed once0d46; canonical4fa is clean as observed16:27, not whole-workflow acceptance. Actualownereb1 live4174 eight blocked entries omit blockedReason: activealpha2 and immutablealpha3 omit a field already present canonical316. Served UI/APIengine exact version/artifact/source provenance must be distinct from repositoryHEAD and truthful for mixed/stale/unknown state; alpha3switch75 alone cannot qualify current UI. Full workflow remains blocked on later qualified current release and actual live/installed/desktop/mobile owner-flow/full-criteria acceptance; current owner browser list remains empty. Source/demo artifact PASS is not live acceptance. Human75 remains pending revision1; PNG recovery is not activation. No install/restart/hotpatch/host/provider/wake/schema action.",
"createdAt": "2026-09-30T19:30:23.720Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T16:38:00.000Z",
"revision": 19,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z",
"revision": 21,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -234,6 +245,20 @@
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T16:38:00.000Z",
"note": "Metadata-only expectedrev18 records complete actual Release5d377 proposal/vector addendum and owner ee430 precise scope/spec corrections. Future exact contribution only new src/self-host/runtime-metadata.mjs, new QA-owned test/fleet/runtime-metadata.test.mjs, append-only docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md; excludes proposed test/fleet/TIN. Preserve actual candidate recursive per-directory localeCompare inventory traversal and raw hash preimage, any.git/rootvalidation exclusions; independent nested/case/punctuation vectors reject changed ordering. Full contract forwarded existing QA/Kernel/Console with no code authority/new task/assignment. Useful observations separate authentication unknown, no native E/S/A/memory/deliveredbyte claim, no DB/status/reconcile. All state/owner/e8/request/sevencriteria/history retained."
},
{
"from": "blocked",
"to": "blocked",
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z",
"note": "Metadata-only expectedrev19. Actual QA818/f0bad resolves Release contributor/link precision; actual owner15c48 grants bounded named Release implementation on SAMEworkflow, not fullowner transfer/lifecycle/new assignment or consumer edits. Preserve blocked state/e8 request/fullcriteria/history and actual live/API/browser gaps. Record concrete Console separate Overview/consumer scopes and ownerd2feed message UX requirement; existing roadmap only, no source/schema permission or summary replacing attributable authority."
},
{
"from": "blocked",
"to": "blocked",
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T17:07:00.000Z",
"note": "Metadata-only actualQAa6b usable exact Overview four-sitepath/newdensitytest/appendTIN consent resolves routine contributor hold; five strict scenarios/crowded49+17/density1440x1000/390x844 preserve Work347 baseline and existing Fleet3/runtime.review/kernel.info/qa.urgent. Owner06 confirms unique-info already implemented, no duplicate fix/test relaxation. Later exact arbiter source scope separate; no implementation authority/newassignment/state/sourcecommit change. Actual browser disconnected/full liveacceptance remains open; separate Release implementation active."
}
]
}
@@ -19,7 +19,8 @@
"Exact clean candidate checks, independent QA acceptance and guarded serialized integration are required; no fixture-only output, omitted unread filter or acknowledgement counts substitute for real current evidence.",
"Before publishing a final blocked/waiting-on-approval/needs-owner report, refresh authoritative unread inbox, current named permission and task evidence; distinguish a timestamped earlier observation from current state and reconcile already-resolved routine waits without asking the owner again. A mechanical observation-watermark/status protocol, if needed, requires an owned reviewed proposal before schema/API implementation.",
"Before a failed-check repair/check iteration, refresh the current authoritative brief, actual addressed unread inbox, current task and named consent revisions; apply already-resolved peer direction before further edits or checks. A pending wheel/rAF/scrollend stimulus or an acknowledged historical handoff cannot substitute for current instructions, justify trial timing patches, weakened assertions, duplicate dispatch or a missing-owner-permission claim. Preserve strict behavior, failed receipts and attributable historical evidence; any new mechanical refresh/status protocol needs separately reviewed owned scope.",
"Before classifying a same-task contribution as duplicate, completed or waiting, refresh the actual addressed unread inbox and compare the exact named current handoff, candidate and requested scope with superseded/completed contributions, even when the task revision is unchanged. Startup/resume UX must distinguish a stale orchestration hint from a pending current contribution and show its provenance; a reused followup flag or terminal old contribution cannot close a new handoff. Any mechanical handoff/version/status schema or activation change remains a separately reviewed owned proposal."
"Before classifying a same-task contribution as duplicate, completed or waiting, refresh the actual addressed unread inbox and compare the exact named current handoff, candidate and requested scope with superseded/completed contributions, even when the task revision is unchanged. Startup/resume UX must distinguish a stale orchestration hint from a pending current contribution and show its provenance; a reused followup flag or terminal old contribution cannot close a new handoff. Any mechanical handoff/version/status schema or activation change remains a separately reviewed owned proposal.",
"Future reviewed coordination-message reference/pagination UX keeps immutable version-pinned full contracts accessible while returning concise attributable recipient-specific current decision/delta with explicit supersession and exact permission/task revision. Newest actionable decisions are not obscured by repeated long contracts; all recipients, unacknowledged pages, older failed decisions and identity-bound complete/truncated observation remain intact through Kernel565. No summary, repeated-body cohort, read/ack count or historical page can imply resolution, complete unread coverage or transferred approval. Local aggregate traffic is not provider cost/token evidence; this is a requirement only, no new API/schema/code scope."
],
"observedAt": "0fdfcb3b68e4511f2993d03e1fff8f89124b731c",
"feature": "Identity-bound inbox selection and observation integrity",
@@ -36,14 +37,15 @@
"message:22df881a-9d38-4706-b0bf-da05c6b674c8:Console12:22-stale-QA-wait-after12:19-consent",
"message:c9bd14d0-f006-4b65-9f4e-54c77c58cb42:failed-check-recovery-current-brief-unread-consent-refresh-boundary",
"receipt:8ac4a6ab-99b9-4fa5-a941-eac1d03842ba:a7e84cf:fail507-vs327-after-resolved-QA8009-numeric-stimulus",
"message:7a6eb8ca-bc61-4b1e-860b-d4f87f521855:reused-arbiter-followup-flag-obscured-new-Work2f8-Manager5ab-attempt-store-contribution"
"message:7a6eb8ca-bc61-4b1e-860b-d4f87f521855:reused-arbiter-followup-flag-obscured-new-Work2f8-Manager5ab-attempt-store-contribution",
"message:d2feed55-f6dc-4c72-92c3-9b55a39af808:measured-115messages275123bytes22repeatgroups57messages-reference/pagination-UX-requirement-no-autoack"
],
"commit": null,
"integrationRequest": null,
"blockedReason": null,
"createdAt": "2026-10-01T10:32:53.996Z",
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T13:28:26.706Z",
"revision": 6,
"updatedAt": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z",
"revision": 7,
"history": [
{
"from": null,
@@ -86,6 +88,13 @@
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T13:28:26.706Z",
"note": "Owner 7a6eb8ca explicitly requests existing stale-brief/task-startup UX recording of exact named current handoff versus superseded/completed/pending contribution, including shared arbiter orchestration incident. Reviewed metadata-only amendment, expected revision5. Preserve owner/state/candidate/dependencies, eight prior criteria and full history. Native service has no metadata-amend operation; no lifecycle transition, new task/assignment, API/status/schema implementation, provider launch or acceptance."
},
{
"from": "assigned",
"to": "assigned",
"actorId": "session-manager",
"at": "2026-10-01T17:03:00.000Z",
"note": "Reviewed metadata-only expectedrev6 at explicit ownerd2feed existing inbox/coordination requirement. Runtime retains assigned e440/no candidate and Kernel565 blocked source/native history; append one strict sharedreference/supersession/pagination requirement/evidence preserving ninecriteria/fullhistory. No second assignment,new backlog,providerstart,API/schema/code permission,autoack or fabricated token/cost measurement."
}
]
}
@@ -1,5 +1,102 @@
# Current pilot remaining-work handoff
## Actual usable Overview consent and current browser boundary, 17:07 UTC
Actual **QAa6b8dfa4** grants named Console contribution on four site paths plus
NEW density test and appenddocsTIN, preserving five strict priority/count/fullqueue/
draft/owner/nav scenarios and crowded49advisory+17Fleet geometry1440x1000/390x844.
Existing driver/fixtures/goldens/tests excluded, Work347 refresh and Fleet3/runtime.review/
kernel.info/qa.urgent unchanged. Owner06 confirms clean-unique worktree information
already exists in current source; do not implement a duplicate fix. Workflow21 and
attention20 record usable consent, not a source implementation decision or assignment.
Console receives exact decision; no stale QA wait. Separate Release contribution
is actually active per owner06, no consumer edits. User browser connection request
is already pending through arbiter; actual browser disconnected/liveDesktopMobile
unverified, not another user question here. Activation75 remains genuine human wait.
## Current B1 verdict, concrete B2 and authorized Release slice, 17:04 UTC
Fresh installed Manager brief **d7e6d69**, explicit addressed unread100 and all56
tasks refreshed; native check-in16:55 is observational, not proof of process absence.
Canonical remains clean **4fa9bd7d490fb740eb1d0bdf3dc9cafa2f309ba1**; its single
Console0d46 landing and arbiter development-ref push are resolved. cce still
needs_convergence, duplicatec532 ready/unauthorized and proposedc178 are preserved.
No new landing/request or task completion occurred.
Actual **QA a13b5c37** narrowly ACCEPTS B1 fixture-source exact clean
**955672c1db15ebde99788eaa87759b6020de5d25**:10 strict scenarios, c08 document prefix
156398 bytes unchanged, three B1 source/test blobs unchanged and exact TIN body
relocated to end. Manager observes clean exact955 with b375..955 docs-only delta.
Owner **29e80f3b** corrects earlier9982: initial child-git probe failed spawnSyncEPERM;
legitimate retry subsequently verifies prefix SHA5c595f1c and unchanged blobs.
Do not turn the earlier premature statement into PASS. Retain9b copy failure and
b375 placement rejection. SAME6e4 verification13, Work full owner, landed316/a178
and all seven native/operational criteria stay intact; B1 review is resolved, no
whole-branch/native/integration/full-task acceptance.
Concrete **B2a-d implementation packet** is pinned in the PhaseB report's17:02
section: Kernel no-args candidate-source-parent and explicit contextV2, Work new
bounded input-snapshot/source-execution/fence modules, then Kernel compatible
store/receipt-adapter and actual Work/Release consumers. Exact paths/quotas/interfaces,
positive real child input consumption after source mutation, snapshot UNKNOWN,
E/A substitution and real setsid/double-fork descendant fence scenarios are named.
Candidate fence backend is ephemeral PID namespace with fixed init lifetime,
subject to actual platform qualification; absent coverage yields no TerminalProof,
never PGID-only PASS or same-user containment claim. No platform activation or
registered DDL/code permission. Existing Work82157432/Kernel6797e181/QA239ebf46
receive concrete contributor/protocol/backend decisions, not a generic design loop.
Future native adapter must independently prove actual compatible schema/writer/
identity/CAS/receipt transport; legacy2 and required3/current2 refusal remain.
Fixtures/all-refusal are not permanent substitutes for the complete real path.
Actual **QA8184bc03** three-path/eight-scenario Release consent plus **f0bad6b0**
link addendum is now usable. Seven admitted immutablealpha3 internal .bin links
motivate hash-only inventory lstat/bounded readlink text with existing raw path/type/
mode/link-text preimage, no target-content traversal; relative internal existing
permitted entry only. External/absolute/dangling/invalid/oversize/special cases refuse
without partial match. Metadata and UI files remain no-follow regular-only; fixed
runtime/active is a separate bounded intentional link. readerModuleEvaluation does
not prove Console server bytes; authunknown and loaded-memory/delivery null remain.
Actual owner **15c48fa3** now authorizes named Release contribution on SAMEworkflow:
guarded clean convergence to4fa, ONLY NEW src/self-host/runtime-metadata.mjs, NEW
test/fleet/runtime-metadata.test.mjs, append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md, strict scenarios/
hash ordering/caps, clean task-named commit then four fresh exact native source
checks/immutable artifacts and independent QA before one guarded request. Manager
**e7fa7fe6** routes that exact authority. Arbiter manually resumes existing Release;
Manager starts none. Console retains full owner, workflow blocked20 for full live
criteria; no consumer edits or runtime75/host/schema authorization.
Actual Console **1ece397d** pins separate future Overview: four site paths
console.html/console.js/attention-projection.js/styles.css, NEW QA density test and
append TIN; owner/urgent first, exact actionable/advisory counts, bounded preview
and full Fleet filter/detail reachability preserving all records, ten destinations,
drafts/current preview/deep links/Back/Forward/mobile/unsafe hazards. Manager1b4836fd
requests exact QA additive consent before separate implementation decision.
Separate provenance consumer is snapshot.mjs no-args helper/display-only observeProject
object; server.mjs snapshot transport remains unchanged. Helper cannot authenticate
loaded API engine, and consumer needs distinct named QA scenario/path scope.
Existing attention blocked19/source4fa and workflow20 own these phases, not duplicates.
Owner **d2feed55** measures115 messages/275123 local body bytes since16:00,
max13362 bytes,11 bodies>8000,22 repeated groups covering57 messages. These are
aggregate local traffic, not provider token/cost measurement or invalid-copy proof.
Existing workflow20/Runtime e440 assigned7 record version-pinned full contract
references with concise recipient-specific decision/delta, explicit supersession
and current permission/revision; all recipient ownership/history/failed decisions
and unread/page completeness remain readable. Kernel565 remains blocked/native
unqualified. No autoack/close/discard or summary-as-permission behavior is authorized.
Evolution eight recurring boundaries and hierarchy ten signals favor precise
interfaces/reference process/scenario ownership among the existing six specialists,
over a new role, promotion, split or merge; no activation/proposal needed on current
evidence. Health49 stale observations/two resolved-dependency warnings remain surfaced
without auto-fix. Full56 roadmap:39 proposed,9 blocked,6 completed,1 Work verification,
1 Runtime assigned; no extra active assignment. Human approval75 remains pending1,
PNG recovery satisfied. Latest peer browser/live-installed-alpha2 evidence remains
unqualified; source4fa and an alpha3 switch do not prove blockedReason/live UI.
No peer source edits, DB/schema, installation, host/provider/wake or publication.
## Actual B1 QA verdict and exact corrective handoff, 16:39 UTC
Actual **QAc73fb0f6** narrowly REJECTS exactb375 only for TIN placement: the
@@ -10,6 +10,118 @@ no new assignment, identity, queue or full-task closure is requested here.
Current authoritative brief is d7e6d69. Kernel's proposed sections18/20 and
ADR026 at 6fdb88ea supply design context, not normative gate changes.
## Current B1 acceptance and concrete B2 implementation packet, 17:02 UTC
Actual QA **a13b5c37-12a3-4757-832c-1938b392f962** ACCEPTS only clean exact
**955672c1db15ebde99788eaa87759b6020de5d25** B1 fixture source:10/10 strict scenarios,
156398-byte c08 document prefix unchanged, three B1 source/test blobs unchanged,
allocation correction body unchanged and physically final. Preserve9b pre-copy
failure and b375 placement rejection. Owner29e verifies the prefix/blob proof only
after a legitimate retry of initial child-git spawnSync EPERM; the earlier9982
claim preceded completed verification and is not retrospective PASS evidence.
No native/whole-branch/integration/full-task acceptance follows. Full6e4 remains
Work-owned verification at landed316/a178; B1 acceptance closes this source review.
The following is a concrete proposed implementation packet on SAME task, with
named peer decisions requested82157432/6797e181/239ebf46. It grants no code authority.
It advances real composition; fixtures and blanket refusals are not the endpoint.
Each row requires exact contributor/scenario consent and separate arbiter scope
authorization. No new assignment, registered DDL or host activation is requested.
| Phase | Exact proposed source paths | Owner and deliverable | Exact proposed QA paths |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| B2a parent and input composition | NEW src/kernel/candidate-source-parent.mjs; additive explicitly V2 surface in src/kernel/check-subject-context.mjs; NEW src/checks/candidate-input-snapshot.mjs; NEW src/checks/candidate-source-execution.mjs | Kernel fixed no-args parent/binding; Work bounded file snapshot and real child consumption. Do not change existing fixtureV1 or existing CheckService/CLI consumers. | NEW test/fleet/candidate-source-parent.test.mjs; NEW test/fleet/candidate-input-consumption.test.mjs; additive V2-only cases in test/fleet/check-subject-context.test.mjs; append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md |
| B2b attributable terminal coverage | NEW src/checks/candidate-execution-fence.mjs; only its reviewed integration seam in new candidate-source-execution.mjs | Work fixed fence backend, parent-only observed exit/coverage proof and strict UNKNOWN handling. No resource/lease policy edits. | NEW test/fleet/candidate-execution-fence.test.mjs; append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md |
| B2c store/adapter and native transport | src/control-plane/candidate-attempt-store.mjs; src/control-plane/candidate-attempt-store-provisioner.mjs; NEW src/control-plane/check-receipt-adapter.mjs | Kernel exact versioned no-DDL finalizer/adapter and compatibility/provisioner qualification. B0 fixture issuance is not registered authority. | additive test/fleet/candidate-attempt-store.test.mjs; NEW test/fleet/check-receipt-adapter.test.mjs; append docs/TEST_INTEGRITY.md |
| B2d actual consumers and release qualification | later separately scoped src/checks/service.mjs, src/integration/service.mjs and src/cli.mjs | Work existing consumer/gate semantics; Release fixed CLI-to-parent binding, only after actual compatible native transport proves exact receipts. | QA independently pins actual service/CLI/integration scenarios before any edits |
Ownership queries confirm Kernel src/kernel/** and src/control-plane/**, Work
src/checks/**, Console src/observability/**/src/console/**, QA test/**. The specific
future check-receipt-adapter name preserves the existing reviewed map, not the
alternative candidate-receipt-adapter sketch. Existing files outside the listed
later rows remain excluded; no implicit permission to wire a consumer.
B2a contract to pin before source: openCandidateSourceParentV1() has zero caller
arguments; derives its fixed installed module and actual startup working directory,
validates install/project/managed common-dir/registered branch/clean source, and
retains opaque parent state. A registered identity issuer must be an actual reviewed
bound native seam; branch labels, caller JSON, private WeakMaps and same-user access
are not authentication. CanonicalCheckSubjectEsaBytesV2 or explicitly named successor
binds E interface/module plus fixed entry and dependency-manifest length/SHA; A
declaration bytes/schema/interface plus actual adapter entry/dependency length/SHA;
S project/commit/clean tree, snapshot-policy and frozen-manifest digests, total input
bytes/count. Inputs include definition/args/allowlisted env and run/guard generations
at admission. private inputRoot never crosses caller serialization. Pre/post fixed
E/A reads detect substitution; disk re-read is not loaded-memory attestation.
Work's snapshot is a NEW bounded stream/copy seam, not a declaration that existing
snapshot.mjs or PhaseA input.directory is qualified. Proposed concrete maxima to
ratify:8192 input records,64MiB per regular file,512MiB aggregate,4096 UTF8 path bytes,
1MiB descriptor/manifest frame. Enforce original lengths/counters before allocation,
no symlink/special/traversal, owned unique scratch outside source, explicit canonical
relative-path/byte/mode records and policy-version digest. Streaming copies and
pre/post source/frozen manifests detect drift; they do not prove an atomic directory
snapshot or same-user filesystem containment. Worker cwd is ONLY private snapshot
inputRoot, never caller input.directory. Fixed trusted command/dependencies come
from reviewed parent E binding; candidate child receives no writer/DB/adapter token.
Do not reuse copied-byte descriptor truth as proof that real files were consumed.
B2b backend decision must cover escaped sessions/descendants. A proposed concrete
candidate is an ephemeral Linux PID namespace with fixed reviewed namespace-init
wrapper lifetime: every descendant stays in that namespace, init termination ends
its population; parent holds namespace identity/generation and observes closure.
This mechanism must first be supported and independently qualified in the approved
execution environment, with bounded output/time/signal cancellation; no host-service,
cgroup/timer setup or provider launch is authorized. Work must accept this backend
or name a precise already available enforceable alternative and ownership. No
fallback to process-group emptiness, kill-command exit, process name or fake fence.
If namespace creation/coverage/lifetime is denied or unknown, return UNKNOWN with
no TerminalProof/PASS and retain attributable run evidence. This is descendant
lifetime coverage, not protection from a malicious same-user outside process.
Positive black-box scenarios, not only forged-input refusal:
1. Actual child reads known captured files via relative paths from snapshot cwd and
emits their contents/digest. Alter original worktree after capture via deterministic
barrier; child still emits original captured bytes. Include nested files and a
file larger than1MiB so descriptor size cannot substitute for product consumption.
2. Alter frozen snapshot before or during execution: manifest verification yields
UNKNOWN/refusal and no eligible result/receipt; no source-policy relaxation.
3. Fixed parent captures E/A, then same-ID entry/dependency bytes change before import
or after execution: substitution refuses. Positive unchanged pre/post tuple passes
context admission only with an actual issued binding; JSON/spread clones do not.
4. Real child creates a setsid/double-fork descendant that waits beyond its direct
parent's exit. Supported fence observes containment/termination; parent cannot
finalize while coverage is open. Unknown coverage and PGID-only fake each refuse.
5. Known-good confined run with unchanged files and sealed artifact produces one
attributable terminal proof. Timeout/signal/error/ENOBUFS/overflow, zero-exit drift,
stale generation and cancellation ambiguity cannot yield eligible PASS.
6. Actual supported adapter on exact compatible schema/tuple finalizes one sealed
attempt/result/eligible receipt atomically; duplicate/replay and interrupted CAS
preserve history without second receipt or ambiguous retry. Wrong adapter/schema
and fixture authority refuse. Fixture positive transaction is separately labelled.
B2c has additional executable prerequisites, not a prose waiver: exact DDL bytes
and canonical semantic schema digest; compatible existing receipt-table/writer
matrix; authenticated native identity/attempt transport; issued->executing->sealed
->finalized CAS; result and eligible receipt in one short transaction; ambiguous
commit/read-only reconcile policy; writer/lease/fence generation evidence. Inspect
and independently qualify actual compatible registered adapter state without
opening a migrating initializer. Current required3/schema2 refusal remains intact;
any missing registered store or DDL recovery is a separate genuine decision with
exact state/risk evidence. Never copy fixture receipts, assume old installed engine
equivalence or alter exactPasses to land. Native receipts can qualify an unlanded
clean candidate only through that supported protocol; post-landing-only receipts
would recreate the circular gate. Full four exact source checks/current definitions,
immutable artifacts, independent QA and native serialized landing remain required.
Immediate peer decisions are concrete: Work ratifies snapshot/execution APIs,
quotas and one supported fence backend; Kernel pins V2 bytes and real bound issuer/
adapter transport compatibility; QA grants exact listed test/contribution scopes
and positive barrier/descendant/CAS scenarios; Release pins later fixed parent CLI
invocation. Source code remains unauthorized pending those decisions and the
arbiter's bounded scope choice. This packet retains the complete real native path.
## Actual B1 four-path authorization and real composition roadmap, 16:29 UTC
Latest16:39 **QAc73fb0f6** REJECTS b375 narrowly for append-only TIN placement: